5 ms·
How does Uber hurt trust?
by jessriedel 11y ago
How does Uber hurt trust?
- TeMPOraL 11y agoUber's business model is based on throwing VC money at lawyers that can keep local administration at bay and let them freely ignore the law. Meanwhile, they try to paint themselves as a white knight going against the Evil Taxi Mafia. It erodes trust people have in the rule of law. I agree my comment above doesn't fit Uber in such obvious way as it fits AirBnB, but Uber is actually sociopathic in its DNA, starting from top-level management[0]. A lot of things they did and do were based on abuse of trust and civility. [0] - Source: scroll down to the bottom of this page, enter "Uber" in the search bar, and browse through relevant submissions from the last two years; we've covered all the antisocial behaviour of Uber and its management here, on HN.
- Balgair 11y agoCome on, you got to give a better source than that. If you tell us to basically google it, that's not a source, that's an assignment. Nor is telling us that a comment is a source. You have to give us at least an article or link to even pretend you are sourcing something.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoI'm not asking to Google it, I'm asking to type it into the Hacker News search bar, which fetches the results from this site, and sorting them by popularity. Me giving a list would amount to just copy-pasting headings from those results. But ok, random issues from the top of my head: - sabotaging competition, hiring people to do this, facilitating mass cancellation of rides by providing them with burner iPhones and credit cards - blatantly breaking local taxi regulations - employee/contractor issues and related tax issues - Uber management declaring they'll set up a fund to ruin a journalist's life because the latter dared to voice criticism about the company - God's Eye view and privacy issues - encouraging drivers without proper insurance - tricking drivers into (and helping them) getting loans for a new car, and then (after a year or two) adjusting payment rates so that they basically stay locked in Uber All of them discussed at length on HN, most of them covered on the first page of search results.
- Balgair 11y agoThen link to them! copypasting the results, though easy to search, is just as easy for you to do too. Save the reader the effort. The web is a god-send because of links and that ease of info transfer. This is not print where I know I have to look it up.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- baddox 11y ago> It erodes trust people have in the rule of law. By showing that some laws are bad? What's wrong with that? I don't think people should have trust in the rule of law.
- TeMPOraL 11y ago> By showing that some laws are bad? No. By showing that through breaking them, having enough resources to keep the government at bay. They provide a good service and throw a lot of freebies initially to convince people they're cool, and then when people learn that their local administration is trying to ban/fine Uber, citizens are upset at the officials. Meanwhile taxi drivers ask themselves, why should they follow the law if Uber doesn't have to, and the whole startup ecosystem is looking at Uber as an example of perfect company and trying to replicate their methods. I don't know about you, but I don't want to see breaking the law as the modus operandi of startups in the future. > I don't think people should have trust in the rule of law. In other words, let's just give up on the whole "civilization" thingie, pack our bags and go back to the caves we came from.
- baddox 11y ago> No. By showing that through breaking them, having enough resources to keep the government at bay. I don't think that's bad. I think deliberately breaking bad laws is a reasonable and effective means to get rid of bad laws. > Meanwhile taxi drivers ask themselves, why should they follow the law if Uber doesn't have to, and the whole startup ecosystem is looking at Uber as an example of perfect company and trying to replicate their methods. I think taxi drivers should ask themselves that, even before Uber and its kind existed. > I don't know about you, but I don't want to see breaking the law as the modus operandi of startups in the future. I don't have a problem with it if I don't like the laws that are being broken. > In other words, let's just give up on the whole "civilization" thingie, pack our bags and go back to the caves we came from. Following all laws regardless of their merits is hardly the defining characteristics of civilization.
- TeMPOraL 11y ago
- Thriptic 11y ago> Uber's business model is based on throwing VC money at lawyers that can keep local administration at bay and let them freely ignore the law. Meanwhile, they try to paint themselves as a white knight going against the Evil Taxi Mafia. It erodes trust people have in the rule of law. That's fair, but if there was trust in local government and it was doing its job well then there wouldn't be such overwhelming popular support for Uber to begin with. Many licensed taxi services allowed by local governments provide terrible service, and local governments frequently show no interest in improving quality or lowering barriers to entry for new competition as long as they are collecting large amounts of money from medallion sales. This is people voting with their wallets and telling government they don't like the ramifications of existing regulations.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoI agree. Of course the issue isn't binary, it's additive. Uber is just one of the many forces that are now destabilizing the relationship between people and the government (many of them are of government's own doing). But just because the house is already on fire, doesn't mean you should be free to pour gasoline into it. The thing is, Uber isn't even really innovative. In Europe, we had a (arguably slow-going) process of reforming taxi laws going on for years. There were transportation upstarts that tackled taxi regulations through legal channels and in many places, my own country included, they managed to keep themselves on the market. Whatever tension there was between them and taxi companies got resolved in courts, regulations were updated and everyone was better off. But then Uber came and basically said, "fuck regulations, we have money to burn, what you're going to do?".