5 ms·
A while ago, I said something like "the elites have totally won the battle against the slave class (formally known as the middle class)" to a friend and he was
by mark_l_watson 11y ago
A while ago, I said something like "the elites have totally won the battle against the slave class (formally known as the middle class)" to a friend and he was shocked that I felt that way. I was half way joking but the more I think about it the more I think that it is game over for the non-elites, except for a few things that people can do:
1. Pay a lot of attention to your own job skills and education, managing career, etc.
2. Put a lot of energy into maintaining your economic outlook, that of your family and friends, and that of your local community
3. Ignore crap like the show of elections, and the show of "news" in general. If you want to do something positive then pick a cause, like a constitutional amendment to overthrow the Citizen's United ruling, and work on that cause year after year. Time better spent.
- onion2k 11y agoIt's never been "game over" in the past. History has shown that oppression of the masses is usually the forerunner to a revolution. Why would be any different this time around? (I'm not advocating revolt as a solution; just questioning the validity of the idea that the 'slave class' have no way to change things.)
- yesco 11y agoPeople really harp off about 1984 a lot when speaking about surveillance but they always seem to leave out what I considered the most disturbing part of the book. The government in the story was very aware that they were following a pattern that would lead to a revolution. So they created a system where revolution was impossible. 1984 like most science fiction, was created to show an extreme. While there is no such thing as an unbeatable system, there is definitely people higher up aware of the possibility and actively preventing any major paradigm shifts in politics. The only thing that would truly force a revolution (which doesn't even have to be violent) is if people don't have enough food or their life is on the line. We saw this in the Arab Spring with the rise in wheat prices, which Saudi Arabia was able to avoid through subsidies.
- JustSomeNobody 11y agoBecause this time the government has large bombs.
- tootie 11y agoHistory has shown no such thing. Slave revolts almost always failed. Popular revolts almost always failed. They also happened very rarely. Most empires fell from the outside, not the inside. Also, America and Canada and the rest of the developed world in 2015 are freer and more prosperous than any time in history. We'd be setting a ludicrously low bar for revolt if copyright is what pushes us over the edge.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- bufordsharkley 11y agoIt's the classic problem in a democracy, that a minority with a vested interest (here, the rent-collectors on copyrighted material) are far more likely to effect what they want than a majority who, by and large, doesn't care that much. I think the key here is simplifying things-- the public domain isn't going to afford the lobbying power as the rent-collectors, but we can at least try to simplify the message, that rent-collecting is harmful.