6 ms·
What Open-Access Publishing Actually Costs
- PaulHoule 11y agoIt depend what services you want. I was involved with arXiv.org and we estimated costs somewhere around $5 a paper, however we were not doing any typesetting (mostly we got submissions in TeX) and no peer review. It may sound blasphemous, but it is not clear how much value you really get out of peer review. One key is that arXiv was running on a very large scale, if you are considering the cost of the programmers, hardware and such, it is just as expensive to run a small "journal" as it is a large one. The reason I don't work there anymore has to do with the extreme difficulty we had in finding that $5 a paper. After years they've finally been able to get other academic institutions to put some chips in the pot, but it seems to me that it is much easier to find money for a boondoggle than it is for a lean operation.
- fdej 11y agoIt seems to me that all we really need is a way to attach reviews/endorsements to papers already posted on the arxiv. Tim Gowers's initiative is a good start, but with just one specific overlay journal, a tiny one.
- ISL 11y agoYep. That's the future. The crux is figuring out how retain the good aspects of the existing system (well-considered and appropriate peer review, approximate ranking by importance) and getting enough traction to allow it to take off.
- PaulHoule 11y agoIt is a tricky problem. For one thing there are a lot of people who are not qualified to have an opinion who would like to chime in on the topic and in certain fields (say gravity) they outnumber the real researchers. Some of these people are clearly psychotic but some of them will put up an huge fight, in the courts even, and other people are marginal cases, right on the edge, where you will lose the moral battle if you keep them out. Another issue is that some senior (and junior) scientists tell it like it is (or rather how they think it is) and don't stop to think about the emotional impacts their words have on people, particularly when shared with the wider community. These people have valuable things to say, but they make mistakes like the rest of us, and the peer review process defuses much of the tension in this situation, although it too has the problem with tail cases with very high cost.
- kriro 11y agoHere's my naive view: 1) Upload PDF of a paper to a server 2) Reviewers get notified and do their thing 3) Paper is accepted and set to public (or rejected) Collecting related papers and typesetting them and whatnot should not be default but rather addons. All that matters is getting the paper, quality control and making it available. No need for set release dates and quarterly, just kanban it. As long as you have enough reviewers who are willing to do the work that should work. Optional: 4) Allow git style updates to the paper (author needs write access for this) 5) Comment system (potentially mark papers as "not so great after all, should not have made it through review")
- sre_ops 11y agoThere are very few things in common between the accepted manuscript that arrives at the publisher and the paper that you read which is why even society journals outsource paper processing to the likes of Informa and Elsevier
- exelius 11y agoA big part of "open access" is "accessibility" -- and a big part of accessibility is consistent formatting, typesetting, abstracts, etc. Without this, scientific papers become much harder to process electronically and turn into semi-structured data that is machine-readable. You need an organization to take stewardship of this process and escalate when the process breaks down, because all processes have escalations and exceptions. You also need a group capable of certifying experts in a field. In journals, this is done by the editor - who is usually an expert, or at least enough of an expert to know who the experts in a field are. What you described is basically Reddit -- and there's nothing wrong with Reddit, but I think it's a little unstructured for scientific discourse.
- xorcist 11y ago> Paper is accepted and set to public (or rejected) Is this even relevant post-scarcity? Just make everything available all the time, just like the rest of the web works. If it is obvious how many citations a paper have, and of their respective quality, that would carry over to make a quality index for the paper itself. Low quality papers would languish as only friends and family would bother with the.
- kragen 11y agoarXiv.org, which does just the publishing part of publishing — without the typesetting, lawsuits, sales staff, and political lobbying against freedom of speech — spends about US$1 million per year, with a staff similar in size to the Open Library for the Humanities, but more highly paid: https://confluence.cornell.edu/display/culpublic/arXiv+Sustainability+Initiative;jsessionid=3B375E7BFF6B88E48141AA7B29C46974?preview=/127116484/327622987/arXivCY15Midyear.pdf https://confluence.cornell.edu/display/culpublic/arXiv+Susta... I didn't say "without peer review" because, although the arXiv doesn't pay for peer review, traditional academic publishers don't pay for peer review either. Instead, scholars do the peer review for free, often as a favor to the journal editor (who may or may not be paid). They do have a moderator on contract for physics submissions to keep out the cranks. They currently get about eight or nine thousand submissions per month, all of which they publish: http://arxiv.org/stats/monthly_submissions http://arxiv.org/stats/monthly_submissions and about 12 million downloads per month http://arxiv.org/stats/monthly_downloads http://arxiv.org/stats/monthly_downloads. Reducing these figures to SI units, arXiv spends 32 millidollars per second, accepts submissions at 3.2 millihertz, and provides downloads at 4.6 Hz. If you impute their costs to the submissions, then they spend US$10 per submission. Definitely see PaulHoule's comment https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10539269 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10539269 about how they were struggling badly when they were trying to get by on half that. A couple of academic fields — notably math and physics — have switched almost entirely to arXiv. These are, perhaps not coincidentally, fields where the researchers already did most of their own typesetting. It's probably worthwhile to cost out how much it costs on the market to buy academic editing (in the traditional sense of fixing your prose so that other people can read it) and typesetting services. That information is not as easy to find because those services are not as standardized; the US$380 per paper given in this article is probably not too far off for typesetting, but I think editing can run somewhat higher, particularly for non-native speakers who have not yet reached a high level of competency.
- omginternets 11y agoAll I hear from academic publishers is "publishing costs money", but that's not the point, and they know it. The point is exactly threefold, and much simpler than even the simplest article they review: 1. It costs dramatically less to publish it used to. 2. Editors routinely offload expensive tasks to those submitting, i.e.: formatting figures and text, converting to publication-quality file formats, and in some cases even layout, to the point where we're not even sure what it is they do anymore. 3. Most research is publicly funded. It seems ethically wrong for there to be paywalls, especially considering the hefty price-tag associated with submitting an article in the first place. Editors: we're academics, not idiots. Please respond to our actual goddamn points.
- ISL 11y agoEditing, in the journal sense of the word (finding good referees, hounding them to get reports back, responding to authors, evaluating revisions, etc.) takes a lot of work and time. I wouldn't be willing to do an editor's job for free (unless underwritten by another employer, as I am for peer review), and I wouldn't expect anyone else to do so either. Publishing costs are far, far lower than they used to be, but good proofreading and style-guide checking still takes time too.
- x1798DE 11y agoMaybe it's because I'm a native English speaker with strong writing skills, but I don't think any actual editing of the text has taken place on the journal's side on any paper I've ever been on. Usually the co-authors do this in several rounds before submission.
- ISL 11y agoIt's common for major physics journals to copy-edit before publication. The APS journals and the Review of Scientific Instruments both do it. Sometimes they'll catch a subtle error, sometimes they make edits to bring the document into compliance with their own style guide, and occasionally they'll introduce an error. On balance, they make the publication much stronger and more consistent. I've gotten nice PDFs that highlight the diffs and any questions/concerns they may have.
- cubano 11y ago> Eventually, the publisher won’t need a programmer... Yes, they will need 5 ;)
- dougmccune 11y agoThe biggest thing I object to in this article is the following quote from Michael Eisen (one of the PLOS founders): "The costs are largely the same between open-access journals and non-open-access journals," said Michael Eisen, a co-founder of the open-access project PLOS. "We’re doing essentially the same thing as traditional publishers." The type of peer review that megajournals (like PLOS One) do is categorically different than a lot of traditional journals. A megajournal will typically review for scientific soundness only. If the methodology is sound then the paper should be accepted regardless of whether it breaks new ground in the field or is seen as important. This is not the same kind of peer review that you will find when submitting to Nature, where they are trying to curate for importance in addition to vet for soundness. I won't argue one way or the other about whether one type of peer review is better than the other, there are arguments to be made on all sides. But they are not the same, and they do not cost the same amount. Methodological peer review is cheaper. That's why the megajournals like PLOS One, et al do it that way (well, it's one of the reasons, the other main one being a philosophical reason). You could not run the big OA operations at their price points with traditional peer review. Their revenue is purely driven by acceptance volume, and so therefore anything that slows down peer review or rejects too many papers has a serious material impact on revenue. It's a balancing act between ensuring you don't accept quack science accidentally but don't reject too much than you have to.
- dumbmatter 11y agoPLOS ONE is only one of many PLOS journals. The others do also review for importance. This is probably why PLOS ONE is cheaper than their other journals: http://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/publication-fees http://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/publication-fees So Eisen is correct, it's the same thing. A non-open access publisher could make a non-open access equivalent of PLOS ONE if they wanted to (and maybe somebody has). It's not a question of open access.
- dougmccune 11y agoI agree that OA vs non OA isn't the argument, and that there are examples of OA journals with a particular focus on "impact", like eLife. My point is really about megajournal-style peer review vs traditional peer review. But in the press these two things get conflated, and when referencing how cheap publishing should be people always quote the lower price of megajournal APCs and not the higher price of traditionally peer reviewed journal APCs. But it is worth noting that a move to APCs dramatically changes the incentive structure for a publisher, and there are built-in mechanisms in such a system to produce new strange dynamics that we haven't really seen much of before (ie the tension between needing to accept a certain volume to stay in business vs try to keep the reputation of the journal high).
- jmount 11y agoI found an example of a Wiley journal that claims to be "open access." But you dig around it is really "pay to place". Example: http://www.win-vector.com/blog/2015/11/fast-food-fast-publication/ http://www.win-vector.com/blog/2015/11/fast-food-fast-public...
- hackuser 11y agoThe focus on costs as business expenses overlooks the primary problem with non-free journals: It limits the dissemination of knowledge - the primary reason for publishing - to the few who can pay. Currently, independent scholars or intellectual members of the public who want to learn something have very limited access to this knowledge. AFAIK, you need to go to a library to access it - you can't even join a library and get remote access to their computers. That means all the well-researched, expert knowledge in those journals is replaced with whatever is found on the Internet. How will the next brilliant patent clerk participate and make her/his contribution? (If anyone knows a way to access JSTOR without enrolling in a university or going on-site to a university library, I'd love to know.)