5 ms·
That point is so important that I hesitated to add a distraction but I think it's also worth remembering that the NSA has a defensive role, too. It's been much
by acdha 11y ago
That point is so important that I hesitated to add a distraction but I think it's also worth remembering that the NSA has a defensive role, too.
It's been much neglected in recent decades but the entire country would be better off if the NSA helped patch things. They're hoping some suspected bad guy doesn't get patched but odds are high that many Americans, particularly important IP-heavy businesses, are going to get exploited as well — and given all the reports about how e.g. bin Laden preferred to send messages using trusted couriers, that trade off doesn't seem very good.
- ethanbond 11y agoWhy do you think the two are mutually exclusive? I was under the impression that the NSA publishes security advisories all the time?
- gkop 11y agoAt least one issue is perception of the NSA by the talented people that the NSA needs to recruit. At the time I graduated CS undergrad in 2010, the NSA was still seen as "Sketchy, but good (and reliable) on the balance." Post-Snowden, views have changed. If the NSA can't do a better job of public relations, nobody is going to want to work for them, and then this defensive work won't be done as well.
- Mtinie 11y agoConscription neatly solves that problem... Given the proper motivation (neé, "a carrot-shaped stick"), a potential prospect will be inclined to accept the offer of employment.
- ionised 11y agoForcing people to work for you is a surefire way to ensure they do a terrible or half-arsed job. Worse, they may even actively do a bad job in the hope of doing damage. Plus, the whole idea of conscription is absurd.
- Mtinie 11y agoApparently I needed to include a "/s" on my comment. No, conscription is most assuredly not the answer :)
- hibikir 11y agoFor the most part, any party the NSA might be interested into is going to be running an OS and an application suite that will also be used by Americans a whole lot. Probably even other government agencies. So, every zero day they find and weaponize, is a zero day that they don't tell the vendor about. So to be able to be aggressive with exploits, they have to leave American computers exposed too, and hope nobody else has found the exploit. So even with the same budget looking for vulnerabilities, doing the right thing for one of their roles makes them worse for the other. It's a bit like the encryption problem: An encryption system with a backdoor that the NSA has weakens American security too, because the backdoor itself is a valid intelligence target: Infiltrate the NSA, take the backdoor key, and anything the NSA can snoop into, someone else can too. So doing both defense and offense without major tradeoffs requires having some kind of edge that nobody else can ever have: For instance, the rumored gigantic cluster that can crack specific SSH communications, which they expect nobody else to be able to replicate, just due to the cost of the hardware. That's a far more limited offense than what we know the NSA had at the time of the Snowden leaks. So my guess, based on public information, is that they do trade-offs, and disclose the issues that they think are easier to find, while keeping around enough ammunition to have something against pretty much every target.
- SamReidHughes 11y agoOkay, so let's say American businesses can't get hacked so easily by nationstates and have their secrets stolen. Also, Iran has successfully tested a nuclear bomb. Is that the world you'd prefer?
- Ar-Curunir 11y agoThis is such a laughably typical strawman excuse that is used to shut down all discussion on this topic.
- SamReidHughes 11y agoTypical of what? Obviosity? We've got a poster here claiming that business are "going to" get exploited, and in the meantime, non-theoretically (consider reading the Wikipedia [1] article on "strawman"), the U.S. Govt is making productive use of exploits today. You're the one trying to shut down discussion. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia
- iammaxus 11y agoI believe the parent may have been referring to Stuxnet. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stuxnet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stuxnet It is indeed possible that if the NSA used a very different strategy with vulnerabilities, Iran might be further along with its nuclear weapons development.
- nitrogen 11y agoIran was using out of date software and hardware IIRC, so Stuxnet would still have been possible.
- fineman 11y agoStuxnet will always be possible. The vulns/trojans just replace having to get someone to knowingly install it. Or rather, will always be possible until we move to doing protocol and behavior analysis of SCADA commands (as they enter the machine). And that'll just mean it has to get more subtle. If there's a way to do it right, there're more ways to do it wrong.
- peteretep 11y agoAre you seriously suggesting you don't think the security services have decades of experience in weighing the pros and cons of information release?
- frozenport 11y agoWhats good for one agency may be bad for another, for example the State Department might like Tor because it facilitates anonymous informants while the NSA might not like it because they can't read your email. I am not even sure if the NSA's mission extends to defending civilians.
- techdragon 11y agoTheir history has shown a trend toward less and less disclosure over time. Each successive "war" takes longer and longer for things to be declassified. I've got extremely detailed material in my library published within years of the end of WW1 the sorts of detail I honestly never expect to see again. The long cold war "taught" them to not trust the public, and the global media environment and the Internet only multiply their concerns. Even if they have reasons to release... Those are increasingly washed away by their fear. We the public grow to accept "infinite secrecy" inch by inch, it's the Overton Window and sadly it works.
- peteretep 11y agoEach war has an increasing media presence, did you really not notice that?
- akshatpradhan 11y agoThe NSA knows little about defense. They keep saying Defense in Depth but even they don't know what that means. Its Security Compliance guys! Defense in depth (Castle Approach) is Security Compliance because the Security Controls are defined in ISO 27002, FEDRAMP, CCM!