3 ms·
REST-RPC is obviously possible, but would be additional stuff on top of REST, and... I guarantee you that REST advocates would flip out. By and large they think
by jerf 17y ago
REST-RPC is obviously possible, but would be additional stuff on top of REST, and... I guarantee you that REST advocates would flip out. By and large they think that having things that don't cleanly map down to RPC is a benefit; they would object that a function call lacks the richness to fully represent the results of a REST invocation: Did you get a cached value back? Can you get to the HTTP headers? Can you set cache header on the request itself, or other HTTP headers? And there's a lot of truth here. Basically, REST-RPC would be "an RPC mechanism built on top of REST", but would not be "REST that is also RPC"; REST-RPC must necessarily be at least one of "a significantly limited subset of REST" or "more complicated than a simple function call".
Despite the fact I'm not willing to write off XML-RPC as absolutely useless as I believe there are times for simplicity, I also tend to agree that for industrial strength purposes RPC is a bad metaphor and you basically lose if you try to use RPC. It's just that I don't think REST is the right direction; I head more in the direction of message passing, as laid out in
http://www.erlang.org/pipermail/erlang-questions/2008-May/035207.html http://www.erlang.org/pipermail/erlang-questions/2008-May/03...
And REST would agree with at least some of that; at least REST isn't hiding the fact that your function call is not local from you. But it falls afoul of many of the criticisms, too.