2 ms·
Makes me glad I am not a sociologist! The same basic problem occurs in all fields in that many reviewers and editors are basically idiots. When you get a rejec
by danieltillett 11y ago
Makes me glad I am not a sociologist!
The same basic problem occurs in all fields in that many reviewers and editors are basically idiots. When you get a rejection you look through the reviewers comments for the useful suggestions (mostly these are about spelling or grammar, but occasionally you will get a real gem) and send it out again. Whatever you do do not change the paper to suit the reviewers or editor. Just shoot it out again as quickly as possible.
- cmrivers 11y agoThis is a risky strategy - your paper can end up back in the hands of the same reviewers from round one.
- danieltillett 11y agoYes this can occur, but supringly rarely. What always amazes me is how rarely the reviewers ever agree on anything. Getting published is just a matter of sending out your work until you get two or three reviewers who say accept. I have had the situation where all three reviewers said publish and the editor rejected the paper - of course this paper has gone on to get over 600 citations so it was not the best decision that editor has ever made.