2 ms·
US has the most to lose from having the NSA hoard vulnerabilities in popular software that itself uses. So by that logic, the NSA is actually harming national s
by mtgx 11y ago
US has the most to lose from having the NSA hoard vulnerabilities in popular software that itself uses. So by that logic, the NSA is actually harming national security.
> Most users want the risk management paradigm where they buy insecure systems that are fast, pretty and cheap, then occasionally deal with a data loss or system fix
I disagree. I think most people don't know what the hell they want or need in terms on security, but they do want to be "safe". Nobody makes the choice "should I buy this phone for $600 or this one for $300 that is 10x less secure?" - People assume all of these devices have relatively the same security, and then they buy on price.
It's the job of system builders (and I think the government, too) to ensure people get a strong standard of security with their devices. Just like it's the government's job to ensure people don't get food poisoning from buying a random item from a store. You can't expect most people to actually know what they're buying in terms of food - but you expect them to know in terms of device security?
People think the $5 food item has the "same relative safety" as the $50 food item from the same category. Nobody expects to die from the $5 one, just like nobody expects to get hacked for buying a $100 unlocked phone at one of the four major (and let's say trusted) carriers. And by nobody I of course mean "normal people".
- nickpsecurity 11y ago"US has the most to lose from having the NSA hoard vulnerabilities in popular software that itself uses. So by that logic, the NSA is actually harming national security." I totally agree. I've said the same and gone as far to say they're "aiding and abetting" the enemy. Not Manning, Snowden, etc. ;) That said, NSA doesn't build these systems. NSA doesn't use insecure methods of software or system construction to keep their profit margin high on critical stuff. NSA... does... neglect contributions to critical protocols and stuff but so do everyone else. Most of the problems come from businesses, FOSS projects, and demand side all sticking with what produces the most 0-days. There's no excuse as even the first mainframe was doing it better back in 1963: http://www.smecc.org/The%20Architecture%20%20of%20the%20Burroughs%20B-5000.htm http://www.smecc.org/The%20Architecture%20%20of%20the%20Burr... Many did: https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2014/04/dan_geer_on_hea.html#c5598568 https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2014/04/dan_geer_on_h... It's just everyone's choice to stick with the most risky approaches and tradeoffs. What follows is a consequence of that choice. Even when shown better way, they usually tell you to get lost or further justify bad choices. So, it's totally on the market itself. NSA could help and DOD did back with Computer Security Initiative but hard for me to blame NSA for intentional failure and pervasive insecurity of most of 300+ million people and millions of businesses. They're just predators exploiting a bad situation created by others. "It's the job of system builders (and I think the government, too) to ensure people get a strong standard of security with their devices." Ever hear of DiamonTEK? Gemini Computers? Secure Computing Corporation? They did highly secure stuff. They disappeared, were acquired, or withered away (eg Aesec). That's a false claim disproven by decades of buyers and management ignoring good security advice. No, producers only goal it to satisfy buyers and make money. Doing so means trading against security. Time after time.