5 ms·
A woman rants about man bashy stuff written by “women in tech”
- timrpeterson 11y agoInteresting that this post received no comments. Self-fulfilling prophecy. Sad really.
- J_Darnley 11y ago1 - 25 minutes isn't very long to wait for comments but now that I look again I guess you mean on the post there. Though by my reckoning it hasn't been up 12 hours. 2 - Some people are psychotic so I'm not surprised people stay silent.
- kbart 11y agoIt's like playing with fire, that's why.
- Mz 11y agoIt actually already had more traffic and more upvotes than my posts usually get at the time you commented. I have posted enough stuff that made the front page (usually not my own writing) that I am well aware that 25 minutes in is too soon to jump to conclusions. Overall, I thought it went really well and I am quite pleased.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- LifeQuestioner 11y agoI can see a response article "Women rants about women ranting about women in tech. Look at that women who has nothing better to do. I have to spend 16 hours a day just to survive and shes just complaining about complaining". Where does it end? "From what I have experienced, it looks to me like an awful lot of men do not want to engage women professionally for fear that it will lead to scandal of some sort" - any comments from guys on this? Are you ever hesitant to engage out of fear of a scandal?
- HelloNurse 11y agoSeeing the USA tech sector from the very skewed point of view of Hacker News stories, I'm horrified by the apparent abundance of women like Ellen Pao or Julie Ann Horvath, or much worse, and by the terrifying threat they represent even for men who don't make the mistake of hiring them. It's like camping in a forest that is home to a man-eating tiger, completely unarmed. When hiring, or even contacting, a woman is more dangerous than a bad business decision, any uncomfortably immature and sexist "boys' club" becomes better, in all practical and moral senses, than attempting to be nice to predators and sociopaths and being punished for that. Socially responsible people would try to avoid driving the "enemy" into justified paranoia, because (as the linked article argues) everybody loses. I'm afraid there's not enough social pressure to behave normally.
- th0waway 11y agoYes. As a married, white, heterosexual male, being seen having a dinner alone with a single female (or even lunch) would be enough to cause questions from friends. So it's not worth it. And I'm no one, with no fame or high position.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Nadya 11y ago> any comments from guys on this? Are you ever hesitant to engage out of fear of a scandal? Yes. Absolutely yes. As far as I'm concerned my female coworkers don't exist. I think it is sad, but I'd rather treat them like ghosts than lose my job because one of them felt I looked at them funny or in the wrong way. Any meetings require a minimum of 3 people - I refuse to be alone in the same room because if it comes down to a he said/she said, she is the default. Same reason why male college professors avoid being alone with female students. It's absolutely stupid that I have to be a sexist asshole because my other option is to risk my job due to the very real possibility of fraudulent claims of being a sexist asshole. I suppose there is a bit of irony in there as well.
- bonobo3000 11y agoGreat post. I would just like to say that as an immigrant to the US, i see this tendency to turn every debate into "with us or against us" is much more prominent in the media here. I believe that most people across the world are reasonable enough to see the vast "grey areas" you mentioned between any two poles, but when we just read about an issue in passing, we tend to accept what we read so a media pushing dumb controversial articles can create this tendency. The renewed push for accepting women in the workplace is simply one instance where a (reasonable) position has been chosen (women should have all the same opportunities as men in the workplace), but anyone who speaks against this position (even if just to improve it, or learn more) is labeled a old-fashioned,bigoted, and much worse. The answer is to take a position without instantly shaming anyone who disagrees. So we can have an open discussion. The way controversial issues are treated here reminds me of medieval times - if you don't believe, you will be "excommunicated" from society. Debates aren't football games where you watch and cheer for your team to win. Right now, everyone is cheering for the womens side. Dont get me wrong, I am too, but that doesn't mean the other side is wrong/evil.
- gozo 11y agoI don't really see it. Yes, affluent people are the one that can afford to "whine". That's because you need a certain level of independence and education to be able to represent a position. Women have been "nice" throughout history. No one cared. Now they are outperforming men and the only reason we are talking about "sexism in tech" is because women are doing so well in many other fields. The whole premise of the post seem to be that women should know their place. A woman overreacting over being felt up is "whining", while men have been punching people in face over petty things for decade. Some men hesitate to work with women. So? Women didn't have it easy in the past. Now men share the world with women and those that can't work with them won't have many opportunities.
- Gigablah 11y ago> Women has been "nice" throughout history. No one cared. Really now?
- aianus 11y ago> Now they are outperforming men and the only reason we are talking about "sexism in tech" is because women are doing so well in many other fields. Name one where women are outperforming men at the top. I'm genuinely curious.
- programmernews3 11y agoVictimhood.
- huherto 11y agoThe title of woman of the year. Forget it. It seems like Caitlyn Jenner won it this year. http://dailycaller.com/2015/10/21/caitlyn-jenner-named-woman-of-the-year/ http://dailycaller.com/2015/10/21/caitlyn-jenner-named-woman...
- gozo 11y agoWhat makes you think that metric is even relevant? Since women haven't been competing with men on equal terms for long you have to look at fields and metrics were being young isn't a disadvantage. Taylor Swift had the most selling albums of 2014, Jennifer Lawrence was the top paid actor/actress under 30 the same year. Also many metrics relating to education, which if you really are curious can find yourself. Of course there will probably never be an outright dominance of women at the top of any field simply because of competition. But things are definitely going to change.
- 7Figures2Commas 11y ago> I wish women would make more of an effort to understand why men do what they do. Here is my general take on it... From the author's referenced post[1]: > My experience is that men are either not very willing to talk to me one-on-one or, if they are, talking shop is the last thing they had in mind. They are looking for romance, not looking to help me professionally. When I say this to other women, they generally express immediate agreement. Men often deny it, criticize it or just stop talking when I say such things. Most people are not attracted to most people. What this means is that most of the people you are attracted to won't find you attractive, and most of the people who are attracted to you are not going to be attractive to you. Given this simple fact, believing that most of your interactions with members of the opposite sex are motivated by romantic interest is simply not realistic, no matter how handsome/beautiful or charming you are. Maybe the tech industry (or a particular subset of the tech industry) is completely dysfunctional, but in my experience, most adult women and men are capable of interacting professionally without believing that all these interactions are somehow romantic in nature or fearing that they will be interpreted as such. [1] http://micheleincalifornia.blogspot.com/2014/03/the-gray-zone.html http://micheleincalifornia.blogspot.com/2014/03/the-gray-zon...
- Mz 11y agoA man does not need to be attracted to me to be worried that close collaboration -- working late together, having dinner together, etc -- will lead to other people wondering if there is an affair. Bonus points: My experience has been that men who aren't attracted react really negatively to me giving off signals that I am interested. So men who are not hoping to sleep with me can have powerful reasons to just not want to work closely with me in the kind of manner that could dramatically further my professional goals. (I am the author, in case that is not obvious.)
- 7Figures2Commas 11y ago> A man does not need to be attracted to me to be worried that close collaboration -- working late together, having dinner together, etc -- will lead to other people wondering if there is an affair. While there is nothing fundamentally wrong with professionally-appropriate "close collaboration" between two colleagues, "close collaboration" is possible without "working late together" or "having dinner together." In my experience the vast majority of working professionals, even those who forge close ties with their colleagues, don't see working late or dining frequently with colleagues after work hours as being fundamental to "close collaboration." They have their own lives and don't want to be spending their evenings with co-workers, male or female. > My experience has been that men who aren't attracted react really negatively to me giving off signals that I am interested. So men who are not hoping to sleep with me can have powerful reasons to just not want to work closely with me in the kind of manner that could dramatically further my professional goals. If a man or woman takes the risk of signalling romantic interest in a co-worker, he or she should be prepared for the possibility that the co-worker will react "negatively." While most adults are capable of handling this situation maturely and kindly, for obvious reasons the rebuffed party will almost certainly experience some level of discomfort after being rebuffed. This is the primary reason folks should be careful about expressing interest in somebody they have to work with. Are you prepared for the potential of self-inflicted awkwardness? Unless you are frequently signalling romantic interest in the co-workers you are hoping will work most closely with you, I don't understand why you believe men who are not hoping to sleep with you are generally disincentivized from building a healthy and mutually-beneficial working relationship with you. The only thing I can surmise is that your expectations around what "working closely" with a colleague looks like are unrealistic.
- melted 11y agoYup. As a white heterosexual male with a lot to lose, I avoid any kind of controversy involving women at all costs. Does this harm collaboration? You bet! But I don't feel safe otherwise.
- MollyR 11y agoI've noticed Asian and Indian men following this as well. I've overheard them talking about the backlash Nadella got as part of their reasoning.
- melted 11y agoSeems like a good idea for all men, regardless of race, ethnicity, or minority status. When your reputation can be irretrievably destroyed based on nothing but hearsay and someone's perceptions and preconceived notions, this course of action is the only one that's rational.
- kbart 11y agoGreat post, all this exaggerate promotion of feminism only alienates men and makes them actively avoid women as colleagues. You may never know now, if she's one of those overzealous "women's right defenders" that will sue you for accidentally touching her, glancing at inappropriate body parts for a split of a second or overheard "sexist" joke. Actually, not even suit is required -- blog post is enough to ruin your career[0]. Such aggressive promotion of feminism (in today's terms) only makes the gap between genders even deeper -- the exact opposite of this movement's stated goal. No wonder that really clever women start to understand such aggressive confrontation only worsens the situation and form a counter-movement[1]. 0. http://techcrunch.com/2013/03/21/a-dongle-joke-that-spiraled-way-out-of-control/ http://techcrunch.com/2013/03/21/a-dongle-joke-that-spiraled... 1. http://womenformen.org/mission/ http://womenformen.org/mission/
- jld89 11y agoYes completely agree. Let's hope that real equality can be achieved without spiraling into a quest for women's supremacy. It is no wonder that more and more men refuse to express their views about the issue for fear of being called out or for fear of putting their reputations on the line.
- vijayr 11y agoSame with kids too. Men are already scared to enter professions like teaching, hesitant to help when they find a kid lost in a shopping mall etc. Some airlines have a "policy" of not allowing single men to sit next to kids in their planes, some parks don't allow single men - as if the entire male population is criminal. Ridiculous.
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoAt least with kids it is equally applied. The average man treats boys and girls as both a potential threat and thus avoids being alone with either. But for women in the workplace, it isn't equal because the average man is far more worried about a false compliant from a woman than a man, thus they will work closer with other men, will be more willing to work one on one with other men, and other such small choices. Each choice isn't a big deal, but there are so many that over a few years it can vastly impact working relationships, almost making lite version of the old boy's club. For example, the male coworkers from an old job I go to eat out with once a week never invite women. Every now and then some come along and they don't deny any who want to join, but in general they want to hang out with 'the guys' because they realize there are different social rules to such a gathering. This leads to them building up social connections that can offer them a greater advantage.