4 ms·
I don't know. But some people find it to be crossing a line. I don't get it, but I'm also not in a particular minority group (religious minority in my area, but
by Jtsummers 11y ago
I don't know. But some people find it to be crossing a line. I don't get it, but I'm also not in a particular minority group (religious minority in my area, but I don't get upset about sexy nun costumes) that's commonly discriminated against.
Some people might see it as cultural appropriation. But it's a fictional character. Similarly, my ex-girlfriend often (with the approval of her Taiwanese and Chinese friends) dressed in some traditional Chinese outfits for Halloween for several years. None took offense, they encouraged it!
It's really hard to tell what's going to offend and what's not.
- vectorjohn 11y agoThe concept of cultural appropriation as somehow offensive is misguided in my opinion, but "with the approval of her Taiwanese and Chinese friends" Is the wrong argument to make. It's the equivalent of "I say offensive black jokes around my black friends and they think it's funny."
- Torgo 11y agoThe aggrieved always initially present their offense as being representative of the entire community of x. Saying "my friends are OK with it" is a way of saying "you don't speak for all X" and puts them in a position of replying "well maybe the people who know you best and live in your community aren't offended, but they should be according to this essay on critical race theory.
- alextgordon 11y agoThe idea of Chinese people being a "minority group" makes me laugh. It is so absurd that it must be a strawman.
- Jtsummers 11y agoDepends on where you are. And even if globally or even regionally they aren't, in the US there's a history of legal and extralegal abuse of Chinese immigrants. And then go back and look at the way they have been represented in numerous movies and tv shows over the decades in the US. It's not a pretty picture. Calling them a minority group may not be accurate, but there certainly is or was racism/nationalism/religionism targeted against them.
- alextgordon 11y agoSo you could say that cultural appropriation has nothing to do with foreign cultures, but is more of a conflict between different American subcommunities. If a person is Chinese, born and living in China, it seems highly unlikely that they would care about what Americans say or do. If a person is an American, who speaks American English, lives in America, but also has Chinese ancestry: appropriation of their identity is more likely to be a problem. As far as Halloween goes this is all hypothetical, because I'm not totally convinced that anybody is sincerely hurt by 'appropriative' costumes.
- iofj 11y agoI'm not sure that Mulan is really that much more of a stereotype than, say, Shan Yu or even the emperor. They're all Greek style heroes : rejected by their parents/city/mother/... (or at the very least against their wishes) who go off to save the world from some evil villain lacking depth, and they get some desirable significant other as pretty much the only reward. Same story as Lilo & Stitch in many ways. I bet real aliens would be offended too, and frankly all humans should be offended at how the black suits are portrayed.