4 ms·
Interesting observation. Can't understand why you have been voted down!
by chris_wot 11y ago
Interesting observation. Can't understand why you have been voted down!
- pjc50 11y agoSweeping characterisation of college students as "liberals", especially in a thread where they're being accused of illiberalism. It's the continuation of the US 'culture war'.
- thaumasiotes 11y agoYou're confusing "liberal", the US political affiliation, with "liberal" and "liberalism", the philosophy.
- pjc50 11y agoAs vezzy-fnord is arguing nearby, they're not unrelated.
- thaumasiotes 11y agoThe sweeping generalization that college students are liberals is completely warranted.
- chris_wot 11y agoLink: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10535836 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10535836 The more I read that posters comments the more of a fan I become. Not because I agree, but because it makes me think. I honestly don't say that lightly.
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoOK, you used the word "illiberalism". It's a good word, and perfectly expresses your point. It has a nice, clear meaning. But "liberal" has two meanings: It means the opposite of "illiberal", that is, in favor of human freedom. It also means "to the left on the political spectrum", which is a completely orthogonal meaning. (The political left can be as anti-freedom as the political right, and historically, I'm not sure which side has been "better".) Whether or not you like it, both definitions of "liberal" are in common usage. If anything, the political usage is more common than the not-illiberal usage. That means regarding it as "culture war" to call the college students "liberal" is... swimming against the tide? Trying to fight an unwinnable war? Not a good occasion for getting up in arms, at any rate.
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoUsing the word "liberal" to describe leftist policies is a U.S. invention that emerged out of the New Deal and was later hammered to death by neoconservatives who began abusing it to describe profoundly illiberal ideas, or really anything they disliked. It wasn't some grassroots movement, it was a conscious propaganda technique. "I never use the words Republicans and Democrats. It's liberals and Americans." - James G. Watt. It'd be like if one day people started completely uncritically and unironically referring to "libertarians" as "authoritarians". Sure, it's human language and anything goes, but it wouldn't be any less pants-on-head idiotic. Fun fact: the politically conservative party in Australia is called the Liberal Party.
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoSo if it emerged out of the New Deal, it's got about 80 years worth of becoming entrenched in standard usage. You quote James Watt. That was 30 years ago. This ship sailed a long time ago. You aren't going to change everyone else's usage here, no matter how hard to tilt against that windmill.
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoExcept it's nothing more than American slang, plain and simple. You may not believe that words have meanings, but I actually put value into semiotics and semantics.
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoI do believe that words have meanings. I just don't believe that they have cast-in-concrete, good-for-the-rest-of-time, works-in-all-societies meanings. OK, it's American slang. We're talking about an American college here, and I suspect that the majority of the people in the conversation are Americans. That means that you are the one insisting on using words in ways that are not the standard meaning.
- 11y ago
- chris_wot 11y agoWhen I reviewed the comment, there were no responses. It would be so much better if this was expressed as a comment. I was genuinely curious about the downvotes, not because of the score but because I wanted to understand the sentiment! FWIW, the GP didn't make a sweeping statement that all students were liberals, but that it was reported that student administration is largely composed of liberals. Now that is a bit problematic, because a. It doesn't state where this is reported so it's hard to counter, and b. It doesn't define what is meant by the term "liberal"... But these are all things to ask for clarification on. If we could ask for clarification in a respectful way (I'm guilty of not being respectful I'm afraid) these threads would be a lot more enlightening as the discourse would flow more freely and clearly.
- pjc50 11y agothe over-representation of a specific political/societal opinion in an education setting is not a good thing In the US context there is very much a reason for this: the right is hostile to intellectualism per se, and occasionally hostile to non-pragmatic education itself. discourse It's rather rare that the people one is speaking to in a comments thread actually change views in it, especially to the extent that they start off using codeword language. It's more for the 'benefit' of bystanders. And a bit of good old fashioned point-scoring.
- chris_wot 11y agoDiscourse allows for dissemination of ideas. It's not important to change the other person's opinion, but it's good to argue ideas. Comments sections aren't solely for the benefit of the two people hashing out their views, but also for all those reading them.