22 ms·
Apple TV vs. Roku 4 vs. Fire TV vs. Chromecast
- leanthonyrn 11y agoGreat article, but I think it minimizes the 4K video option in both the Fire and the Roku. "The Fire TV now also supports 4K video, if you have a television that can get up to that resolution. So does the Roku 4. The Apple TV and Chromecast don’t support 4K. You can decide how much that matters to you. Offerings of streaming 4K video are pretty limited right now, but are likely to increase dramatically in 2016."
- JohnTHaller 11y agoI don't think they minimized it. To the vast majority of consumers, 4K is currently irrelevant. There's barely any content (only 2 to 3 dozen movies on each streaming service) and a small fraction of 1% of homes have a capable TV. So, they're framed it accurately. It may make more of a difference in 2016... more content, rumored 4K upgrades to the Xbox/Playstation, more TVs compatible, etc... Right now, I don't know a single person in real life that watches 4K video.
- leanthonyrn 11y agoGo to bustbuy.com > TV section. Tell me 4K is irrelevant after you view the content of the front page. Yes, minimal content, but youtube has lots of free content. 2016 is less than two months out.
- JohnTHaller 11y agoRead this again: "To the vast majority of consumers, 4K is currently irrelevant." It's very relevant to electronics stores like BestBuy as they want people to buy new things. But 1080p to 4K is going to take a LOT longer than SD to HD did. Even in that transition, some folks were happy with fake HD (720p) as opposed to full HD (1080p). The majority of laptops still ship with fake HD screens. Far less than 1% of homes have a single 4K panel in their home. Far less than 1% of content is available in 4K. So, yes, "To the vast majority of consumers, 4K is currently irrelevant." The key word here is currently. A year from now -- not "2016", I mean 12 months from now -- there may well be enough 4K content to make it worthwhile for upper-middle and upper-class families. But there isn't right now. And a year from now there will be a new set of TV top devices.
- toxican 11y agoGo to bestbuy.com a few years ago > TV section. Tell me 3DTVs are irrelevant. Doesn't matter what they're selling if most people still have HDTVs
- saturdaysaint 11y agoGo to Best Buy 3 years ago and look at all the 3D TVs and tell me that 3D television isn't about to completely dominate media consumption. TV makers aren't in the driver's seat. You have to sit very close to even a 60" 4K TV to experience much of a difference - you essentially need a TV that dominates your living room to really discern the resolution leap. The performance penalty for games is severe enough that nobody's in a hurry to release a 4K console, so Apple gets a lot more advantage standardizing around one resolution.
- Nerdfest 11y agoI find it strange that he'd recommend the Apple TV. Doesn't it have by far the most limited choices of content and formats, and the most limited connectivity to other devices?
- hahainternet 11y agoHe's an Apple user.
- seivan 11y agoDepends, if you're using Mac OS and iOS then it's the perfect choice. I've only had experience with a Roku (three years ago) and an Apple TV 4 and so far I am really happy with the Apple TV. Itunes music from laptop or phone works awesome, or even using the remote to use the Music app directly. Popcorn time works better than Chromecast with no lag what so ever and I get a *single remote to control the important bits: pause, scroll, volume and turn off. I am considering buying Beamer.app or develop myself for own content with subtitle support. Though I haven't figured out how to change DNS on the Apple TV Device (I can't edit it), so I've had to change it the router, which kinda sucks. Also hoping the Apple TV will get support for an iPhone keyboard and a touch-lock. I just want to point out that we had a really shitty time with Chromecast outside of using it for Youtube.
- tommyd 11y agoBeamer.app is excellent and well worth the money. Simple but effective, just put it in the dock and drop media files onto it and watch them play. Makes my Apple TV3 useful basically! Edit: regarding DNS, try these instructions: https://www.unblock-us.com/how-to-set-up/ https://www.unblock-us.com/how-to-set-up/ - not sure how much the new iOS has changed things though
- Nerdfest 11y agoRunning all Apple across the board is okay until you decide you want to leave. hey don't play well with others. I think rewarding that sort of behaviour with money against my long term interests.
- JohnTHaller 11y agoIt's worth noting that this review is written by an Apple user and doesn't test anything with Android.
- scarface74 11y agoHe tested ChromeCast and the Amazon Fire TV (which is based on Android). But with Google's spotty record when it comes to TV devices (Google TV, Android TV, Nexus Player, Nexus Q), can you blame him?
- JohnTHaller 11y agoI mean that he tested the devices with his iPhone (criticizing the iOS Chromecast abilities) but didn't bother to test them with Android due to the fact that he is an Apple user. This despite the fact that a larger percentage of folks own Android devices and the fact that Chromecast works better with and has more features on Android.
- leecarraher 11y agoagreed, this seems to be a very biased non-technical review. "I am not a gamer, and I love games on the Apple TV" so not gonna test the others in regard to their gaming capabilities... I probably shouldn't have expected much from a business news magazine.
- scarface74 11y agoI'm torn. I have 3 older Rokus that are in need of an upgrade. I'm trying to decide between a new Roku and an Apple TV. Roku Pros: -Has an app for the iPhone that I can use when I misplace the remote and can use the iOS keyboard for text input -Has a native Amazon Prime client. -Find remote feature -Remote with headphone jack -Dedicated app for Pandora and Spotify Cons -anemic app store outside of streaming video -No AirPlay -processor not as powerful AppleTV: Pros: AirPlay Support More powerful processor Better apps Cons: Doesn't support Apple's remote app (yet?) Fragile remote On screen keyboard seems like a pain No Amazon Prime support without using AirPlay No headphone jack on remote No Pandora or Spotify app (yet?)
- pbreit 11y agoAt these price points you don't really have to agonize. Get both. Get a Chromecast and a Fire stick, too. Always nice to have one in your bag and at each TV. Fire seems to work best at hotels. Apple TV doesn't have the headphone jack but it can connect audio via Bluetooth.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dublinben 11y agoYou call the app store selection for the Roku anemic, yet the AppleTV doesn't even support Amazon Prime. Roku has always had the most support for different streaming providers, and never tries to lock you into any particular store.
- RealGeek 11y agoRoku took money from Dish to kick and block all other international content competitors.
- raxvn 11y agoI just closed the browser tab when I saw him recommending apple tv.
- vox_mollis 11y agoAll those features, yet media player companies still have yet to include the ONE feature that would make any of them actually usable: the ability to play arbitrary mkv and avi files from the network with a wide variety of codecs. Western Digital made a good effort some years back, but the UI was terrible. Nobody else seems to care about this one obvious killer feature. As consumers, we are still stuck building custom low noise boxes running xbmc.
- IgorPartola 11y agoI run a Plex server and the Plex app. It's wonderful. Sadly not OSS, but neither is the Roku I run it on.
- soared 11y agoSounds like an incredibly niche feature.
- rffn 11y agoHe misses the NVidia Shield. It has stellar gaming support, has the ChromeCast functionality included and has a similar set of media apps to the AppleTV. Even with the prospect of AppleTV's app selection growing faster than Android TV's the Shield should be a worthy opponent.
- RealGeek 11y agoHe didn't compare any Android TV box. Nexus Player is a very compelling option. Android TV have most of the popular video apps, and Chromecast support. It can be bought for less than $50, which is a great value. I am able to control Nexus Player with my Sony TV remote out of the box, it works through HDMI-CEC. If I Chromecast a video to it while watching cable, the TV automatically switches the input and plays the video. You can also install Kodi from Google Play Store, which gives you access to many more video streaming services which may not have an app for any streaming box yet. I wanted to watch CNN and some Indian News content, but there are no apps for it. I quickly wrote a plugin to stream videos from their official websites.
- feld 11y ago4K is not ready for consumers yet. Here's my friend's 4K Samsung TV that can't do 4K over any HDMI port without buying a $400 upgrade http://i.imgur.com/nOSULENh.jpg http://i.imgur.com/nOSULENh.jpg
- evook 11y agoHe forgot Kodi, the non-plus ultra in terms of streaming software. It wins every streaming device comparison just by not depending on closed hardware and beeing open source while supporting everything. Lacking an app? ( Not really, if you are missing an app in Kodi you'll miss it probably everywhere ) Sit back 2 hours and hack 100 lines in python to build it. Also why is he recommending the fire tv stick and apple tv? The last time I took a look they weren't able to play AC3 and apple was still apple. Edit: I just read that huge wall of... text and can't recommend anyone to read it aswell. Most of it is superficial and extremely biased in favor of apple tv. Some facts are just plain wrong. Why is h264/aac vimeo excluded from chromecast compatibility? Considering the _streaming quality_ doesn't even make sense from a technical point of view. 10,000 words and little to no value or facts. I am literally amazed how little facts, specs and test methods are this essay which should be called "Let me tell you about my favorite streaming device and drop some names of others". Disclosure: Developing my own Media Center on Top of Plex is my part time hobby, which consists mainly of writing plugins that run on a broad variety of clients ( CC, Roku, Fire TV, Xbox 360, PS4, Kodi, Android and so on) for my personal niche media sources. I'd place Roku as #1 and take the Chromecast out of the comparison. Apples and oranges. I wouldn't consider Fire TV and Apple TV as an option unless you are already up to the neck in their system.
- mmebane 11y ago> Lacking an app? ( Not really, if you are missing an app in Kodi you'll miss it probably everywhere ) DRM is a problem, though. I don't think there's currently any way to get Amazon Instant Video working, which is the only thing keeping me from using my nVidia Shield TV as my sole media device.
- evook 11y agoFortunaly that is not an issue for since Amazon Instant Video isn't a viable option for content in my country.
- drewg123 11y agoThey omitted the Nvidia Shield, which is what I purchased because it supports Kodi (formerly known as Xbmc) very well. The advantages of the shield over some of the other players: - Wired Ethernet (my TV cabinet might as well be a Faraday cage) - 4K support - Excellent Kodi support (including hardware accelerated MPEG2 broadcast HD playback without transcoding to h.264) - Blindly fast and always very responsive - IR receiver for easy integration with universal remotes - Support for Google Play video & music - I hear it also plays games, though I've never tried it. The disadvantage is that there is no Amazon Instant Video app, due to the Google / Amazon cold war and Amazon blacklisting a perfectly functional app from all Android TV devices except for Sony TVs. To work around this, I just use the craptastic built-in app in my 4K smart TV for Amazon, which means I watch less Amazon than Netflix. (In Reagan's voice: "Mr Bezos, Tear down that Wall!")
- msabalau 11y agoThe gaming support is really phenomenal. They've got Google Play and their own streaming offering, but for me the killer app is being able to stream PC games over to a tiny device in my living room (with a mouse and keyboard) connected to my short throw projector. Looking forward to playing Fallout 4 on a 150 inch "screen" this evening.
- mugsie 11y agoHe also missed the Nexus Player... I have to say I have used the FireTV, Chromecast and the Nexus Player, and it is by far my favorite.
- IgorPartola 11y agoBS. It's about content availability. Roku and Apple TV are on par with one major difference: Roku supports Amazon video, Apple TV supports iTunes. Depending on where you purchase your content from will determine which one you will want. If you are starting with a brand new setup, Apple TV has one major advantage: the remote is better, especially since you only need one remote to control both Apple TV and the television power/volume. Chromecast and Fire TV lack some of the major providers. Chromecast has some neat features, but it's not as complete an experience. My rule of thumb is this: if I have to think about how to get something done (how do I watch this video? How to I play that slide show?) then the technology is not doing its job. With Roku and Apple TV I don't have to think about how to do it, I just do it about 99% of the time.
- saturdaysaint 11y agoCalling them "on par" ignores the ridiculous platform advantages Apple has - a deep, tightly integrated technology stack from the silicon to the IDE, legions of first rate developers/studios that are assuredly "Apple first", humongous potential audience. The line between video and software is going to blur considerably - personalized sports viewing (switchable commentary, sophisticated PIP options, optional notifications about other games) and interactive fitness apps immediately spring to mind - and Roku will be a distant consideration for app developers if past is prologue.
- IgorPartola 11y agoIn my experience Roku seems to be the platform to get new channels quicker. I am not sure if this has to do with them being more friendly towards developers, or maybe an easier to use SDK, but they were leading in terms of content availability for a long time. I specifically chose it because they had Netflix while Apple TV did not. This may change as Apple TV becomes a competitive piece of hardware (everything except the past generation was not IMO), but as of right now they are pretty much on par.
- saturdaysaint 11y agoUntil this generation, getting a channel onto the Apple TV was essentially restricted to huge media companies, and was limited to a kludgy little markup language, so I think we'll see pretty quickly that comparing last gen Apple TV to Roku isn't going to be indicative of the platforms' futures.
- andrewla 11y agoI have a Roku 3, and have been thrilled with it. The headphone jack in the remote is a killer feature. The worst thing for me was the requirement to add a credit card to enable the device, but I found a thread on reddit [1] where someone had posted a link to a no-credit-card registration entry point. That entry point appears to be no longer valid, but some url hacking reveals that it is now [2]. My other complaints are mostly minor nits -- I hate that the UI has ads in it; I hate those extra buttons on the remote for specific apps (both for aesthetic reasons and for the fact that if you accidentally tap one of those buttons, then you're ripped out whatever you're doing). The scrubbing could be better, though it is pretty good, and it has a "closed caption on instant replay" feature, that could work more consistently, but is a brilliant idea to catch that bit of dialog you just missed. The quality of the UI varies greatly between the different apps, with Netflix clearly putting in the most work, and HBO Go phoning it in (no in-app search feature, just browse -- you can search from the Roku "universal search", but that requires exiting the app I'm already in, etc.) I got a Chromecast as a gift, and it's a neat toy, but when you need to pause a program in the middle, not having a remote is a huge pain. Your phone is locked now, and you need to open it, and then it can't connect to the Chromecast for some reason, and pause resets the program sometimes for some reason, etc., or because it lost the connection it can't figure out what's currently playing so pausing it loses the stream completely. It's possible that software bugs have been sorted out since then, but I'd be reluctant to try it again, especially since the Roku is so good. The lack of Amazon video on Apple TV feels like a non-starter to me; but I'm sure that will change in the future. Fire TV is tempting, but based on using a Fire tablet, I find Amazon's "content-focused" approach to be very confusing, with everything kind of jumbled together. [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/Roku/comments/1yqz30/can_you_activate_a_roku_without_a_credit_card/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Roku/comments/1yqz30/can_you_activa... [2] https://my.roku.com/signup/nocc https://my.roku.com/signup/nocc
- thebouv 11y agoWith you a 100% on this. Apple not having Amazon means I can't touch it (I own so many movies on Amazon for my kids). The headphone jack in the Roku 3 remote really is golden. So many times I've been able to watch things while the wife or kids are sleeping. Love it. Funny, I don't recall needing to register a credit card with my Roku 3, I already had an account from the Roku 2 release so maybe that's why. I'm going to go check my account now to see. I've never bought any apps or anything from Roku's service, so no reason to have that up there. I bought a Chromecast as well, but mostly to play around with developing for it. Plan to use it as simple digital signage delivery system and that's pretty much it.
- AdmiralAsshat 11y agoBut if I had to recommend just one, it would be the new Apple TV. It’s the first of the streaming media players that not only makes television easier but seems to expand the possibilities of what television can be. Reading this comment makes me realize that it's somewhat silly that we don't consider consoles in this competition. For instance, consider the capabilities of my PS3: - plays PS3 games (far more graphically intensive than most app store games) - Runs Netflix, Amazon Prime, and Plex (among others) - Limited support to allow apps controlled via smartphone (Youtube is the only one I can think of at the moment) - Physical controller - Can read and play some video files from a USB stick. - Can play files from DLNA devices and possible other servers via either Plex or PS3 Media Server PS3 is what I've got, so I'd be curious is someone could compare it to PS4 or XB1. And keep in mind as well that I'm not saying everyone should rush out and buy a PS3/PS4/XB1 to watch Netflix. I've still got an HTPC and a Chromecast. I'm merely pointing out that if it's good enough for what most people use their Roku for, it would be worth mentioning, given that a good number of people already have one solely for gaming.
- strictnein 11y agoYeah, Xbox One and Xbox 360 can do most/all of that as well. Amazon, Netflix, Hulu, etc. SmartGlass app for your mobile devices, plus any computer with Windows 10 can can control any Xbox One including streaming games (which works fine, if you're not playing a twitch based shooter (works poorly with Black Ops 3, works fine on Titanfall)).
- akandiah 11y ago> Reading this comment makes me realize that it's somewhat silly that we don't consider consoles in this competition. For instance, consider the capabilities of my PS3: As good as it is, I wouldn't compare it to a PS3 for its media capabilities. The PS3 runs very loud when the room temperature gets above a certain threshold, has a very clunky interface and the smartphone support is mediocre at best. My biggest complaint is the interface when it comes to using my PS3 as a media-centre. Having a dedicated remote doesn't even help with navigation as the amount of content increases.
- 11y ago
- silveira 11y agoI used to watch Netflix and Amazon Instant Video using my Wii U. It was ok, albeit the interface was often slow. Then I moved to a Amazon Fire TV Stick (bought for $19.99 during the launch) and it's amazing. The library of Netflix+Amazon is quite good and the interface is very fast and the remote is super responsive.
- silveira 11y agoI used to watch Netflix and Amazon Instant Video using my Wii U. It was ok, albeit the interface was often slow. Then I moved to a Amazon Fire TV Stick (bought for $19.99 during the launch) and it's amazing. The library of Netflix+Amazon is quite good and the interface is very fast and the remote is super responsive.
- nickspacek 11y agoI use my Chromecast every day and love it. We rarely have a PC in the house to use anymore and use our phones or tablet for most day-to-day activities on the Internet. As such, it's really easy to share a video with the rest of the family by "cast"-ing to the TV. However, we've been a little spoiled by the Xbox One voice controls, which I find work perfectly (unless all of the kids are screaming at it as well). Since getting it, it's now a toss-up on which device to use for Netflix!
- seivan 11y agoI have the old Chromecast that only supports 2.5ghz. It doesn't run 1080p smoothly as it's get choppy at times and takes a while before my phone finds the Chromecast on the wifi so I can control the volume or to pause. There is no way to scroll forward on content that isn't on YoutTube. Sure Chromecast is cheap, but we weren't looking for cheap and the frustration isn't just worth it.
- jhallenworld 11y agoI have the Roku 3. I'm pleased that they recently added a limited web-browser to it. This is key, because you should be able to take your Roku to a hotel, but then you need a browser to log into their wifi network. Roku 3 has the MIT courseware channel, so you can watch talks on computer architecture.
- leecarraher 11y agochromecast is nice, you can outfit your entire house with them in the low $100's and they are practically disposable. And can be controlled from the thing you most likely have in your pocket(well those of us that have phones that still fit in our pockets)
- kitwalker12 11y agoif they're talking content, Roku is definitely the best bet. the article seems a little bit condescending towards the "smaller company" which has so many different providers and doesn't lock you down