2 ms·
The reason all these things are glued together into one deal is that they will not pass on their own, because international trade is not symmetrical. Consider
by snowwrestler 11y ago
The reason all these things are glued together into one deal is that they will not pass on their own, because international trade is not symmetrical.
Consider a wealthy post-industrial nation A trading with a poor industrial nation B. Raw materials and simple goods flow from B to A, so tariffs will be the primary concern. Capital, complex goods, services, and IP flow from A to B, so investment, IP, and regulatory issues will be of concern in that direction. A tariffs-only deal will not be balanced and therefore not succeed. Likewise a regulations-only deal.
Trade issues are not even balanced between industries. A tariffs-dropping deal will find support from manufacturers, but opposition from materials companies.
So to succeed, a trade deal must balance the various interests of many stakeholders. That means gluing a bunch of stuff together so that to any given person, some parts will look good and some parts will look bad.
The reason Congress created fast track is that different people will see different parts as good and bad. Fast track ensures a simple vote on the balance as a whole. If enough people see more good than bad--overall--it passes.
A trade deal will never look ideal to anyone. The question is whether it's a net gain for most.
- walterbell 11y ago> The reason Congress created fast track is that different > people will see different parts as good and bad. That's one perspective. Public Citizen has another, http://www.citizen.org/documents/fast-track-chart.pdf http://www.citizen.org/documents/fast-track-chart.pdf "When Richard Nixon was president, he cooked up Fast Track to seize power from Congress. The U.S. Constitution gives Congress exclusive authority to “regulate commerce with foreign nations” (Art. I-8). Fast Track was a mechanism that delegated away to the executive branch Congress’ authority to control the contents of U.S. trade pacts, as well as other important powers. Fast Track empowered executive branch trade negotiators, advised by more than 600 official trade advisors who mostly represent large corporations, to choose trade partners and negotiate and sign trade pacts, all before Congress voted. Once signed, Fast Track put such deals on a legislative luge run: no matter how many domestic non-trade policies were implicated or threatened by the deal, Fast Tracked agreements hurtled through Congress within a set number of days, with normal democratic checks and balances iced over. Fast Track ensured that Congress’ role came too late to influence trade pacts’ contents: Congress only got a yes or no vote after a pact was signed and “entered into.” That vote also OK’d hundreds of changes to U.S. non-trade law to conform our policies to “trade” deal terms. Federalism was also flattened by Fast Track via a form of international pre-emption: state officials had to conform local laws to expansive non-trade domestic policy restrictions in Fast Tracked “trade” pacts. State officials did not even get Congress’ cursory role. … Fast Track should be relegated to a museum of inappropriate technology. Congress, state officials and the public need a new modern procedure for developing U.S. trade policy, one that takes into account the realities of 21st-century globalization agreements."
- jcranmer 11y agoThe first president to bend the Constitution to reduce Congress's role in making trade deals and treaties was... George Washington, of all people. Note that the Constitution says "[The president] shall have Power, by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate, to make Treaties, provided two thirds of the Senators present concur." At the time this was written, the intent was clearly to have the Senate be as intimately involved in the treaty negotiation process as the president. George Washington started his first treaty by basically asking the Senate what the negotiators should be aiming for. Neither the Senate nor Washington was happy with the process, and so Washington (nor any subsequent president) attempted a repeat. (See <http://www.au.af.mil/au/awc/awcgate/congress/treaties_senate_role.pdf> http://www.au.af.mil/au/awc/awcgate/congress/treaties_senate...).
- walterbell 11y agoThese days, revolving doors and web-based access to TPP drafts give corporate lawyers many advantages over the legislative branch, as members of Congress are restricted to reading TPP drafts in a locked room, without taking notes, without their trade/legal staff, without a phone. The executive branch delegated trade negotiations to former bankers, e.g. the lead TPP negotiator is ex-Citibank, http://www.commondreams.org/news/2015/05/28/us-trade-rep-wall-street-crony-groups-demand-transparency http://www.commondreams.org/news/2015/05/28/us-trade-rep-wal..., "Noting deep ties between the country's top trade negotiator and Wall Street banks, ten groups representing millions of Americans are calling on the White House to make public all communications between U.S. Trade Representative Michael Froman and the massive financial institutions that stand to benefit from proposed trade deals." For more on lobbyists, see http://www.ip-watch.org/2015/06/05/confidential-ustr-emails-show-close-industry-involvement-in-tpp-negotiations/ http://www.ip-watch.org/2015/06/05/confidential-ustr-emails-..., ".. Many of the industry representatives are themselves former USTR officials ... Jim DeLisi of Fanwood Chemical said he had just seen the text on rules of origin, and remarked, 'Someone owes USTR a royalty payment. These are our rules … This is a very pleasant surprise.'" The end result is an expansion of ISDS, which benefits corporate lawyers, https://youtube.com/watch?v=M4-mlGRPmkU https://youtube.com/watch?v=M4-mlGRPmkU
- RobertoG 11y agoIt's perfectly possible that a trade agreement is bad for all the signatory countries and ideal for other third parties that have co-opted the process. Just saying. I don't know if this is the case.