3 ms·
> makes it possible to reach compromises without appearing weak to constituients Why? According to that, all parliamentary debates should be secret, too. 90%
by kuschku 11y ago
> makes it possible to reach compromises without appearing weak to constituients
Why?
According to that, all parliamentary debates should be secret, too. 90% of it are finding a compromise between two parties.
Appearing "weak" is a virtue, not a weakness.
- kspaans 11y agoThe key word is international agreements.
- tome 11y ago> According to that, all parliamentary debates should be secret, too. Not as unreasonable as it sounds. The parliamentary system was devised when hardly anyone could read, and they certainly couldn't see debates on the TV.
- ant6n 11y agoA secret parliament is not a parliament.
- DasIch 11y agoYou should actually watch parliamentary debates sometime. For the most part they are completely boring and debates in name only. It's rare for parliaments to have actual passionate debates. That usually only happens on controversial and dividing issues, where it's worth it to make a stand to appeal to voters or where public support might help. Most of the time these debates are just a formality to pass through a compromise everyone already has agreed to pass through beforehand. Accordingly you'll see that parliamentary debates and even votes are attented often only by a small number of representatives, not because they're not doing they're job it's because they've already done theirs at that point and have better things to do.
- wfo 11y agoThis also has the added bonus of being functionally an oligarchy (oligarchies are MUCH more efficient even when the oligarchs disagree!) and really has no relationship to any kind of democracy, representative or otherwise.
- kuschku 11y agoWell, I’ve read the protocols of the committees that discuss them. They’re pretty interesting.
- pdeuchler 11y ago>>> and have better things to do. Yeah, like fundraising!
- drzaiusapelord 11y ago> all parliamentary debates should be secret, By the time something has reached the debate level, which is just theater for the most part, the big decisions have been made. No one is changing their minds or votes at that point, unless something previously unknown and exceptional is revealed, which is rare.
- kuschku 11y agoWell, the big decisions often are made in committees, sometimes in parliament, too, though. The whole process starts with a committee being started, they writing and working on several compromises, and then giving parliament the ability to vote on these. But the work of the committees – except for the TTIP committee – is also public.
- snowwrestler 11y agoMembers of parliament certainly have private conversations with each other before presenting legislation for a public debate and vote.