5 ms·
Are there any scientific resources about how almost every mainstream success is based on a rather "direct" copy of something that already existed? Like here wi
by k__ 11y ago
Are there any scientific resources about how almost every mainstream success is based on a rather "direct" copy of something that already existed?
Like here with WarCraft/StarCraft and Warhammer/Warhammer 40,000.
- doppel 11y agoI would say it's 50/50 between Warhammer 40k and the Alien franchise when it comes to StarCraft. Both StarCraft and WarCraft steals from a ton of other franchises and glues them together, reaffirming the saying "Good artists borrow, great artists steal!"
- ucaetano 11y agoActually, Starcraft is almost 90% Starship Troopers. From the armored exoskeletons (why do you think there's a "Marauder" unit in the game?), to the bug-like Zerg and the skinny-like Protoss.
- anon4 11y agoWarCraft was going to be a Warhammer game until the licensing deal fell through.
- k__ 11y agoYes, I know. But I hear people always complaining about how Y is like X was back in the days and nothing new. Is there any pattern behind this? People even say "Goethe hasn't invented Faust"
- icegreentea 11y agoYou will enjoy this documentary (Everything a Remix). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=coGpmA4saEk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=coGpmA4saEk Hardly 'scientific'... but how do you quantify copying.
- k__ 11y agohaha, thanks :D The question, I ask myself, is: What is worth copying and what not? I could imagine, that most of this success is simply luck. Everyone copies a different part of an already existing entity and those who hit the right one win. I mean, even successful companies like Google and Apple throw stuff on the wall an see what keeps sticking and they got some of the most intelligent people around.
- icegreentea 11y agoI mean, clearly copying and reference in art and culture is somewhat different from product development - art and culture is competitive in a different way from product development. But one of the things that I've thought of is that copying with understanding greatly increases your 'success rate'. I think you can find that in the heart of the standard quote "Good artists copy; great artists steal". Great artists can copy with understanding and in doing so make it their own - thus steal. They now have a possession of sorts over whatever they took. Blindly copying in the extreme case results in the literal cargo-cults. Copying with too much effort and you lose your advantage (the whole point of copying to is save effort). Still doesn't give you a nice happy equation (or whatever) to figure out what to copy - but I think it lays down a rule of thumb that if you don't know why something works, copying it probably won't be great.
- jegutman 11y agoThis is not scientific, but there was an excellent video series called "everything is a remix" http://everythingisaremix.info/watch-the-series/ http://everythingisaremix.info/watch-the-series/
- jerf 11y agoA fun mental exercise: What would it look like for something to be completely original? What could be made that would be completely immune to the charge of "not being original"? And would it have any value?