3 ms·
Exactly. You should also raise your guard whenever someone is trying to convince you that reality never presents you with hard choices: "So I never have to weig
by SilasX 11y ago
Exactly. You should also raise your guard whenever someone is trying to convince you that reality never presents you with hard choices: "So I never have to weigh my aversion to torture against my aversion to the loss of thousands of lives? Hooray!"
- haberman 11y agoAgreed. My skepticism about a claim is proportional to how much the person arguing it wants it to be true.
- marklgr 11y agoQuite often, the person doesn't realize he wants it to be true, so this raises the question: don't you have similar motives unbeknownst to you, and are you skeptical about them too?
- haberman 11y agoYes I am skeptical about my ideas, often excessively and to my detriment! But I don't believe I or anyone else can completely remove this bias, and I think that beyond a certain point it's not healthy or productive to do so. Taken too far, you can find yourself unable to think any thought without arguing against it with twice as many counter-thoughts. It can lead to paralysis where you aren't able to do or think anything for long enough to actually accomplish something. I think we have to accept that sometimes we are, at least temporarily, operating according to ideas we can't fully justify. We have to be willing to be temporarily wrong or misguided.
- XorNot 11y agoNo you literally never do. Stop thinking of Jack Bauer in 24 while you think about this subject.
- SilasX 11y agoA civilization-ending meteor will probably never head toward the earth, but your ethical worldmodel should be able to handle this scenario without special exceptions, rather than just try to assure yourself that it can't happen so you don't have to think about it.
- XorNot 11y agoA civilization ending meteor has relatively few additional questions to ask. Like are we sure there's a civilization ending meteor? Which as it turns out, actually makes quite a difference in our response to it! Whereas whatever the hell people want to talk about with 24-esque do-or-die scenario begs dozens if not hundreds of follow up questions, all of which have one thing in common: they've nothing to do with torture as conducted by the US to date, which has taken place over the course of years in a systemic fashion in which no assurances that the people we're torturing are even involved with "the enemy" have been able to be given.
- SilasX 11y agoIt's reasonable to say "this specific government will use this tool irresponsibly, in ways that hurt people and damage credibility without corresponding upside". But that's a different argument entirely from "this tool can never work."