3 ms·
Not really sure what the purpose of this piece is. My research concentrates on figuring out what exactly is missing from MWI to make it a complete, sensible th
by jessriedel 11y ago
Not really sure what the purpose of this piece is. My research concentrates on figuring out what exactly is missing from MWI to make it a complete, sensible theory, so I am very happy to entertain criticisms of it. But the author don't make much attempt to understand the arguments of MWI proponents. It's basically just MWI bashing.
He mostly attacks the popular-level work of Tegmark, or other big-name MWI proponents like Hawking who don't actually publish on this stuff. Tegmark is a fantastically smart guy with deep insight on a lot of stuff, but his approach to the measurement problem simply isn't as clearly and exhaustively laid out as people who concentrate on this full time. In particular, you really need to address guys like David Wallace, for whom articulating MWI from a technical background is part of their core research.
It would be like attacking sloppy language in a popular book by a world-famous cancer researcher regarding evidence for natural selection. The cancer researcher has a pretty good grasp on what constitutes evidence for natural selection, but even he can slip up and (say) fall into a just-so story if he's not careful. Attacking that guy is not a good way to engage with relevant philosophy.
Anyways, I have a technical comment on this:
> This picture really gets extravagant when you appreciate what a measurement is. In one view, any interaction between one quantum entity and another – a photon of light bouncing off an atom – can produce alternative outcomes, and so demands parallel universes.
This isn't right in general. There definitely needs to be some sort of amplification (and hence, usage of negentropy) to get the production of branches in the wavefunction. Systems that have thermalized don't branch any more.