3 ms·
Clarity of communication is not the goal here, perspective is. When Darwin realized that we were in fact just an extension of the animals he found a new perspe
by ThomPete 11y ago
Clarity of communication is not the goal here, perspective is.
When Darwin realized that we were in fact just an extension of the animals he found a new perspective that was very helpful to understand the world around us. It wasn't that evolution is true, it's just the best model we to explain biology.
That perspective is immensely useful for all sorts of applications and thats what Mensvoort is trying to do.
You are indirecting repeating the same argument the people who opposed his theories did. Making humans part of the animal kingdom hurt communication. Of course the question is whats the point of that communication?
- mrob 11y agoI'm not opposing his theory, I'm opposing his language.
- ThomPete 11y agoYou could have made the same argument with Darwin back then. Thats my point. Creating another word doesn't provide the perspective he is trying to achieve. His challenge isn't going to be clarity but like Darwin to get people even to accept the idea that it's the same.
- wrongc0ntinent 11y agoThere's no use in blotting out meaning. You can get more precision and (as he does) make a point as to the inadequacy of a concept - by establishing degrees. It's been done for ages in philosophy.
- ThomPete 11y agoThe insight is that technology is natural. That's it. Now that might in the end form a new theory that will require a new name (just like Darwin did when his insight was that animals and humans are part of the same tree), but the insight is not a new word but instead the insight it would represent. You can take the term "a theory of evolution" away and it's still as insightful a perspective (humans come from apes).