4 ms·
"freshly prepared meals with locally sourced vegetables and grains" I will never understand this obsession with "local". Local is not safer, local does not emb
by ars 11y ago
"freshly prepared meals with locally sourced vegetables and grains"
I will never understand this obsession with "local". Local is not safer, local does not embody less CO2 (it actually has more), it does not mean more nutritious, it does not mean less pesticides.
Pretty much the only argument that ever made even a bit of sense to me is cultivating a relationship with the farmer - but what difference does that make when you buy the food from a chain restaurant (as described in the quote above), or even a grocery store?
Is this author just trying to load up the article with as many buzzwords as possible? I noticed they didn't mentioned "organic".
- tptacek 11y agoIt doesn't necessarily mean more nutritious or fewer pesticides, but if you are optimizing for attributes like that, your best bets are going to end up being a local producer. Not all local is good, but the best producers usually are.
- ars 11y ago> Not all local is good, but the best producers usually are. Wait, so you are saying, if I live far away from the farm the exact same produce suddenly tastes worse?
- tptacek 11y agoYes. It's not the exact same produce. The very best produce doesn't travel at all. If you live in a major US city, go to one of the top restaurants in it sometime for dinner, and ask your server a lot of questions about where the vegetables come from. Chances are they don't come from big purveyors; most will come from farms with names you can write down, and probably buy direct from --- but not from your supermarket, and definitely not from a supplier anywhere more than 150 miles away. Sometimes these are gold-speaker-cable kinds of differences, and sometimes they're real differences that you'd have to train your palate to detect (and so why would you want to do that?), but sometimes they are huge differences, products you simply have to live in the region and buy at the right time of year to get.
- jdminhbg 11y agoYour list of benefits missed taste. Local produce is picked closer to peak ripeness because it doesn't have to survive as much shipping.
- ars 11y agoPeople might believe that, but it isn't actually true. If anything the opposite is true because when your only market is local you can't be sure to sell everything right away, so you pick it earlier to give yourself extra time to sell it.
- cmurf 11y agoIf we want to get nitpicky about locale of food sourcing, some things simply don't grow in a lot of places in the U.S. so you can't get them locally. At least not year round. And arguably, they probably shouldn't be. Modern agriculture has obliterated native plants, and even the microbes supporting the correct soil conditions for those plants. Eating environmentally sound and "locally" means eating native plants, and when that's not possible, it means eating the animals that do eat those plants. Ask people to do that. It's not very practical.
- tptacek 11y agoThat's all well and good until we realize that means Floridians and Californians will pay $15 for a loaf of sandwich bread and $30/lb for ground chuck, while people in the midwest will be eating turnips and potatoes all winter long. Local is great but it seems like it's pretty clearly a marginal phenomenon.