6 ms·
Seed 'extensions' are becoming the new normal in fundraising
- tsunamifury 11y agoGranularizing rounds seems like a good idea until you realize how much work it is to raise. If a startups path goes from seed, A, B, Exit to Seed 1, Seed 2, A, Bridge, B, C, Bridge etc then the founders have significantly less time to focus on their product and spend more time playing the game. Anyone have any advice on raising enough on the seed round to match your needs without having to create an absurd valuation that will crunch you in A?
- danieltillett 11y agoYou could avoid having to raise a series A by slowing down your growth so you reach cash flow positivity. Unless your seed investors have a claw back clause there is not much they can do. Of course doing this will make it hard to raise more money in the future, but if you are clever about it you could hide this action by claiming you can't find suitable people, the right location, etc, etc.
- wpietri 11y agoI'd also be curious to know if people who have raised money previously feel like the work to raise today is lower. The limited anecdotal evidence I've heard suggests that, but I've love a broader perspective.
- austenallred 11y ago> Anyone have any advice on raising enough on the seed round to match your needs without having to create an absurd valuation that will crunch you in A? Grow extremely quickly by doing everything else right? There's really no shortcut or trick, that's just what it takes. To raise <$1 million and be ready for a Series A is just brutally difficult. For example, my brother just raised his A and he said investors were looking for a $1.5 million run rate and 3-4x YOY growth. So in ~18 months with ~5 people you'd have to build product, make that many sales and still have compounding growth. That's set up to find the companies that are doing extremely well. It will happen, but that's not something you can really brute force (it didn't happen to my company, even though we're on a very promising trajectory). Now, say you raise a $2m seed extension. That gives you an additional ~18 months to hit those same metrics, while hiring a couple more people. That's just so much more doable. Especially considering most first-time founders (myself included) spend the first six months making mistakes around building the right team. (One way to help make it to a series A on your seed is to have all the people you want/need ready to be plugged in.) I think either the Series A expectations will come down slightly or "seed prime" rounds will become the norm, as they already are becoming. Not many are ready to go to the NBA after playing in High School. Simple as that.
- 7Figures2Commas 11y ago> ...most seed companies aren’t actually burning that much money. A lot can be done today with a small team and $50,000 a month. > In many of these cases, the founder simply didn’t raise enough to hit the milestones they promised. Product development often takes twice what was anticipated, and many early stage companies simply didn’t have the capital to achieve what they hoped in advance of an A round. This is contradictory. On one hand, the author claims "a lot can be done today with a small team and $50,000 a month" but on the other he's admitting that many of these companies aren't able to do what the founders "promised" they'd be able to do. > Valuations tend to be flat or flat-ish. > In the end, however, the entrepreneur benefits because they usually see a step up in valuation from the first to second seed. Which one is it? > These differ from your classic seed. They tend to have new participants, unlike the more classic extension, which is merely the insiders injecting additional capital into the company. This is the perfect demonstration of what happens when there's too much money chasing too few opportunities. New investors are willing to put more money into a company that underestimated its funding needs, missed its targets and can't raise a Series A, and do so at the same or slightly higher valuation as previous investors. Insanity. The "seed extension" phenomenon also demonstrates why early-stage startup employees should be skeptical about equity. These "seed extensions," which look like dumb money bridge rounds, can be really destructive. Just do the math on what happens when a company raises $1 million at a $10 million valuation, and then raises a $2 million "extension" at a "flat-ish" valuation.
- danieltillett 11y agoOn the maths isn't it the same as having raised $3 million on a $10 million valuation? Of course if you start doing this you are going to find that you don't own much by the time you get to series A and you have managed to totally destroy any incentive for your team to build the business.
- wpietri 11y agoI agree with your concerns about the article, but I'm not so worried about the phenomenon. The new money in a seed extension could be dumb money. But it also could be real validation of a pivot, where the first idea didn't work but the second, better informed one could. I'd certainly prefer people taking multiple seed rounds to them taking a ton of money up front. Too much money is startup poison.
- codinghorror 11y agoInteresting. Due to the seed explosion (which is absolutely a good thing, more entrepreneurs trying new stuff) Series A has indeed become very challenging -- extremely challenging, even. Rather than raise more seed, we decided to buckle down and try to fund through paying customer growth. Slower of a curve than a 2 or 3 million dollar injection, but no strings attached either. And I figure you need to develop your billing and customer chops eventually anyway, so why not start building those skills now?
- wpietri 11y agoBravo! I occasionally mentor at startup events and I can't tell you how crazy it makes me when first-time entrepreneurs look down on getting revenue as some sort of grubby detail not quite worth their attention. I love it when people go after actual customer money; it forces them to pay careful attention to the heart of the business. There is a risk, though. (I'm sure you know it already, but I mention it just to balance out my enthusiasm for others.) If a company's revenue is $0, investors can imagine anything they want. But if revenue is $1.39, investors may be subject to an anchoring bias [1]. I don't think that's a huge risk for companies that have a well-understood business model; if you are selling annual software subscriptions, it's pretty easy for investors to imagine scaling that up. But I think Twitter and Facebook were smart to avoid revenue for a long time because it let them sell the dream. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anchoring https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anchoring
- gavazzy 11y ago> "What, revenue? no, no... no revenue! Why would you go after revenue? No, if you show revenue, people will ask "how much?" and it will never be enough. The 100x'er or the 1,000x'er will now be the 2x dog. But if you have no revenue, then you're pre-revenue. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BzAdXyPYKQo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BzAdXyPYKQo
- wpietri 11y agoWow, that's a little too good. I'm think going to save watching Silicon Valley until I'm retired so that I can experience it as comedy rather than horror.