3 ms·
> Ever since an American electrical engineer invented a food that abolishes the inconveniences of foraging and cooking, and contains all the nutrition a human b
by DanBC 11y ago
> Ever since an American electrical engineer invented a food that abolishes the inconveniences of foraging and cooking, and contains all the nutrition a human body is known to require but is devoid of the substances that harm, there has been talk that it can end not only the problems of the overfed but also the underfed. After all, it is in the tradition of Silicon Valley-blessed projects to invent a solution for the rich that eventually “makes the world a better place,” to borrow an expression used by tech billionaires and comedians.
Jesus fucking christ.
1) Soylent didn't invent anything. Complete liquid meals have been around for many years.
2) No one credible suggest soylent is useful to end world hunger. It's too expensive; it has the wrong nutrient balance; it's made in the wrong place; it requires too much clean water; it's worse than the existing emergency food products in many different ways.
- philh 11y ago> It's too expensive; it has the wrong nutrient balance; it's made in the wrong place These don't sound like dealbreakers. One assumes that it can be made more cheaply with scale; with adjusted nutrient profiles; and in places where it is not currently being made. If existing products are better, then Soylent will presumably face some problems on this stage, given that world hunger is in fact still a problem. But I don't think they'll be those ones.
- gotrecruit 11y agogod, thank you! as an entrepreneur who has been bodybuilding for more than a decade, i have a really weird love-hate relationship with soylent. i really love the idea because its actually something i've done for myself (custom mixing meal replacement powder formulas) and considered marketing and selling, and i really hate that the soylent guy went ahead and just did it. the worst part for me is that this guy started way way behind myself (and many others who are obsessed with bodybuilding and fitness and nutrition) in terms of nutritional and dietary knowledge, which is evident from his early formulas, and yet he managed to drum up enouogh media attention that he is widely considered a pioneer in the space. i mean, meal replacement powders have existed in supplement shops for decades!
- CuriouslyC 11y agoSoylent is a mediocre product with great marketing. That is unfortunately the curse of capitalism - it isn't the best product that wins, rather the best _promoted_ product that is at least barely acceptable. On the plus side, given Soylent is mediocre, I suspect that it can only expand the market for functional foods.
- kushti 11y ago"the curse of capitalism" - I guess it's the curse of the media-driven society.
- lnanek2 11y agoYou are indeed right. Although I'm surprised HN hasn't ghost banned you for being negative anyway, lol
- jacquesm 11y agoHN does not 'ghost ban' people for being negative.
- nether 11y agoI think any Soylent thread would benefit from a summary of typical comments, to make way for new ideas. Pick yours. 1. Liquid diets aren't new 2. Cooking is easy and enjoyable, I don't see why people avoid it 3. Soylent is healthier than fast food even if it's inferior to well-made natural meals 4. It hasn't undergone rigorous, clinical testing 5. It's dystopic, dehumanizing 6. It's a dietary choice of others that makes me inexplicably angry 7. I've been trying it for 50-100% of my calories for X weeks and it's been great/terrible 8. It's based on outdated FDA recommended allowances 9. It ignores the social, cultural aspects of food
- codingdave 11y agoI pick #1. My biggest problem with Soylent is not what they are doing, but that they have an attitude that they invented the idea.
- bordercases 11y agoLike how Apple "invented" the GUI? The results speak for themselves.
- Crito 11y ago> "Apple is successful, therefore your criticism of [unrelated company and their unrelated product] is irrelevant. I see this a lot. It is ridiculous.
- bordercases 11y agoIt's usually put against the class of arguments that being derivative or being recombinant is in itself a valid criticism of a product. The company isn't going to give up any revenue just because it found a better target market for a similar good; and neither will accepting the existence of predecessors help the predecessors any. Not to falsely represent your point, but do you believe that changing industries makes this any less the case? Plus the extent that Soylent is a substitute for Ensure or Boost or those peanut bars they give to starving earthquake victims isn't total: Soylent is based in consumer feedback while Ensure/Boost have stopped innovating; Soylent is aiming for use in perpetuity while Ensure/Boost are meant to be stopgap measures, etc. I like the product a lot so I'm going to be speaking vehemently about it, but that doesn't mean I'm not open for criticism. I'm wondering what your thoughts are.
- infinotize 11y agoThere's another thing people forget, too: you're made to chew things. Chewing helps break down food for digestion, and probably more importantly generates saliva, which is also very important for initial digestion as well as oral health.
- x5n1 11y agoNot to mention the gut is a muscle, and muscles need exercise. Eating liquid food is probably not good in the long run for your digestive system and probably causes other problems that will be evident 5-10 years down the line or more. People were not meant to eat liquid supplement.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- darkmighty 11y agoIf this is the only problem maybe it has a solution too? It shouldn't be too hard to make a nutrient-poor spongy substrate to carry Soylent.
- discardorama 11y agoOr, you know, just spit into the soylent as you're constituting it?
- darkmighty 11y agoDoesn't provide chewing or gut muscle activity.