7 ms·
Some people appear to believe that if the average temperature of the globe increases by two degrees, then the average temperature in May in Munich must increase
by Arnt 11y ago
Some people appear to believe that if the average temperature of the globe increases by two degrees, then the average temperature in May in Munich must increase by 2.00 degrees, the average temperature in Timbuktu in June must increase by 2.00 degrees, the average temperature in Panjim in July must increase by 2.00 degrees, the average temperature in Valparaiso in August must increase by 2.00 degrees, and so on and so forth.
Then these people are astonished when it doesn't work that way. "Oh! Some places heat up more, others less, or actually don't heat up!" or "Oh! The summers and winters don't change in the same way?"
Depressing.
- usertaken 11y agoAnd some people refuse to give in when their theory was just disproven. Really depressing.
- Bud 11y agoWhich people? What theory was "just disproven"?
- BogusIKnow 11y agoWhat theory? That every place on earth gets warmer? Yes if you've held that theory you have been disproven.
- vlehto 11y agoIf you wish to learn about climate change, I'd recommend looking at the history of it. One key thing to look at is radiation balance. The whole field of science was lot less hyped and corrupted before the 90's. And I haven't heard of any new findings that would dramatically change that picture.
- usertaken 11y agoWhy did the narrative change from "Global Warming" to "Climate Change"? Because you can't prove the climate changes. The climate has been changing since the earth was created and it will continue to change. Can someone tell me when Miami will be underwater like you tell me it will be? Give me a date range...something specific. Since it's science and it can be "proven" then someone should be able to tell me that. And if that date comes and goes and it doesn't happen do you promise to back down or will you make up an excuse? Of course you won't back down. You'll just tweak your theories. Until then why take issue with taxing U.S. companies w/ carbon taxes or whatever you're calling it nowadays and focus on the real carbon polluters....China, Latin America?
- SquareWheel 11y agoSince when were there all these conspiracy nuts on HN?
- tptacek 11y agoDon't call people nuts, even when they're very wrong about things. All you accomplish by doing that is making people wonder whether this is a religious debate that they shouldn't care about.
- csallen 11y agoYou sound like you haven't ready any of the leading evidence or arguments for climate change at all.
- jotux 11y agoWhat's sad is 60 seconds of googling would point him to a paper answering the exact question he believes cannot be answered: http://www.pnas.org/content/112/44/13508.full.pdf http://www.pnas.org/content/112/44/13508.full.pdf >Analysis based on previously published relationships linking emissions to warming and warming to rise indicates that unabated carbon emissions up to the year 2100 would commit an eventual global sea-level rise of 4.3–9.9 m
- usertaken 11y agoI've heard different years and that's why I bring it up....because the "science" has been disagreeing on this point. Does this take into account the emissions deal w/ China? Because that should push that figure out a couple years or decades from that 2100 figure, no? How much? It's science. Boils down to if you believe the authors are giving an unbiased viewpoint. They receive funding from someone, no? Do those sources benefit from taxing emissions?
- jotux 11y agohttps://www.skepticalscience.com/sea-level-rise-predictions.htm https://www.skepticalscience.com/sea-level-rise-predictions....
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoWhen the global average goes up, the extremes get more extreme.
- puppetmaster3 11y agoHi Andrea, why did you say that? I mean, do you have any data or links or your own thinking?
- madaxe_again 11y agoBecause of centuries of data, climatic modelling, and... have you looked out of your window lately?
- tedunangst 11y agoWait. You're saying I should evaluate claims of global warming by looking out my window?
- spdustin 11y agoClimate change. And, odds are, looking out your window for a year and comparing that to what you saw and documented in previous years would show that the climate you've experienced this past year is different. It's changed. The weather on any given day may not, but the sum total of annual energies revealing themselves to you through temperature, atmospheric pressure, precipitation, humidity... that is likely to be different from past years in a statistically significant way.
- tedunangst 11y agoSeems like a flawed setup. If I observe a change, "see, there's climate change." If I don't observe a change, "duh, it's global change, you can't just measure locally." Heads you win, tails I lose. And seriously, compare this year to last? Do you think the climate in years 1000 and 1001 didn't change? This is exactly the bullshit "science" climate change deniers use.
- nabla9 11y agoTemperature anomaly map: http://data.giss.nasa.gov/cgi-bin/gistemp/nmaps.cgi?sat=4&sst=6&type=anoms&mean_gen=09&year1=2010&year2=2015&base1=1951&base2=1980&radius=1200&pol=rob http://data.giss.nasa.gov/cgi-bin/gistemp/nmaps.cgi?sat=4&ss... Btw. Increased temperature may be the underlying cause. Warmer temperature -> increased humidity -> more snow -> more ice.
- usertaken 11y agoSnow doesn't fall in warm places.
- nitrogen 11y ago"Warm" is relative. -40 degree air can probably hold more water than -50 degree air. Warm air over water can evaporate more of the water, which can be carried to cold places. Also, as a comment (iirc) on the Ars Technica take on thus story pointed out, the error bars on the study are so huge that it's unreasonable to conclude the ice is thickening without more accurate data.
- spdustin 11y agoPrecipitation doesn't fall where it enters into solution with the atmosphere.
- coliveira 11y agoThis is one of the biggest problems of the modern world. So much of what we know is based on science, but there is so little scientific literacy that it is very easy to convince people of incorrect things. For example, global warming deniers are all the time using cheap arguments like this. Because you need to have some understanding of logic to identify logical fallacies, it is increasingly easy to create bogus arguments to support things like creationism, conspiracy theories, etc.
- bmmayer1 11y agoIf science has taught us anything, it's that Science is not a Revealed Truth but must be prone to criticism, testing, and new insights, not to mention the discovery of the unknown. Using 'global warming deniers,' a not-so-subtle comparison to Holocaust deniers, to denigrate an entire body of scientists (scientists, not politicians) who disagree about the degree, level, impact or even nature of global warming, is doing science on a whole a great disservice. Yes, logical fallacies are frequently used by all types to make cheap arguments. The point is no better made than in this comment.
- nitrogen 11y agoLet's not relitigate the use of the word "denier" here. If we can never again use any word that's ever been used in the same phrase as the word Holocaust, what does that benefit us?
- droopybuns 11y agoIt rightfully shames tribal thought that attempts to masquerade as "scientific." There is value in shaming uncritical thinking.
- Frondo 11y agoExcept, as has so often been pointed out, the "entire body of scientists" who reject AGW is a tiny, tiny, tiny fraction of the entire body of climate scientists. And every so often it comes out that one of the high-profile deniers is on the payroll of some company that benefits from the confusion they stir up! You could probably find an "entire body of scientists" who believe in a flat-earth theory, and they too are worth ignoring or characterizing as "deniers".
- incongruity 11y agoObligatory disclaimer - I'm not arguing against anthropogenic climate change... That having been said, I think that some of this seeming confusion on the part non scientists/casual consumers of mass media news sources makes a bit of sense. Science reporting is usually poor quality - it goes for the sensational headlines and it often doesn't do a good job of differentiating fact from theory from prediction so when new evidence/data gets brought in to the mix, it becomes all too easy for the casual news consumer to be confused and feel like "the story is always changing"... And in some ways it is. That's what science does. It always builds on (or rejects) older ideas as better evidence becomes available. In the case of climate change, the narrative was "global warming" which, to a casual news consumer, could sound like warming will take place across the globe. Incorrect, yes, but the confusion is partially understandable, imho.
- 7952 11y agoIt doesn't help that climate change activists seem to rely so heavily on science as a way to win arguments on policy. Science just tells us what is happening and gives a way of predicting the future. It is not some silver bullet for deciding policy or persuading people to change their habits. We need people to be far more literate about the environment in general and understand why it is in their self interest to protect it.
- incongruity 11y agoBut there's the rub... by and large, it's not in my personal interest to stop global warming. Short-run gains matter more to a lot of people AND many people who could change won't see the return on their investment (or their bad behavior) in their lifetime. (I should say, I'm not endorsing that thinking either... just noting that there's a challenge here, especially when one tries to frame climate change in terms of "self-interest")
- nitrogen 11y agoThis might be the one area where "think of the [grand]children" is a reasonable argument.