5 ms·
I find it strange that I hear a lot more reference to the "means of production" concept in marxism these days. I always thought it's a concept from the weakest
by netcan 11y ago
I find it strange that I hear a lot more reference to the "means of production" concept in marxism these days. I always thought it's a concept from the weakest parts of marxism. But besides that, it's an increasingly ethereal concept.
In Marx' day, you could think of "means of production" as land, factories & tools mostly. At least, thinking of it in these few concrete terms related very closely to most of the economic activity around you. In a communist society, workers own the factory and farmers own the land, fairly concrete. Marx then suggests (as I said, I always though it was very weak) that a proletariate state would just own all means of production and workers in general would own it. So, he breaks from the simple and concrete concept pretty quickly. Still, at least you can picture what you're thinking of.
But in today's world, what is Google's "means of production?" What's Apple's? HSBC's? Disney's? Uber's? Uber is more fiction-made-matter than a bunch of "capital."
I find it surprising. I mean Marxism/Communism/Socialism has other concepts that I think are more relevant and less contrived that I'm surprised we don't hear more about. The idea of historical progression seems appropriate given the rate of change we see today. The Marxist revolutionary concept that when the majority don't have a stake in the status quo, revolutions happen... that seems relevant given the trends in inequality. Global solidarity.
At least "labour power" isn't making its back way into general political vernacular.
- kuschku 11y agoWell, one way to do it is to make sure most shares of a company are owned by the workers, subcontractors, the customers, etc. Like the many co-op consumer cooperations, which usually have an upper limit of 2000$ investment per person, and are owned by hundredthousands of people at once.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- krisdol 11y agoIn these days, means of production may also mean the company resources & venture capital, with so much production being digital.