6 ms·
The Luddite Fallacy is itself it fallacy because it misses one very very important thing. Technology and AI is able to solve higher and higher levels of abstra
by ThomPete 11y ago
The Luddite Fallacy is itself it fallacy because it misses one very very important thing.
Technology and AI is able to solve higher and higher levels of abstract thinking which means it will be able to compete with humans more and more. It's not just about competing with our muscle but with our brains. And AI increasingly do so. Furthermore once a new skill is learned it's instantly re-learnable by all other machines. Humans takes years to develop.
And where human evolution relatively is at a standstill technology keeps growing exponentially.
AI doesn't have to be general purpose to put most out of a job it just have to be good enough to the kind of functions our jobs represents.
When people like Andreesen claims that 150 years of industrial evolution proves the "luddites" wrong, all I can really say is that million of years of evolution proves Andreesen wrong.
There are no systems that can't be replaced by others.
- sidescroll 11y ago"There are no systems that can't be replaced by others." Weak A.I eventually meets strong A.I and the cycle begins again. Every paradigm and those centered on it has its time.
- vlehto 11y agoMachinist these days is several orders of magnitude more productive than manicurist. They make similar amounts of money. Cost of production mostly depends on salaries, machinery and raw materials. Company that produces machinery has the same structure. So does company that produces the raw materials. In the end, all costs of production are related to human work. If 90% of current jobs are automated, then purchase parity controlled prices of current products fall by ~90% too. (If competition happens.) Which means average consumer has 90% of their budget to spend on new stuff. That new stuff is going to employ people. The fact that nobody here has any idea what those people are going to do, doesn't mean there is nothing to do. There are possible problems though. The type of person most needed might not be the most common psychological make up present in the population. Like currently with software developers. Also shift from production to services might require income inequality to work.
- ThomPete 11y agoAverage consumer (those 90%) don't have a job so they don't have any money to spend with. The cost of living is going up not down mainly because of urbanization. "The fact that nobody here has any idea what those people are going to do, doesn't mean there is nothing to do. " Thats not how it works. You would already now see plenty of new types of jobs replacing those that are lost. This is a gradual process although perhaps exponential. In other words you would already now see new types of jobs that would pay someone enough to live off and the prices go down on things. They are not and thats despite us needing less and less people for things.
- vlehto 11y agoMy great grandfathers we're all farmers. Only one of my cousins is a farmer. That supposed "90% don't have any income" -event already happened. My extended family is richer than ever. Human beings have tendency to find new jobs before they hit rock bottom and help each other out. That probably explains lot of this dynamic. Purchase parity controlled cost of square meter of habitable indoors space has remained pretty stable. People just want bigger houses. And are more willing to pay for it than before. >You would already now see plenty of new types of jobs replacing those that are lost. Short term yes. Short term seems to work out as unemployment is well below 20% in EU and U.S. But 30 years from now? Nobody has any idea. Just like for the past century. In other words, why is this time really different? Automation has been happening for a long time now. Computerized automation has been happening since 70's. Secretaries going unemployed did not cause permanent dent on employment.
- ThomPete 11y agoIt's not different this time because it's not a different time. It's just that technology is a very long trend who's exponential growth is now starting to rear it's ugly head. It used to be a tool to help us compete with others. Those who used them best got the biggest productivity gains. But now technology is not just competing with our muscles it's competing with our brains. Thats why it's different. We are moving away from a world where technology was our servant to a world were it very well be our master. Again your analogy says nothing when you take it in the bigger evolutionary perspective. There are no natural laws that says that just because something been a certain way for 150 years it will always be like that. The bigger trend shows no special treatment of humans.