4 ms·
And yet results from the actual world do not match this study. One thing non-believers report missing the most is a community. However there is a definitely a
by ars 11y ago
And yet results from the actual world do not match this study.
One thing non-believers report missing the most is a community.
However there is a definitely a difference with regard to in-group and out-of-group behavior with religious groups, where most of the generosity is directed in-group only.
I suspect that this group-oriented behavior is responsible for 100% of the difference found in the study.
Non-believers are not oriented toward in/out groups so much (presumably because they do not have a built-in group, so the concept is not mentioned much).
I suspect if you redid the study and had some kids be told "the other kids goes to the same xxx as you", (and others not told) you would find some very interesting results.
I suspect the in-group generosity of the religious kids would go up much more, compared to the in-group generosity of the non-believers.
- fsloth 11y ago"And yet results from the actual world do not match this study." I would have given the benefit of the doubt before this study. Based on the huge sample size of my two children I cannot fathom how religious upbringing could make them more altruistic than they are. They share things, because they want to be nice to other people. They have different sensibilities - one is more altruistic than the other - but basically we try to teach to both of them the right thing by asking what they think the other person would feel. Simple as that.
- ars 11y ago> I cannot fathom how religious upbringing could make them more altruistic than they are. It probably couldn't. What it can do is take a parent who would not teach such things to their children and make them into a parent who does. What it did do is take a world that did not think that way, and make it into a world that does think that way. The history of the actions of religions is not always "clean" (the in-group out-of-group thing I mentioned), but the history of the thought is, and that influenced the world more than the deed.
- mreiland 11y ago> One thing non-believers report missing the most is a community. Do you have any sort of a citation on that?
- ars 11y agoGoogle atheist church. For example: http://www.reviewjournal.com/life/religion/atheist-church-provides-community-without-supernatural-origin http://www.reviewjournal.com/life/religion/atheist-church-pr... and http://nymag.com/news/features/46214/ http://nymag.com/news/features/46214/
- mreiland 11y agoThat's not really a citation to backup the idea that most non-believers miss a community.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> That's not really a citation to backup the idea that most non-believers miss a community. What was claimed upthread was "One thing non-believers report missing the most is a community." That's a very different claim from what you ask to be defended, "most non-believers miss a community."
- mreiland 11y agoThe only difference in meaning I see in those two statements is the original is more strongly worded (ie, less room for interpretation). The second statement doesn't imply how badly the community is missed, the first explicitly states it's the most missed thing. "most non-believers" also implies a smaller percentage of the group than simply saying "non-believers". No one would say "christians believe dancing is immoral", but they would say "christians believe in God". The reason is the implication is wrong. There are denominations to that do believe dancing is immoral, but it would be more accurate to say "some", or "many". Whereas the second sentence would be considered more accurate since you would probably be hard pressed to find a christian who didn't believe in God. The short and sweet of it is that if he didn't mean to imply most non-believers than he should probably clarify that because the language, as is, very strongly implies it.
- lemming 11y agoHowever there is a definitely a difference with regard to in-group and out-of-group behavior with religious groups, where most of the generosity is directed in-group only. So... not very altruistic, then.