4 ms·
> There's a document at Twitter that lists the schools that Twitter wants to recruit from. This document was penned by Alex Roetter, the Senior VP of engineerin
by geofft 11y ago
> There's a document at Twitter that lists the schools that Twitter wants to recruit from. This document was penned by Alex Roetter, the Senior VP of engineering. He had his other directors contribute to it, modify it and refine it. It listed Cal, Stanford, CMU, Waterloo, MIT, typical schools like that. Never listed any state schools. Never listed any HBCUs. It listed certain companies and excluded certain companies. It excluded certain titles. So if you're a software engineer in tests [an engineering role] at Microsoft, that's not a "real" software engineer. And some of the best engineers I know are software engineers who test for Microsoft!
Leaving aside all ethical questions, it is baffling and sad to see how un-scientific an approach to hiring and staffing we take. This is about pride and self-image; there's zero reason to believe that restricting your hiring to certain universities, certain previous roles, etc. gets you a more effective engineering team. (And I say this as an MIT graduate in software engineering proper.) If anything, being willing to hire from more universities and more career paths gets you different forms of experience, avoiding an engineering monoculture, for less money and time than it takes to participate in the top-university recruiting extravagance or hire away those engineers already in demand.
One of the particularly unfortunate things about the current software industry is that it makes these sorts of policies non-testable. Companies are supposed to compete, but a number of factors, from the wildly inconsistent availability of venture funding, to network effects, to personal connections between founders and people already established in the industry, means the market is remarkably inefficient at determining how productive a company actually was. The fact that Twitter did as well as it did conveys zero information about how much better it could have done. There are so many obvious technical things they screwed up (developer relations, notably) and succeeded despite those failures; it's equally likely that they succeeded despite many of their non-technical decisions instead of because of them.
- netheril96 11y agoThe concentration of talent in other schools are lower, so finding the few talents are harder. Hiring costs, and bad hirings cost a lot, so it may be cost effective not to spend a lot hiring from less-than-stellar schools. Of course this is just a hypothesis. No hard data to back it up.
- brohoolio 11y ago3/4 of our engineers aren't from top tier schools. Several of our best never even graduated.
- threeseed 11y agoEngineering is actually more like an art than a science. It requires creativity, problem solving ability, lateral thinking and a strategic mindset. People who are purely book smart generally don't excel in these areas. I think targeting top schools alone is a pretty misguided strategy.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- striking 11y agoEngineering != computer science, at least not all the time. What you're thinking of is pretty different than engineering which is essentially applied math.
- Technophilis 11y agoThere are relatively easy and cost effective ways to filter candidates from the supposedly less-than-stellar schools. Personal projects, open source projects contributions and programming contests are a good way to easily gauge candidates for a software engineering position.
- smt88 11y ago> programming contests Programming contests aren't anything like actually working at a software company. If you select for the wrong skills, you'll lose lots of good people.
- netheril96 11y agoI once encounter someone on reddit who says he purposefully ignore personal projects and open source projects contributions when making hiring decisions, because he thinks it is a white male privilege.
- paxtonab 11y agoThe college list is interesting especially considering the emphasis many startups (Y-Combinator included) place on hiring hackers, self-taught engineers, etc.
- asdfologist 11y agoI disagree. All companies have only a finite amount of time/money to spend on hiring, so they're often forced to use crude heuristics to filter out resumes, especially in companies that get a huge number of applicants every year, like Twitter. Maybe it's just me, but based on my experience, filtering candidates (as a first pass) based on school or previous role does yield many false positives and negatives, but it still works pretty damn well compared to other equally fast/cheap filtering methods.
- ryandrake 11y agoA couple of things: 1. Limiting your hiring to a tiny set of schools makes about as much sense as only interviewing candidates with names that start with A-F or candidates that come from California. You're just going to end up with a smaller list, not a better list. 2. I thought there was this dire "shortage of engineers", at least that's taken as a given on HN. Why the need for an arbitrary filter?
- asdfologist 11y agoSo you're implying that there's no correlation between academic pedigree and work performance. Maybe that's true, but not what my personal experience would suggest, at least in the realm of software engineering. I'd be happy to change my stance if there's data to the contrary.
- falsestprophet 11y agoGoogle has studied this. http://mobile.nytimes.com/2014/02/23/opinion/sunday/friedman-how-to-get-a-job-at-google.html?_r=1&referrer= http://mobile.nytimes.com/2014/02/23/opinion/sunday/friedman...
- brazzledazzle 11y agoDidn't Google drop their degree requirement entirely?
- mgkimsal 11y ago
- santaclaus 11y ago> It listed Cal, Stanford, CMU, Waterloo, MIT, typical schools like that. Never listed any state schools. Berkeley is a state school. Also, Waterloo is a Canadian public... Edit: Pulling up the US news rankings, 4 of the top 10 are public state schools. So a (pretty horrible) recruitment policy that only hits the top 10 schools from a mostly arbitrary ranking system will still get 40% public state schools.
- tzs 11y ago> This is about pride and self-image; there's zero reason to believe that restricting your hiring to certain universities, certain previous roles, etc. gets you a more effective engineering team. If the description in the article is accurate, the document said they recruit from particular schools, not that they restricted hiring of new graduates to people from those schools. Is anything publicly known about what they do when someone from a school they do not recruit from sends them a resumé?
- geomark 11y agoThis is an important point. I was a hiring manager at a large company. Resources for recruiting activities were not unlimited so choices had to be made. Top schools that helped facilitate the recruiting process were always on the list. We hired from everywhere if the applicant was good. But a lot of good schools were not very organized or proactive in promoting recruiting by employers.