5 ms·
12th year as a postdoc? While I don't think the postdoc system is working very well, this example is not the face of failure of the postdoc system. This examp
by dnautics 11y ago
12th year as a postdoc? While I don't think the postdoc system is working very well, this example is not the face of failure of the postdoc system. This example is a failure of market signals to overcome an individual's sense of entitlement.
- Estragon 11y agoSense of altruism, more like it. I don't see the sense of entitlement in spending years in low-status, low-paying positions to research Alzheimer's.
- dnautics 11y agoyou stay in a postdoc because you think you're entitled to a professorial position. You could advance to a staff scientist position or move on to industry, or just do something else. If you've spent 12 years doing something, it means you were probably a bad experimentalist, really unlucky, or just bad at 'playing the game'. If you're in science and any one of the three above applies, you should quit. The market was trying to tell her that, she didn't get the message, even when her institution forced her out.
- danieltillett 11y agoThere are no real "staff scientist" positions less competitive that an academic position. In regards industry have a look at how many Ph.D.s have been laid off by the pharmaceutical industry in the last 10 years. Not every field has had the run comp sci has had in the last few years.
- dnautics 11y agoI'm a biochemist so I'm aware. After four years of postdoc, I quit my job and drove for Lyft for a year. Now I contract code. So, I read the writing on the wall. And by the way, staff scientist positions are most definitely not as competitive as professor positions.
- giaour 11y agoMaybe every year she received several rejection letters telling her just how close she came to making it. I remember getting a few "you were one of X finalists so please try again next year" letters; they made it really difficult to move to industry and really easy to think that all would work out in my favor if I just stuck around for another year.
- dnautics 11y agoI have gotten that letter for startup accelerators, but never for an academic professor slot position.
- giaour 11y agoI was in the humanities, and maybe the process is different in the sciences, but 3-5 finalists for each position would always be invited for an on-site interview. Your rejection letter might not spell out that you were a finalist, but it was clear from the interview process.
- danieltillett 11y ago>And by the way, staff scientist positions are most definitely not as competitive as professor positions. I did say real staff scientist positions, not temporary postdoc-like positions or admin jobs. There are relatively few true research jobs that are not fixed term outside of academia (I am excluding industry of course as that is a totally different path).
- johncolanduoni 11y agoWorking hard while getting paid peanuts to have a shot at your goal in not exactly what I'd call entitlement. She obviously didn't expect the position to fall into her lap if she thought it was still worth working for it at year 11. I'm not saying it's rational, but it's not like she threw a tantrum when she got turned down.
- chrisseaton 11y agoWhy does it have to be up-or-out? Not everyone can reach the top. What is wrong with working as a mid-level researcher for your whole career?
- robotresearcher 11y agoThe complaint is that the salaries and roles are very bimodal. You're either a postdoc with very low pay and few responsibilities or a prof with pretty good pay running your own lab. There are few roles in-between. There are some - soft money researchers - but these are not as common as they might be.
- chrisseaton 11y agoThere's a whole structured career ladder between those two roles. I guess it takes most people at least a decade after they finish their last post-doc before they become a professor. During that time you have fellowships, lecturerships, readerships, with increasing pay and responsibilities.
- robotresearcher 11y agoThose are the UK-derived names. In North America those are all referred to informally as 'professor'. Even the lowest, Assistant Professor, is usually expected to run their own lab. Many people don't ever make full Professor. edit: and the jump in pay and responsibility from postdoc to assistant prof is huge - maybe a factor of 2 in pay. The rest is incremental.