5 ms·
Poems by the man who romanticized the colonization of my grandparents' country are always cool, but the logic doesn't hold up. If you're not as well-armed as th
by geofft 11y ago
Poems by the man who romanticized the colonization of my grandparents' country are always cool, but the logic doesn't hold up. If you're not as well-armed as the British Empire, and you very much do not have the resources to defeat the Dane, it's nice that the end of the game is oppression and shame, but you're going to lose well before you even get to endgame.
- SHIT_TALKER 11y agoThe British created your grandparents' country and you should be thankful to them for it. It was nothing but fortunate for India to have sensible men like Charles James Napier working to put an end to barbarism like Sati: A story for which Napier is often noted involved Hindu priests complaining to him about the prohibition of Sati by British authorities. This was the custom of burning a widow alive on the funeral pyre of her husband. As first recounted by his brother William, he replied: "Be it so. This burning of widows is your custom; prepare the funeral pile. But my nation has also a custom. When men burn women alive we hang them, and confiscate all their property. My carpenters shall therefore erect gibbets on which to hang all concerned when the widow is consumed. Let us all act according to national customs."[1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_James_Napier#Service_in_India https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_James_Napier#Service_i...
- jacquesm 11y agoThe fact that colonialism had some beneficial side-effects does not make it right and does not oblige anybody to be thankful.
- SHIT_TALKER 11y agoWhen you are weak, you take what you can get. It was much better to have been colonized by the British, who actually had an interest in nation-building and respect for law and human rights (to the extent they deemed their subjects capable of handling them), than, say, to have become the personal fiefdom of Leopold II of Belgium.
- jacquesm 11y agoThat's a false dichotomy if there ever was one. The alternative to being colonized by the British was not to be colonized by Belgium but not to be colonized at all.
- SHIT_TALKER 11y agoOnly if there was a universe in which India would have not have been colonized, which there was not. Ergo, no false dichotomy. They got a pretty good deal, all told.
- newjersey 11y agoIt is arguable that India benefitted from being under British rule compared to be in under the rule of mad Moghal emperors though. I'd say gp was not a false dichotomy. Of the options available, British rule was not the worst possible outcome in hindsight. To my Indian friends, please be wary of ultranationalism and the far right. It never does anyone any good. Just look at us and learn from US' shortcomings.
- SHIT_TALKER 11y agoIt is amusing to see English-speaking Indians pulling down healthy salaries working in the American tech sector so adamant about the evils of British colonialism and how much it allegedly retarded their country's progress.
- ekianjo 11y ago> was not to be colonized by Belgium but not to be colonized at all. There was no such alternative if you were a weak, divided nation in the first place. Please look at what happened in other places with a similar situation (even China during a long time). Once the European nations stopped fighting each other they looked for other territories to conquer at the time - and this, by the way, not limited the the recent world history at all. Territorial conquest is something that started that was documented even in Antiquity, although we did not call it colonization then. Most countries have been colonized many times and there's almost no connection nowadays between the actual "natives" and whoever is currently ruling.
- ashishchaudhary 11y agoWhat you say is true to your name. Take a look at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f7CW7S0zxv4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f7CW7S0zxv4
- SHIT_TALKER 11y agoWhat utter nonsense. Do the Romans likewise owe reparations to the Turks, French, Spanish, and English?
- geofft 11y agoNapier is one of my favorite historical figures, but wasn't sati banned based on the requests of (native) Hindu reformers, and Napier merely spoke in favor of the ban when other Hindu priests complained? It seems like a stretch to argue that it was Napier who worked to put an end to sati.
- SHIT_TALKER 11y agoNone of the other sensible men like Napier gave such a pithy and powerful quote on the topic.
- geofft 11y agoAh, yes, pithy and powerful quotes! I should be thankful for colonialism for providing pithy and powerful quotes. Take up the white man's burden of speechwriting. Seriously, there are much better arguments for the position you're espousing. I can come up with half a dozen without trying. If you're really interested in contributing to discourse, try making them.
- SHIT_TALKER 11y agoThe topic was the banning of Sati. It was just one example of the benefits of British rule. That it is such a salutary example is why I mentioned it. You are welcome to keep crying on Twitter that people said things you don't like but I have nothing further to say to you.
- geofft 11y agoIt's not even close to salutary. You can't defend your point, that's why you have nothing further to say to me. You are wrong on the facts, and you don't even know how to lose an argument graciously.
- SHIT_TALKER 11y agoWhat argument is there to be had with someone who will not even admit the elimination of the ritual immolation of widows as a salutary benefit of colonial rule? There's clearly no reason involved in such a stance but simply reflexive chauvinism.
- littletimmy 11y agoIf you are talking about India, it wasn't a "country" before the British. It was a mixture of disparate kingdoms and sultanates. Not to mention that before the British, most of India was under Muslim colonizers i.e. the Mughals. The Indians have always been a conquered people, it is only in the last 70 years that they have had freedom; you should thank the British for it.
- adiM 11y agoThe Mughals were not colonizers. The definition of a colony is: "country or area under the full or partial political control of another country". The Mughals were ousted from Central Asia; India was the only country they ruled. So, by definition, they were not colonizers. India had been ruled by kings who were not originally from India. But, nothing in the history compared to the "loot" of the British (see http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/mar/04/east-india-company-original-corporate-raiders http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/mar/04/east-india-comp...)
- akamaka 11y agoYour comment may be factual, but you could have skipped the "you should be thankful" bit. It's quite a rude thing to say to someone you don't know.
- zo1 11y agoThat's not the context the OP used... It was: "you should thank", not "you should be thankful". A very subtle difference, but in this case (to you), it's the difference between offending and not.
- akamaka 11y agoI think both wordings are rude, particularly because of the word "you". OP doesn't know anything about his family's history. It's different from making a general argument that talks about the benefit to the whole country.
- srean 11y ago
- tomjen3 11y agoYou do realize why the British called it the "dane geld" and not tribute right? Because the Dane used to plounder the English and demand gold to go away, and the English learned to their sorrow what happens when you pay the dane geld. And I say that as a Dane.
- treenyc 11y agoThis is told to me by a Danish classmate (while intoxicated at a party). He asked me: do you know why we say "Skull" when we drink? I said: No I don't. He Said: Well, back then during the Viking times. The Danes would fight all the way to the kingdom and cut the off the Skulls of the English princes; Dump out their brains and use the skull as cup for drinks. Hence the word "Skull". I said: Huh? Interesting! "And then we also took all their good looking women. And that's why all the Danish girls are soo good looking" Add him. You got love the Danish people!
- teddyh 11y agoThat is all bullshit. The word is not “Skull”, it is “Skål”, and it is a normal noun, meaning “Bowl”.
- kawsper 11y agoThere is a lot of debate about the origins of the word, and the skull story is a nice (but brutal) party story. Let me give you another version. Back in the days people were drinking off bowls, instead of cups as we do today. And guess what the danish word for bowl is? "Skål". A "skål" is a flat version of "trebolle". You can see one if you Google Image search for "trebolle" to get an idea of how it looks.