3 ms·
You misunderstood what I said about Google. I still don't care about the ads shown by Google (I run my ad blocker just the same). What I meant is that at least
by rglullis 11y ago
You misunderstood what I said about Google. I still don't care about the ads shown by Google (I run my ad blocker just the same). What I meant is that at least you have a point that Google can be more effective, for the reasons you mentioned. And if that is "as good as it gets", why should let other business take for granted that all they need is to get eyeballs and the ad money will come? It makes no sense.
Also... please, Buzzfeed partnering with the White House is a sign of "quality news"? The quote "If you want something in the paper, that’s advertising; you want something kept out, that’s news" comes to mind.
> It's FAR better to have democratic and free access to content rather than tying it to direct payments and vastly limiting access and amount. That is going backwards to the entire intent of the internet and the spread of information.
That is a false dichotomy. You can get free access to content without relying on ads as your revenue stream. Wikipedia is not a business and does it. Stackoverflow is a business and uses the careers site as the main revenue source. We don't need an "Ads industry" to have quality content.
- manigandham 11y ago1) Eyeballs = attention = what advertising is all about. Relevancy is a way to target to make best use of that attention but it's not required. 2) Why don't you actually read some of the BuzzFeed news: http://www.buzzfeed.com/news http://www.buzzfeed.com/news They have writers from NYT and WSJ amongst others on their staff. Put aside your prejudice and actually see for yourself. 3) Wikipedia isn't a business, but their business arm Wikia makes all their money on advertising. StackExchange makes all their money on advertising (those job postings are ads and other banners on their site). However both companies are not in the content business because all their content is user generated. That's why they have no costs other than technical upkeep. A real content business requires people to actually create that content so your examples aren't relevant. Sure we can replace everything with direct subscriptions but that doesn't scale and severely limits the access to and quantity of content available. Those are the facts in the industry, there's no denying that, no matter how much you hate ads.
- rglullis 11y ago>> Why don't you actually read some of the BuzzFeed news: http://www.buzzfeed.com/news http://www.buzzfeed.com/news I did. Sorry to tell you, but they seem as "hard news" as CNN. It is infotainment. Most of the topics are still about what is popular, what can generate clicks and what can polarize. There is nothing in there that I feel I would pay to see investigated, studied or analyzed. (1) and (3) The point I am trying to get across is that any kind of business is supposed to exist to support some kind of need for society. The "advertising industry" only fulfills any social utlity when it manages to efficiently connect producers to their target consumer. If to do that, it needs to steal attention from people, it is not doing its job properly. If the "advertising industry" ends up providing a system that makes people consume only things from the producers with more capital, instead of the best product, then the industry is not doing its job properly. If the "advertising industry" ends up creating by collateral a huge mass of well educated people that depend on this "meta-work" of producing content that can be pass for journalism or entertainment, then it fails to fulfill its social function. >> Wikipedia isn't a business, but their business arm Wikia makes all their money on advertising. Society benefits from something like wikipedia. I can donate $25/year like I do to Wikipedia, and hope that enough people will contribute to it to keep it running. Good thing that Wikia can bring some funds and not have to rely on many more people. But if Wikia ceased to exist, people can still find ways to keep wikipedia around. If society loses wikipedia, we would lose a lot. Now, if for some reason Wikia was not being profitable, do you really think society would be worse off? Perhaps for historical and cultural reasons, it would be bad to lose it - just look at all the work from the archive.org people. But look at Geocities: do you think society is that worse off without it? Would we be worse off without Wikia? >> Eyeballs = attention = what advertising is all about. To come back to my point: I do believe that there are cases where business manage to provide the social function of advertising (establish a communication channel between producers and consumers), but this "produce content and try to monetize it" with ads is not one such case. - The content that gets produced is of dubious quality (because the focus of the content producer is not in the quality of the content, rather how much of the people's attention it can grab) - There is no real connection between content producer and the producer paying for ads. So content producers may end up becoming crap-pushers without even knowing. - It makes for an uneven field for smaller producers. We live in an era where the cost of producing, processing and distributing information is almost zero. The balance of power could be completely in favor of the people. We HAVE the means of production of wealth in our hands. But because of advertising, we give this power back to the Capital owners. You describe your work as a "marketing platform for top brands". Let me tell you one thing: I WANT BRANDS TO BE DESTROYED. There is no real value in brands, except for the brand owners. They stiffle innovation. They created consumerism as a lifestyle. I am all for free-market and minimal intervention on business. But you state a equation like this one where "attention" as something that can be extracted value from WHEN IT IS NOT FUCKING YOURS! It is immoral and you don't even see it.