5 ms·
Chinese entrepreneurs, investors on Google: ‘Just quit. We don’t care.’
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- varjag 17y agoQuite predictable. What should've one expected from them, support for Google's move and criticism of Chinese government? These people have their lives, families and business there, on the mercy of officials. The last section on opinions from Chinese entrepreneurs who moved out to the States is also telling..
- garply 17y agoI think you should also consider the possibility that the Chinese entrepreneurs are speaking sincerely - while I know many natives (particularly among the white collar workers) here in China who find the gov't obnoxious, I also know many educated, intelligent people who would agree with these statements. And when you consider the statements of Chinese expats about the Chinese government - you have to expect an anti-Chinese government bias (merited by the government or not) in their views. I mean, they left China for a reason. It's a little like asking political exiles from Iran whether they like the Iranian government or not. In short, I don't think it's reasonable to completely toss out the statements of the people who haven't left China and focus only on the statements of the self-selecting population who have made a concerted effort to leave.
- bilbo0s 17y agoIn the military this was called 'incestuous amplification', I don't know what the civilian term for it is. We tend to lend more credence and legitimacy to that portion of a population that agrees with our own views. Be very careful about falling prey to it. It has actually cost the US military dearly over the past 8 or 9 years. There are actually far reaching initiatives being pursued, at all levels of the military, to mitigate its effect with respect to groupthink in the future.
- lmkg 17y agoYou're quite right that they could be telling their honest opinion. The point is, we can't tell anything about their honest opinions based on what they say. If they think X, they say X. If they think ~X, they say X. Therefore, when they say X, we gain no information.
- potatolicious 17y agoBeing Chinese (Taiwanese to be specific) myself and knowing many Chinese people, I have to say it's more likely they are speaking the truth than not. This comes down to a matter of national pride: most Chinese care deeply about the pride of their nation, and the new generation (the ones that grew up under the current regime) seem to be incapable of separating the Chinese identity from the Chinese Communist Party. So, when criticism falls upon the government, even perfectly valid criticism, there is a perceived need to defend the government - since in their mind the government is the people. This false association causes a lot of problems, since it removes rational discourse. The new generation of Chinese have an immense amount of national pride, and IMHO this is going to be the biggest problem we face in the future.
- JunkDNA 17y ago"I also talked to a few Chinese expatriates who had left the country for the U.S. and met with the delegation. They only wanted to publish their first names because they were worried about making critical comments of the government publicly." This cuts to the heart of the problem right here. We often take it for granted in the US (and in other similarly structured socieities as well) that we can be critical of the government and not face retribution. Heck, there are people who make entire careers out of it. In open societies we have vigorous debates about how to structure rules and regulations (i.e. "net neutrality"). Markets require that sort of public debate so investors and companies can make informed decisions.
- cia_plant 17y agoIt is often taken for granted that you can seriously challenge the US government without any retribution, by people who have never seriously challenged the US government.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- JunkDNA 17y agoI'm sorry, but every day hundreds of newspapers and magazines devote pages and pages to honest critique of the government. Add to that all the commentary on television, radio, and the net. The vast majority of those individuals partake in the discussion without the slightest bit of fear that a bunch of thugs are going to put them in prison for years. I'm not saying abuses don't happen. But the government is not formally organized to go after them.
- RK 17y agoA few months after a Chinese friend of mine came to the US in 2004 I asked him about some things like Taiwan, voting in China, and the free movement of people within China. The answers he gave me sounded like straight up propaganda (e.g. Taiwan is just a problem caused by the US government). About a year later I asked him some of the same questions and his answers were completely different. I think he had come to realize that in the US he could say whatever he wanted without worrying. It was rather eye-opening.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- rfreytag 17y agoGoogle thus announces publicly that its results are not filtered. If you are in the largest growth market (China) and can get to Google (you can somehow) then you will get authoritative results. Brilliant move. Ethics are good business. Should have done it sooner.
- jsm386 17y agoI think this is pretty predictable. There was an opinion piece by a Fellow at the Open Society Institute in the WSJ yesterday that explained this mindset. The entire piece is worth a read, but here are the two relevant excerpts: "One night in the mid-1990s when I was working as a journalist in Beijing, I went out to dinner with some Chinese friends. I had just finished reading a book called "The File" by the British historian Timothy Garton Ash. It's about what happened in East Berlin after the Berlin Wall came down and everybody could see the files the Stasi had been keeping all those years. People discovered who had been ratting on whom-in some cases neighbors and co-workers, but also lovers, spouses and even children. After I described the book to my Chinese dinner companions-a hip and artsy intellectual crowd-one friend declared: "Some day the same thing will happen in China, then I'll know who my real friends are." The table went silent. ... I do believe, however, that in my lifetime the Chinese people may learn more about some of the conversations that have taken place over the past decade between Internet company executives and Chinese authorities. When that happens, they will know who sold them out and who was most eager to help the Chinese Communist Party in building a blinkered cocoon of disinformation around their lives-and in some cases deaths. This censored environment makes it easier for the Chinese government to lie to its people, steal from them, turn a blind eye when they are poisoned with tainted foodstuffs, and cover up their children's deaths due to substandard building codes. It is a constant struggle, and sometimes literally a crime, for people to share information about such matters or to use the Internet to mobilize against corruption and malfeasance. That is the information environment that China's business elites, many of whom have gotten rich running Internet and telecommunications companies, are responsible for helping to build and maintain. For now they are national heroes, having made great (and lucrative) efforts on behalf of China's economic growth and global competitiveness, making China a force to be reckoned with on the global stage. But if history takes some unexpected turns-and that's the one thing you can count on Chinese history doing-it won't always be on their side." Source: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704362004575000442815795122.html http://online.wsj.com/article/SB1000142405274870436200457500...
- jerf 17y ago'After I described the book to my Chinese dinner companions-a hip and artsy intellectual crowd-one friend declared: "Some day the same thing will happen in China, then I'll know who my real friends are."' Sometimes I think people misunderstand why police states are evil. It isn't that it oppresses this group, or that group. It oppresses everyone. From the lowliest peon to the person putatively at the top, everyone must watch their step. Some people seem anxious to set up police states because they think they will be in the oppressor class rather than the oppressed class, but there isn't an oppressor class, just varying degrees of oppression. (I don't mean some people here on HN, I just mean in general.) As wonder as it may seem to be Chavez or Kim Jong-il, they find their hands pretty tied by the system they've created too.
- Pahalial 17y agoI found it telling that not a single one of them talked about the coordinated attacks - at most they mentioned the censorship.
- angelbob 17y agoWow. That's a good point.
- sgk284 17y agoYou'll find that not a single Chinese media/news source mentions the attacks. Most Chinese people don't even know they happened, the only side of the story they are aware of is that "Google doesn't want to follow our laws." The other funny thing is that when censorship is mentioned, everywhere I've seen it elaborated on in Chinese media simply says something to the effect of "Without the Chinese government stepping in, Google returned too much pornography with search results." and never dares to imply that the Chinese government is hiding information or manipulating what they are allowed to know. It's really unfortunate... many Chinese have too much blind faith in their government (not that it's their fault, everything about the culture encourages it).
- huherto 17y agoNot entirely on topic and kind of obvious. But, China has made great advances on economic growth. But they have a huge debt on social freedoms. We will see in the next years how much economic growth can be sustained in that environment. I am curious if China will opt to open up, may be slowing growth in the short term but giving viability on the long term. Or if they will insist on the current model. I don't think there is a single instance on the history of humanity of a country to become fully developed without the corresponding social freedoms. May be China will be the first case.
- marze 17y ago'officials brushed off Google’s threat, saying that “effective guidance of public opinion on the Internet is an important way of protecting the security of online information” ' Classic doublespeak.