4 ms·
If you hand pick your data set, you can probably show anything you want. I remember reading about the stock market, that if you just shift the starting and end
by Tichy 17y ago
If you hand pick your data set, you can probably show anything you want. I remember reading about the stock market, that if you just shift the starting and end points of "measurements" (for example about your fund's value), you could always claim an x% increase over the last y years.
So this here is an interesting data point - but it really is just that.
I wouldn't be surprised if there were places on earth where temperatures have been falling steadily, or have been rising or falling by extreme amounts.
- paulodeon 17y agoI think the point is that this is simply the best dataset out there, it hasn't been cherry-picked. The only problem with this article is that there is no mention of how the gulfstream could have had a stabilising effect. The 30 year periods aren't cherry-picked either, they are picked because they were the ones with the greatest increase in temperature.
- fnargle 17y ago"The 30 year periods aren't cherry-picked either, they are picked because they were the ones with the greatest increase in temperature." Lol. If that's not it, would you mind explaining to me exactly what you think cherry-picking is?
- Tichy 17y agoIt seems to be one data set from one location. How can this be "the best data set" out there? I don't think looking at one location is sufficient at all.
- Retric 17y agoIf you are going to measure a dataset by its completeness and its length you are going to find it's the best based on that scale. However, if you want to define some other scale which cares less about those factors and more about geographic coverage feel free, but don't try to mix there definition with yours because your "best" will be less compleat or cover a shorter period. PS: If you feel some other dataset would be a better proxy feel free to argue the point on its own merits. But be careful when you start to redefine the terms someone else is using, it has little to do with their argument and is not useful.
- Tichy 17y agoI have nothing against the data set as such - I think it is great if such a complete data set exists. All I am saying is that a data set from one location is not sufficient to calculate the climate of the whole planet. It is one data set among many, which happens to be especially complete.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- jgrahamc 17y agoLet me use your reply as an opportunity to make points I've made in a heated fashion elsewhere on this thread more calmly: 1. It's not clear that CET is a proxy for global temperatures. 2. If CET is a good proxy (and that could be easily checked from the Met Office data) then fast warming in the past needs to be explained to be sure that we are seeing something anomalous now. 3. This Daily Telegraph claims that man-made global warming is refuted by the CET. I don't believe that to be true. It may be questioned by the data, but questioning is within the realms of science. 4. The original blog posting makes the claim "since we've seen 30 years of warming in the past that are faster than the last 30 years of warming there's nothing to worry about". The last part is not correct. If this is correct (modulo #1) then we need to determine what was causing warming in the past compared to today.
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoIf you shift the end point you cannot make any claim about the last y years, because the last y years always end at the beginning of the current year. What he did is to take the entire dataset, not some selected part of it. And there aren't many places on earth for which long term measurements even exist. So selecting this particular dataset seems plausible enough to me. On the other hand I would like to hear the counter arguments as well, because if this is such an important dataset, proponents of AGW will have an opinion on it. There may be a good counter argument.
- Tichy 17y agoShifting the end point was an example from the stock market (I think I remember better now: to make your fund look good, you can almost always find a point in the past from where you made earnings relative to today). It was just an example of hand picking data to prove what you want. I have nothing against this particular data set. I just doubt that it is all that relevant in the bigger picture. It is just another data point that can be fed into models and whatnot.
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoIt may be an example from the stock market but it's not an example for what the author of the article did. He did not select an arbitrary period. I don't know anything about the relevance of the dataset, so maybe you're right, but I suspect that the dataset is important because no other country I know of has reliable records going back that far.
- Tichy 17y agoHe did not select an arbitrary period, but an arbitrary place. For example, recently there was a post on HN about the current cold wave. Turns out while it was very cold in Europe, at the same time it was very warm in the arctic. It would be interesting to look at the data from central England and see what kind of results one could get by cherry picking individual weather stations.