4 ms·
The training thing is addressed in the article, as near as historians can tell when facing soviet pilots the kill ratio was 1.4 to 1 (favouring the Sabre) but r
by noir_lord 11y ago
The training thing is addressed in the article, as near as historians can tell when facing soviet pilots the kill ratio was 1.4 to 1 (favouring the Sabre) but rose to 9:1 when flying against non-soviet pilots.
> The Mig-29, SU-27 and on are solid first class fighters and probably have the edge on the F-16 and F-15.
As a pure dog fighting aircraft possibly but as an air intercept fighter I think the F15 (with the except of the F22 and the EF2000) is still the thing to beat.
- lujim 11y agoProbably true. The f15 has shot down a satellite, landed without one of it's wings, and has never lost a fight. Not bad for something that first flew 43 years ago.
- noir_lord 11y agoThe F15 is an interesting story, it was created in part as a reaction to the terrifying intelligence they had about the Mig25, they went all out to create something to beat something that turned out not to exist in a sense (The Mig-25 existed of course but it's actual characteristics where very different to what intelligence suggested, it was big and fast and that was about it, if it ran at full speed the engines ate themselves). In doing so they created the best air intercept fighter of it's generation and a design that is still considered premier-tier, the US consider it obsolete because it lacks stealth but not every country has fully adopted the stealth mantra (the Russians never really did or possibly didn't have the manufacturing capability). It will be interesting to see if they continue it's development, there where nominal plans for new variant called the Silent Eagle which adopted some radar reduction measures and upgraded it's electronics to state of the art, I think once you except stealth that we are at a point with fighters where the airframe is secondary to the avionics and weapons, they all have the capability to kill the pilot from G forces so maneuverability isn't really an issue anymore. It's interesting to see what the Indians have done with their Mig-21 upgrade program, with modern avionics and weapons it's reputedly as potent as a middle-bloc F16 which considering that's a 60 year old air frame design is incredible.
- spacehome 11y agoits
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ta0967 11y agohave an upvote, it's missing its goal of communication with its confusion of "it's" and "its".
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- nl 11y agoNo, "it's" is correct. It is a contraction of it is, used appropriately in this context. http://grammarist.com/spelling/its-its/ http://grammarist.com/spelling/its-its/
- kwhitefoot 11y agoOnly in the last sentence.
- spacehome 11y ago> The Mig-25 existed of course but it's actual characteristics where very different to what intelligence suggested ... You're saying this should read "... but it is actual characteristics ..."?
- nl 11y agoI'd pretty much agree about the F15, but I do think that the F14 is underrated in the role[1]. It certainly seemed much better in its day than the Super Hornet (aka "shit the F35 still isn't ready. Please give us something. Anything.") is today. I guess the Super Hornet is better than the old Hornet though. [1] http://theaviationist.com/2014/08/18/the-story-of-a-legendary-f-14-pilot-and-the-gun-kill-on-an-f-15-that-could-sell-tomcat-to-japan/ http://theaviationist.com/2014/08/18/the-story-of-a-legendar...
- noir_lord 11y agoSuperhornet still doesn't have the range the F14 had, paired with the Phoenix missile that thing was incredible (and expensive).
- cstross 11y agoF14/Phoenix was a fleet defense weapon -- horribly expensive and intensive to operate, intended to stop long-range Soviet bombers from griefing the carrier battle groups (Tu-22Ms and Tu-160s with Moskit or similar supersonic anti-shipping missiles are a carrier captain's nightmare). Once the cold war went away there wasn't really anyone left who offered that kind of credible threat, and attempts to turn the F14 into a bomber were more expensive and less effective than the F/A18. Today, there is one aicraft/missile in service with roughly comparable performance to the F14/Phoenix -- the Eurofighter Typhoon II when equipped with the (similar range to Phoenix) Meteor missile. This isn't an accident. One of the major purchasers for Typhoon is the UK, satirically renamed "Airstrip One" by George Orwell in 1984; because it's basically an unsinkable aircraft carrier off the coast of Western Europe, and in event of a conflict with Russia it'd be a major NATO logistical resupply target for the aforementioned TU-23Ms and Tu-160s. The Typhoon II was delayed into the 21st century but basically it started as a cold war solution to the exact same problem as the F14, minus the cats and traps.
- noir_lord 11y agoAlso we are currently building two supercarrier's so the Meteor missile will probably end up on the F35, it's a hell of a missile. Not just a purchaser of the EF, we co-built it with the Germans/Italians as part of a consortium.