11 ms·
ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway
- Matheus28 11y agoThat's really not smart. By paying it up you just incentive them to do it more often. Not only to yourself but to other websites.
- hodwik 11y agoBut if it buys you time to upgrade your infrastructure it could be worth it.
- sarciszewski 11y agoNo, it's not worth it.
- Matheus28 11y agoIt's never worth it. For $6k you can get actual protection for some time before you upgrade your infrastructure.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoIsn't Cloudfare around $2,000 a month with no data caps for high-end package with $50 a month for low end? I know reasons why some people avoid them but I figure there's a similar service in Switzerland that just costs a bit more. That might be what they're referring to for $100,000. I'm curious.
- vabmit 11y agoFor a site the size of ProtonMail, $6K is the cost for protection for a single month. Most of the companies that offer this kind of protection require you to sign a one to three year contract. There are two kinds of protection, basic HTTP/HTTPS and DNS only (done with DNS and CDN like servers co-located at peering points), and traffic filtering that is done through BGP with and a GRE tunnel. While you can get basic HTTP/HTTPS and DNS from CloudFlare for $200/month on a business account, what ProtonMail needed was a BGP/GRE which at it's lowest price is a multiple and an order of magnitude more expensive.
- pdkl95 11y agoPaying ransom is never worth the long-term costs. Once you've proven to the criminal that you're someone who will pay, they usually try again in the future because you're an easy mark. Not only that, there is a power imbalance that shouldn't be ignored: the criminal has more experience in these kinds of confrontations than you do. Sam Harris has a very good article on this topic[1]; while he is discussing violent interactions on a personal level (e.g. mugging), the principles apply to many situations. The short version is that the criminal is trying to draw you onto their turf and to play by their rules. Almost always you will only make your situation worse when you let the criminal set the rules. [1] http://www.samharris.org/blog/item/the-truth-about-violence http://www.samharris.org/blog/item/the-truth-about-violence
- jessriedel 11y ago> Paying ransom is never worth the long-term costs. I am amazed about how many people are making this claim confidently in this thread. It's clearly wrong. Very, very often it's definitely worth the cost, because very often you will never see the same criminal again. Consider: "Don't pay ransoms, because (1) you'll get extorted again once the criminal knows you're an easy mark and (2) if everyone always refuses to pay, criminals will have no incentives to try and extort." versus "Don't pay muggers, because (1) you'll get mugged again once the mugger knows you're an easy mark and (2) if everyone always refuses to pay muggers, muggers will have no incentive to mug." Yes there are cases, like if you're the government, where you are very long-lived and your reputation is reliable such that having a stated, followed policy of not being extorted works. But for individuals, it's just not feasible most of the time. You probably won't see that mugger/extorter ever again, and it's very unlikely that most victims will refuse.
- jacquesm 11y agoMuggers are typically not going to come across the same victim twice and word does not spread that you are 'an easy mark'. So the advice to people being mugged is to simply give your stuff rather than to try to put up a fight. But extortion is different than mugging. See, in extortion you have a perceived weakness other than that you fear for your life and that weakness has subscription possibilities, unlike mugging people. For instance one simple defence against muggers would be to have nothing on your person. Hard to mug you in that case. But since the ransom victim can't really change the nature of his business (short of removing themselves from being online) they will always be open to a replay. Individuals are not the parties being extorted here, it's companies with some degree of success and visibility. I pretty much guarantee you that every larger entity online has either been prodded by extortionists or will be prodded in the near future. This is a very large business and everybody that pays makes it a bigger issue because of the perceived easy money drawing in ever more prospective extortionists. Muggers != extortionists. Blackmailers are extortionists and they always come back until they get stopped through some other means (for instance the authorities) or until you tell them to do their worst. In the case of one Dutch bank this led to intermittent outages over the course of several weeks but eventually they got things under control and there hasn't been a problem since. If on the other hand they had paid I'm pretty sure that they'd be paying a nice monthly protection fee. "It'd be a terrible thing if something happened to that nice website of yours.", it's just the same tactic as the mob employs against shops.
- onewaystreet 11y agoThis is the first case I've seen where a digital blackmailer didn't follow through with their promise. It's bad for business for them to renege as it increases the chance that their next victim wont pay.
- Matheus28 11y agoFrom what it seems, there were two DDoSers. The ones they paid to, did stop DDoSing, but the other one is unknown and is still doing it. The first one did contact them and tell them that they had already stopped DDoSing.
- stingraycharles 11y agoThe article states that it was most likely two different attackers, due to the different methods used and the blackmailer denying responsibility for the comtinued (unsophisticated) attack. I'm not sure what to think, but I can easily understand why they did pay. It's easy for others to say what would be best for the industry, but when you are the one suffering and your ISP is angry at you, and you can pay a small sum to (possibly) make the problem go away, your opinion will change.
- meowface 11y agoThe original DDoSers actually did honor the ransom and stop their attack. However, another group started hitting them after the ransom was paid. Probably because they just advertised themselves as people who will reward DDoS attacks.
- jacquesm 11y agoOf course. That's what any clever criminal would do, if they pay up once chances are they'll pay up again. My ISP was hit like this a few months ago and sent out an email outlining the situation to their customers before the second wave began to give us a heads up and very clearly stated they had absolutely no intention of paying whatever would happen and that's the only acceptable stance and I as their customer fully supported them in this decision and would have left if they had decided otherwise. Props to cloudflare for standing by to help out in that particular instance, absolutely fantastic.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- zzleeper 11y agoLoved the comment at the bottom: 'So basically ProtonMail said "We're incompetent and fund criminals… give us money."'
- Matheus28 11y agoThere's another good one: "ProtonMail should apply for a refund. Or at least store credit."
- blondie9x 11y agoWasn't able to get on site earlier at protonmail.ch
- donatj 11y agoGod, why? That's utter incompetence. Never pay ransoms. This has highly lowered my opinion of ProntoMail.
- c0nducktr 11y agoYeah, I'd be upset if I were one of the people who donated and found that's what they did with the money.
- babuskov 11y agoI know you mistyped it, but ProntoMail really sounds cool.
- donatj 11y agoMight have been autocorrect on my phone but I'm leaving it now.
- brongondwana 11y agoAll rights Reserved, Mailcentro, Inc Copyright © 2002-2013 (damn, it does sound like a cool domain)
- mikegirouard 11y agoI'm reminded of a similar article on ransoms and FBI's strange advice to pay up. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10482242 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10482242 I think this is a good example of why this is bad advice.
- meowface 11y agoRansomware is a different scenario. With ransomware, if you have no backups and absolutely need your files back, paying the ransom is the only sane option. Of course, this can easily be prevented by taking frequent backups. With a DDoS, there are almost no advantages to paying the ransom. Much better to spend the money on DDoS mitigation instead, to help now and in the future. Also, the FBI wasn't making an official statement. It was just an off-hand remark from an agent, recommending technically ignorant people who desperately want their files back to pay the ransom.
- squidlogic 11y agoAgreed. The difference is that with ransomware the act has already been done. You can think of it as negotiating with kidnappers vs. paying off the mob to not rough up your shop.
- meowface 11y agoExactly, that's a perfect analogy. If someone kidnapped your child, paying the ransom isn't such a bad idea.
- cm2187 11y agoIn fact backups is not enough. It has to be offline backups, which raises the bar quite a bit. Backing up to a network drive doesn't even help, and I am not aware of any wildly used "write once-only" network drive capabilities.
- meowface 11y agoBackup to an external hard drive that you only leave connected during the backup, or a cloud service (ransomware could theoretically target these but so far have not), or do a "pull-style" backup where the machine doesn't have write access to the backup location.
- jacquesm 11y agoNEVER EVER PAY RANSOM MONEY. Please. Even if your business will suffer it will suffer a lot more if you do pay since now it is known you'll cave. Also: you are making the problem larger for others.
- lqdc13 11y agoI think cryptolocker actually decrypted the FS after the ransom was paid. So sometimes it works. Actually, it makes no sense to not follow through because that is their business model.
- jacquesm 11y agoLet me make a spam analogy: the reason we are drowning in spam is because it works. If even 0.00001% of the spam recipients enters into a financially beneficial relationship with the spammers then everybody will get spammed. The only way spam will go away is if everybody will finally stop responding to spam. So you just simply do not pay extortion fees unless you want to become part of the problem. In the case of an encrypted filesystem that means you will have to restore from a back-up (which I assume (naively maybe) that you have). And you chalk the whole thing up to your education fund. Paying up is simply wrong.
- jessriedel 11y ago> The only way spam will go away is if everybody will finally stop responding to spam. Right, which is why "never pay extortion fees" doesn't make much more sense for combatting this stuff than "never click on spam links" makes for combating spam. It's unrealistic to think we will convince enough businesses to altruistically not pay extortionists, just like it's unrealistic to think you'll get your grandmother to stop clicking on spam links. You need another solution.
- jacquesm 11y agoThere is nothing altruistic about businesses not paying extortionists. Sure they may come to (some, hopefully limited) harm. But once you as a business pay an extortionist you have just taken on another partner in your business, who will do none of the work and who will take almost all of your profits. So paying out of pragmatism will actually have the exact opposite effect of what you intend to achieve (to make the problem go away). A good parasite does not kill the host, merely takes all the resources they can get and it certainly won't stop with one attempt at extortion. And judging from the blog post linked they learned their lesson. edited for clarity, thanks ghotifish.
- lifeformed 11y agoI don't understand why the attackers wouldn't stop? Why would they want to build up a reputation of not being worth paying? If they were always true to the word, then people would mostly always pay.
- jacquesm 11y agoDifferent shark. Once there is blood in the water there'll be more.
- ThinkBeat 11y agoQuite a few companies do pay ransoms that is not unusual In fact is 100% of people never paid a ransom the attacks would not be funded Publicly speaking about paying ransoms is very unusual.
- shocks 11y agoRunbox have also been under DDoS ransom too [1], although they appear to have handled it well because I haven't noticed any down time. 1: https://blog.runbox.com/2015/11/ddos-attacks-on-runbox/ https://blog.runbox.com/2015/11/ddos-attacks-on-runbox/
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- rdl 11y agoThe only thing worse than paying a ransom is publicly announcing you've paid a ransom.
- gozo 11y agoI guess by publicly announcing that they paid ransom that "didn't work" they have slightly undermined the trust for ransom as a solution in cases like this. So it might be correct from a game theory perspective, if you disregard any decrease in trust for themselves that is.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoThere's regular security solutions then there's those meant to stop High Strength Attackers. I warned ProtonMail's team and infrastructure wouldn't handle the latter. I was expecting stealth 0-days, though, given there's DDOS mitigations available. That they went down due to DDOS was a bit of a surprise. "Cost estimates for these solutions are around $100,000 per year since there are few service providers able to fight off an attack of this size and sophistication. These solutions are expensive and take time to implement, but they will be necessary because it is clear that online privacy has powerful opponents." No shit lol... Not a good sign that they're already in reactive mode. On other end, that MyKolab hasn't gone down might mean they're already compromised or just not targeted by this attack. I wonder what it is. They're just a GPG carrier in a semi-neutral jurisdiction in my usage, though. ProtonMail would've been, too, but I figured they'd be more likely to have service issues.
- vskarine 11y agoYou mentioned that you warned ProtonMail's team about High Strength Attackers. What else did you warn them about? What other security flaws do they have in your opinion?
- nickpsecurity 11y agoI warned others about them. I rarely warn projects any more because my associates and I have done that until we were blue in the face with little effort. My MO is to just post good stuff in forums that attract talent so they might see and adopt it. In any case, I posted a write-up on what real security is and what goes into it on Schneier's blog in response to a [false] comment saying secure coding is all you need. Here's the Pastebin of it: http://pastebin.com/y3PufJ0V http://pastebin.com/y3PufJ0V Here's a specific example where I try to make a step-by-step guide for high assurance Tor without knowing its internals. Just drew on my prior work: https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2014/09/identifying_dre.html#c6678915 https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2014/09/identifying_d... Hope what High Assurance Security takes is more clear now. Unless you get lucky (eg GPG), you need high assurance to resist TLA's successfully and that might just be delaying inevitable. Still need monitoring & tamper-detection.
- rcurry 11y agoIt is always a temptation to an armed and agile nation To call upon a neighbour and to say: -- "We invaded you last night--we are quite prepared to fight, Unless you pay us cash to go away." And that is called asking for Dane-geld, And the people who ask it explain That you've only to pay 'em the Dane-geld And then you'll get rid of the Dane! It is always a temptation for a rich and lazy nation, To puff and look important and to say: -- "Though we know we should defeat you, we have not the time to meet you. We will therefore pay you cash to go away." And that is called paying the Dane-geld; But we've proved it again and again, That if once you have paid him the Dane-geld You never get rid of the Dane. It is wrong to put temptation in the path of any nation, For fear they should succumb and go astray; So when you are requested to pay up or be molested, You will find it better policy to say: -- "We never pay any-one Dane-geld, No matter how trifling the cost; For the end of that game is oppression and shame, And the nation that pays it is lost!" - Rudyard Kipling
- throwaway09128 11y agonever deal with terrorists
- Kieselstein 11y agoBomb their families instead?
- cm2187 11y agoQuestionable solution but I bet it would help for hackers! Impunity is what fuels this type of criminal behavior.
- imglorp 11y agoIf victims need to be consistent. When terrorists are shown that they'll either get a bomb through the roof or nothing, but never payment, then they'll change their business plan.
- 11y ago
- blondie9x 11y agoHonestly maybe they could have hired security consultants for a comprable fee? Fireye etc
- ymse 11y agoCloudflare should have an emergency hotline for situations like this. Charge half the ransom to handle the traffic for the duration of the attack. Offer contract afterwards.
- dangrossman 11y agoCloudflare's $200/month business plan includes DDoS mitigation. It's self-serve and there's an "I'm Under Attack!" button in every account. There's no extra cost for the bandwidth.
- ymse 11y agoSo $6000 would get them over two years of self-service DDoS mitigation. Ouch.
- Kimm0n0 11y agoIf you are in the privacy business, a man-in-the-middle like CloudFlare, is not the thing you try first.
- vemv 11y agoReally? Do men-in-the-middle matter if your communications are encrypted (be it HTTPS, PGP)?
- dangrossman 11y agoIn this case yes, because users don't get an encrypted channel with the site's servers, only with Cloudflare. Cloudflare isn't acting as a dumb TCP proxy which would allow that. When it hosts an HTTPS website, it does so by terminating the HTTPS connections itself. Cloudflare has the private key, and can see the content of every request/response. That's necessary to compress images, inject scripts, minify code and do all the other optimization/CDN stuff they do -- but it also means making them an MITM between a site and its users.
- 11y ago
- mark_l_watson 11y agoNo evidence given for it, but my first thought was to wonder is it was a government not liking ProtonMail's encrypted email service,and taking them down.
- giancarlostoro 11y agoI mean, the day of SOPA blowing up when everyone was protesting what was necessary to take down piracy websites they shut down megaupload and arrested people across the world. My only question that day was: why doe we need SOPA again?
- cft 11y agoWhy couldn't they put it on Cloudflare?
- jagermo 11y agoPrivacy and a s service sitting between user and host doesn't mix well, I'd guess
- vabmit 11y agoBecause ProtonMail would have been required to give CloudFlare encryption keys that would have 1) allowed CloudFlare to inject JavaScript to steal decryption passwords and keys 2) Allowed CloudFlare to collect metadata on traffic for individual users ClouldFlare are a bunch of great guys. And, they wouldn't do any of that unless they were delivered a National Security Letter forcing them to. If ProtonMail signed up with CloudFlare, like HushMail did, ProtonMail would have no way to know if these types of code modification attacks or metadata collections were happening. And, as people saw with Hushmail, since CloudFlare does not do SMTP proxying (filtering/challenging) a DDoS could have still taken down ProtonMail's mail servers offline. While CloudFlare allowed Hushmail to get it's website back online, mail to my Hushmail account is currently delayed by several hours due to DDoS of their mail servers. From https://hushmailstatus.com/ https://hushmailstatus.com/ : "We're investigating reports of incoming and outgoing email delivery delays. We'll update this page as more information becomes available."
- geofft 11y agoI suspect, sadly, this is why Gmail and sites like it will continue to win. Secure email always sounds like a good thing, but it's less important in practice than accessible email. If you have to make a choice between confidentiality, integrity, and availability, for day-to-day email, very few people will choose anything other than availability. (The email deliverability problem doesn't help matters, of course.)
- awqrre 11y agoan email server doesn't need to be accessible 100% of the time to guarantee deliverability
- geofft 11y agoBy "the email deliverability problem" I'm referring to the problem that only well-known IP addresses get to send mail that doesn't get arbitrarily thrown into spam filters. See e.g. http://liminality.xyz/the-hostile-email-landscape/ http://liminality.xyz/the-hostile-email-landscape/ , which was front-page here a few weeks back. If you're just talking about availability, then yes, but this was a sustained DDoS that took their servers down for hours. While the email protocol does insist that the sender should queue and try later, having no new email for hours is not really what people want out of email.
- vabmit 11y agoProtonmail's e-mail servers were off line for multiple days. With an outage of that length mail will start to bounce. It depends on the local configuration. But, 3 days/72 hours is pretty standard.
- awqrre 11y agoThat length of down-time is unacceptable for any type of connection.... even for residential. But at least I guess that the senders will know that the emails bounced.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- danlindley 11y agoIt is possible that by paying the ransom, ProtonMail effectively financed its own DDoS attack. That being send, I commend ProtonMail's transparency in this situation, regardless of the seemingly negative reaction.
- michaelbuckbee 11y agoI'm not recommending it, but it should be noted that this does sometimes work as when Kim DotCom paid for the LizardSquad DDOS of XBox and PS4 networks to be halted last Christmas: https://torrentfreak.com/kim-dotcom-stops-xbox-and-playstation-attacks-141226/ https://torrentfreak.com/kim-dotcom-stops-xbox-and-playstati...
- JupiterMoon 11y agoKim Dotcom gave a gift that could easily be revoked if the attacker had continued attacking. Very different situation to giving cash (or bitcoin).
- jusben1369 11y agoTo pay or not to pay....the bigger story here is the implication a nation state was involved.
- jacquesm 11y agoThat's purely speculative.
- jusben1369 11y agoI did say implication
- nkurz 11y agoIt seems like the largest threat to the "ransom seeking industry" is for the public to come to believe that paying the the ransom will do no good. Sometimes, such as in cases like this, it becomes publicly known that a ransom is sought before it is paid. An interesting aspect of a Bitcoin ransom is that third parties can verify that a ransom was paid. Would it be in the legitimate interest of the public as a whole for a third party (possibly governmental) to carry through on the threat as soon as the ransom is paid? This would be to the detriment of the victim, but reduce the likelihood that future ransoms would be paid, and thus eventually might reduce the number of future victims. Might that be what's happened here?
- jacquesm 11y agoThat's an interesting angle, but if traced to the source that source would still be 100% on the hook for any and all fall-out from such an attack and I really wonder if any government entity would be willing to sign off on such a vaccination service.
- stingraycharles 11y agoIt doesn't necessarily have to be a government, things like this probably attract more vigilante "Anonymous" type of people anyway.
- raquo 11y ago> An interesting aspect of a Bitcoin ransom is that third parties can verify that a ransom was paid. Huh, interesting. If third parties have attackers' bitcoin address, they can also pay the ransom themselves.
- transfire 11y agoI hope they catch the culprits and put them in jail for thirty years.
- cpncrunch 11y agoGood luck with putting Xi Jinping in jail :)
- hieudang9 11y agolol, shame for you ProtonMail and Welcome to my blacklist
- khalidmbajwa 11y agoI belong to a minority community in Pakistan target of regular state backed oppression.In addition to violence and flagrant discrimination the community representatives are also targets for abductions. The community has a rule.It never pays ransom to the kidnappers because this sets a precedent and exposes the representatives all over the country to even more kidnappings. This strategy while it may seem brutal is a necessary one and over the years kidnappings for ransom has gone down. Again, computer security is different, but the principle is same, you dont want to send out the message 'We'll give you money to make you go away' because it just goads even more to resort to such tactics.
- eru 11y agoSee eg http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/news/colinfreeman/100251070/david-cameron-wants-a-global-ban-on-ransom-payments-as-a-former-hostage-i-think-hes-wrong/ http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/news/colinfreeman/100251070/dav...
- snowy 11y agoDoes any one know the technical details of the attack? The article simply refers to it as 'highly advanced denial-of-service attacks'. From the fact that it knocked off their upstream providers also means it was probably just a simple volumetric attack like an NTP or DNS reflection attack. These are relatively easy to defend against. I work for an ISP that gets hit with 5 or 6 of these a week, but because of the mitigation strategies we have in place our customers don't even notice...
- cpncrunch 11y agoThey say the attack "exceeded 100Gbps" (https://protonmaildotcom.wordpress.com/ https://protonmaildotcom.wordpress.com/). I moved my server to OVH 6 months ago, and since then any DDoS attacks don't affect me at all. OVH say they can handle up to 480Gbps of attacks, and people are reporting that they are getting up to 90Gbps of DDoS attacks mitigated by OVH without any problem. Their DDoS protection is completely free with any of their dedicated servers. I don't really understand the logic behind setting up with a Swiss datacenter with zero (or very little) DDoS protection. It is pretty much guaranteed that China will DDoS you if you are in any way involved in helping dissident groups.
- keehun 11y agoIt seems like a similar DDOS knocked out FastMail last night for a little while, although they returned to service very quickly (<30 min)
- if_by_whisky 11y agoVigilante solution: You could automatically send a ransom request any time you see a company getting DDOS'd by an attacker. If the attacker is also asking them for a ransom (so the company gets two ransoms), you ensure confusion and that the attacker doesn't get paid. Otherwise, you might get paid while the attack happens. This way: (1) companies that pay ransoms are AWLAYS punished and it never causes an attack to stop (2) no attacker ever gets paid a ransom
- jexe 11y agothis article is great, in a way. People pay ransoms with extreme agony, but because they are supposed to be effective. If they don't work, there goes the only reason to pay. this is exactly the article the DDoSers don't ever want to see written about them.
- Drdrdrq 11y agoI wonder if the second attack was trying to punish them for paying, and a warning to others?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]