3 ms·
TL;DR How is it possible that the proposal of a couple of Marxian professors from the Benelux—riffing off some of the more utopian musings of Enl
by ricardobeat 11y ago
TL;DR
How is it possible that the proposal of a couple of
Marxian professors from the Benelux—riffing off some of
the more utopian musings of Enlightenment dreamers in a
brief outline of an idea that they themselves concluded
was only “sketchy and tentative”—has been able to
capture the imagination of politicos of every hue in
recent years?
Also
to get productivity growing again, labour has to become
more expensive. And the only way for labour to become
more expensive is for there to be a genuinely global and
militant labour movement
I don't even know what that means. Want to know a surefire way to make labour more expensive? Minimum income for everyone.
- SilasX 11y agoI apologize for voting this up. Considering the rapid, popular support, I think skepticism and contrarianism regarding UBI are merited, and so it's great to hear good arguments against it to help readers be better grounded. So pretty much any essay to that effect is welcome in my mind. But if that's all it's offering, don't bother. The first summary is "appeal to he's-a-baddy", and the second is reasoning from a price change. Any good argument takes the form, "here is how an improvement in your worldmodel results in regarding conclusion X as correct/false". This isn't that.
- applecore 11y agoIt's even more ironic when you consider that a small group of political philosophers riffing off the musings of some early Enlightenment thinkers are essentially responsible for Western civilization as we know it.
- kapnobatairza 11y agoThank you. A basic income increases the negotiating power of the laborer because he now has an implicit price floor from where he can start his negotiations.
- jameshart 11y agoNot so much a price floor as a better BATNA - the ability to walk away without having to go and live on the streets.
- kapnobatairza 11y agoYep, that's a much more apt description.
- mattm 11y agoHow terrible that the people at the lower end be given more power. The peons and wage slaves should be kept in their place. /s
- obrero 11y ago>> to get productivity growing again, labour has to become more expensive. And the only way for labour to become more expensive is for there to be a genuinely global and militant labour movement > I don't even know what that means. Want to know a surefire way to make labour more expensive? Minimum income for everyone. It means when labor is cheap, there is little thought investing in labor-saving capital equipment, but when labor is expensive, labor-saving capital equipment is developed and invested in. Some companies pay dividends. This is money not being used to resupply the company, nor reinvest in the company, nor to pay wages. Workers creating that wealth fighting for it to go to wages as opposed to dividends will have some side effects, one being a desire to automate the industry jobs more. Basic income for all has an effect on all of this, but not as direct. Particularly for say, programmers in San Francisco, where the small amount of money they get from basic income won't have much effect on work, automation and such at all.
- eru 11y agoThe dividends are why people create and invest in companies in the first place. Also, dividends aren't just burned. People can consume them or re-invest.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- aidenn0 11y agoIt also contains the point roughly: "UBI is a pittance offered to the proletariat from the elite to prevent us from revolting"
- cbd1984 11y ago> "UBI is a pittance offered to the proletariat from the elite to prevent us from revolting" So does the author actually want a revolt? Because that's insane. It is not rational to want a war when you can get the essentials, enough to stop a revolt, through peaceful means. And, during and after the war, who will be hurt hardest? The working class! The very people the author claims to support! This is why nobody takes people like the author seriously. They demand everything and are satisfied with nothing, and then threaten to burn the whole thing down instead of investing the effort to fix it. Revolution isn't a solution. It's a threat which, if it is carried out, causes even more problems. If it is continuously threatened, it is a cop-out, a way to avoid thinking about how to actually solve anything. Sometimes revolution is needed. Never think it solves more problems than it creates.
- aidenn0 11y ago> Sometimes revolution is needed. Never think it solves more problems than it creates. I love that. I feel the same way about most forms of government regulation; in the small and short term they can be necessary to solve a problem, but in aggregate and the long term they harm competitiveness in an industry. I always thought "clean your shit up, or we'll regulate you" to be better at improving an industry than actual regulation. Naturally, if you don't ever follow through, the threat has no power, so it is necessary sometimes.
- aidenn0 11y agoI think the main thrust was that if labour does not have sufficient power at the point of UBI's implementation, it is likely to be, at best, neutral for the poor, as welfare will be withdrawn at the same time as UBI is introduced.
- deleted 11y ago
- Eridrus 11y agoI think that depends a lot on the level at which the minimum income is set; 1k is very different from 10k is very different from 20k. If you abolish the welfare system and institute welfare at 1k/yr, you've probably fucked a lot of poor people over.
- skybrian 11y agoOn the margin, having something to fall back on gives workers more freedom, since they have more alternatives. I think it would have complex effects on negotiating power. Some jobs might pay more because they're unattractive and workers are less desperate to take jobs that are barely worth it. Some might pay the same or less, because they're attractive from a lifestyle point of view (good location or prestigious). This would be similar to how someone on a trust fund can afford to take an unpaid internship, but regular students can't afford it. Other jobs will be mostly unaffected since they already pay a lot more than minimum income. I don't see any way that having more money is bad for workers. It might not be great for unions because it's about individual workers having more power on their own. On the other hand, it pays for some part of the strike fund.
- fche 11y ago"to get productivity growing again, labour has to become more expensive" Productivity is the saleable value of the work, not the cost of the work. The latter is only a floor for the former (since work that cannot be sold at least at its cost will simply not be done - witness the rise of fast food robots).