3 ms·
This article really misses the facts of the Nyquest-Shannon theory. In order to decimate a signal to 44.1 or 48khz, and preserve high-frequency content, high f
by gwbas1c 11y ago
This article really misses the facts of the Nyquest-Shannon theory.
In order to decimate a signal to 44.1 or 48khz, and preserve high-frequency content, high frequencies need to be phase-shifted.
This phase-shift is similar to how lossy codecs work.
For what it's worth: I'm a big fan of music in surround, and most of it comes in high sampling rates. When I investigated ripping my DVD-As and Blurays, I found that they never have music over 20khz. It's all filtered out. However, downsampling to 44.1 or 48khz isn't "lossless" because of the phase shift needed due to the Nyquist-Shannon theory.
I still rip my DVD-As at 48khz, though. There isn't a good lossless codec that can preserve phase at high frequencies, yet approach the bitrate of 12/48 flac.
- Hello71 11y agono, it addresses it fairly clearly (albeit briefly): > So the math is ideal, but what of real world complications? The most notorious is the band-limiting requirement. Signals with content over the Nyquist frequency must be lowpassed before sampling to avoid aliasing distortion; this analog lowpass is the infamous antialiasing filter. Antialiasing can't be ideal in practice, but modern techniques bring it very close. ...and with that we come to oversampling. if you accept that the limit of hearing is around 20 kHz, then you must also accept that frequencies above that can freely be removed without loss of fidelity to the human ear. the article notes that higher frequencies can be heard, but only in the form of ultrasonic intermodulation distortion. (i.e. not in fact the higher frequencies at all)
- itp 11y agoWhen you say > In order to decimate a signal to 44.1 or 48khz, and preserve high-frequency content, high frequencies need to be phase-shifted. What do you mean by high frequency? If you mean frequencies below but near the Nyquist frequency then no, there is no phase shift. If you mean at or above... I'm struggling to avoid a blatant appeal to authority here, but your position is that the author of the Ogg Vorbis coded doesn't understand digital sampling, which seems challenging to believe.
- nullc 11y ago> In order to decimate a signal to 44.1 or 48khz, and preserve high-frequency content, high frequencies need to be phase-shifted. Your understanding of sampling theorem is incorrect. Sampling alone (not quantization, of course) is completely lossless under the critical frequency. We demonstrated this in a very clear way near the end, at about 21 minutes in, on the primer two video: http://www.xiph.org/video/vid2.shtml http://www.xiph.org/video/vid2.shtml where we show a square wave being phase shifted tiny fractions of the intersample length.