4 ms·
Economics is mostly microeconomics. The stuff you read in the newspapers is not what most economists do. And of course most people who aren't economists, or don
by barrkel 11y ago
Economics is mostly microeconomics. The stuff you read in the newspapers is not what most economists do. And of course most people who aren't economists, or don't know economists, think that economics is little more than astrology.
- bachmeier 11y ago> Economics is mostly microeconomics. Please elaborate. Macroeconomics and econometrics are very much a part of economics.
- barrkel 11y agoI didn't say they weren't part of the discipline. What I meant is that most professional economists are not making prognostications about the economy; they are typically analysing costs and benefits at several degrees of indirection, developing models from data, and more generally optimizing choices - economics is the study of choice. What I'm particularly arguing against is the idea that the average economist is some kind of marketplace weather forecaster and that consequently, owing to accuracy little better than chance, there's nothing worthwhile in the discipline.
- rz2k 11y agoMaybe I am misinterpreting your comment, but forecasting isn't the primary function of macroeconomists. Most of what will determine the future hasn't happened yet, or hasn't yet been measured. And yet, public policy, fiscal policy, and monetary policy choices all have enormous effects, and those choices are ideally informed by people who have actually studied the economy. To put it in familiar terms, there is a difference between the climate and the weather, and we are able to influence the economic environment for good or bad in the same way that we could affect the climate by changing the atmosphere or changing the distance to the sun.
- halostatue 11y agoInasmuch as any branch of economics theory depends on homo economicus, it is IMO little more than astrology. There’s a lot of really interesting economics research out there (at least the stuff that the Freakonomics podcast is surfacing to my notice is interesting), but it’s on edges that are, by and large, rejecting homo economicus and is trying to reflect what people really do. (There’s a lot of behavioural economics research that has been reported on for the last several episodes, which is fascinating.)
- kjs3 11y agoIf you're oh-so-considered opinion of the state of economics is based on what Freakonomics is going on about (as entertaining as it might be), then please quit trying to pretend you give two shits about what economists are really up to and quit using obnoxious conceits like homo economicus.
- halostatue 11y agoI don’t actually care what economists are really up to. Where I care is that inasmuch as many (prominent) economists interact with the world, they do so from a perspective where homo economicus is a real thing (they don’t use that term; instead, they use terms like “rational actor”, which amounts to the same thing—a disconnect from the real world as it would detract from their theories). This is, IMO/IME, much more common from economists that believe in unfettered, minimally-regulated capitalism. The same folks who think that healthcare would be better if it were actually treated as a market, or there is such a thing as perfect information about markets. I have far fewer problems with behavioural economists, in the same way that when it comes to language I side with descriptivists far more than I do with prescriptivists. Essentially, I think that there is very little one can learn from economists—especially the famous (macroeconomists) called out in the article. Except, perhaps, what not to do.
- kjs3 11y agoSo you're even more pretentious and shallow than it originally seemed. You make up terms where widely accepted terms are already used (because the appropriation of Latin phrases makes one sound much smarter that those silly PhDs) and dismiss the essentially the entire field because there are some (in your view) ignorant troglodytes who don't dovetail with your obviously more informed world view. Your argument is so compelling that you don't even feel the need to support it with facts. Bravo...you must be a joy at parties.