5 ms·
No they're not. And no matter how many times this gets linked to on the Internet, it's still wrong. The basic problem: the quieter a sound or detail gets, the
by TheOtherHobbes 11y ago
No they're not. And no matter how many times this gets linked to on the Internet, it's still wrong.
The basic problem: the quieter a sound or detail gets, the fewer bits of resolution are used to represent it.
In 16-bit recording, there simply aren't enough bits to represent very low level details without distorting them with a subtle but audible crunchy digital halo of quantisation noise.
In a 24-bit recording, there are.
Talking about dynamic range completely misses the point. It's the not the absolute difference between the loudest and quietest sounds that matters - it's the accuracy with which the quieter sounds are reproduced.
This is because in a studio, 0dB full-scale meter redline is calibrated to a standard voltage reference, and both consumer and professional audio has equivalent standard levels for the loudest level possible.
These levels don't change for different bit depths, and they're used on both analog and digital equipment. (In fact they've been standard for decades now.)
This is why using more bits does not mean you can "reproduce music with a bigger dynamic range" - not without turning the volume up, anyway.
What actually happens is that the maximum possible volume of a playback system stays the same, but quieter sounds are reproduced with more or less accuracy.
In a 16-bit recording quiet sounds below around 50Db have 1-8 bits of effective resolution, which is nowhere near enough for truly accurate reproduction. (Try listening to an 8-bit recording to hear what this means.)
You might think it doesn't matter because they're quiet. Not so. 50dB is a long way from being inaudible, ears can be incredibly good at spectral estimation, and your brain parses spectral content and volume as separate things.
There's a wide range between "loud enough to hear" and "too loud" and 24-bit covers that whole range accurately. 16-bit is fine for louder sounds, but the quieter details just above "loud enough to get hear" get audibly bit-crushed.
The effect isn't glaringly disturbing, and adding dither helps make it even less obvious. But it's still there.
24-bit doesn't need tricks like dither - because it does the job properly in the first place.
Now - whether or not commercial recordings have enough musical detail to take full advantage of 24-bits is a different question. For various reasons - compression, mastering, cheapness - many don't.
But if you have any kind of aural sensitivity, you really should be able to A/B the difference between a 24-bit uncompressed orchestral recording and a 16-bit recording using an otherwise identical studio-grade mixer/mike/recorder/speaker system without too much difficulty.
- ska 11y agoIf your mastering is done competently, you really aren't going to be able to hear it in a realistic scenario. Which is why: "Talking about dynamic range completely misses the point." isn't really sensible. It's the use of dynamic range that decides how much useful resolution you have when quantizing a signal. This is really why higher bit depths on record and mixing are useful - they let you be sloppier with the inputs without losing much information before you've had a chance to work with it. It still doesn't gain you anything fundamental but it does mean if you got the levels a bit wrong you can salvage it. Higher bit rates here are excellent. There is nothing magic about 24 bits here. Record something with 48 bits but set up your equipment all screwy so your only actually using the first 8 bits... and you've got an effectively 8 bit recording. In real world applications the codec is giving you trouble with the low amplitude stuff, not the quantizer. Not that in realistic situations your equipment is likely to be able to generate this cleanly anyway. "24-bit doesn't need tricks like dither - because it does the job properly in the first place." No. Dither isn't a trick, it is a fundamental approach to quantization error at any depth. On playback, the issue goes the other way around. If you've mastered things correctly you'll be using the available dynamic range of the output in such a way that the information content of your signal is well represented. This is sufficient at CD rates for all practical listening scenarios.
- beat 11y agoMastering, especially modern mastering, compresses the bejesus out of the end product. Trust me, you do not want to listen to uncompressed recordings under real-world conditions. Details will be so quiet you can't hear them. It'll sound thin and dull. Most modern pop has maybe 5-6db of dynamic range. Really loose, open mastering will be 20db or so. As someone who both records/mixes albums and a live-instrument musician, a live instrument in the room sounds utterly different than any recording. Not necessarily worse, just different. The pursuit of "accuracy" in audio playback is childish and naive. The sound of a recording is a function of technical limitations, compromises, and aesthetic decisions as much as it is a product of the raw source sounds. Don't make it sound accurate, make it sound GOOD! And that usually means a lot of compression, and often deliberate distortion.
- ubercow13 11y ago