3 ms·
Doesn't that depend on what type of playback you are doing? More and more playback these days is done via digital transfer with the volume set in software at th
by alkonaut 11y ago
Doesn't that depend on what type of playback you are doing? More and more playback these days is done via digital transfer with the volume set in software at the sending end, to amplifiers at fixed volume, such as many multi-room systems.
If I airplay a song from my iPhone and have the volume at 50% set in software, then a few extra bits can help. Not sure if it makes a noticable difference, but it's a digital mixing scenario occurring at playback. If you play at extremely low volume it should be noticable.
- derefr 11y agoAn aside: I've never understood why the logic around digital signal-path volume adjustment isn't "keep the volume number around all the way to the end; throw the signal through the DAC at 100% gain, and then attenuate the signal on the analogue path using the digital volume setting." Uses more power, I suppose.
- alkonaut 11y agoThat's how it should work. Not sure why it doesn't. Needs some updated standard for digital transfer I suppose. Updates to AirPlay, Toslink etc.
- detaro 11y agoWhy woulda few extra bit in the source data help there? A DAC with more bits would, but that can easily be scaled from the existing data.
- alkonaut 11y agoIf you attenuate digitally you bit shift things out. If you have data in a 16bit (-32k..32k) stream and set a low volume in software before you send it, then it will scale the samples to (say) -8k..8k which is basically now a 14bit stream. With a 24bit stream you can easily give up a few bits without losing dynamic range.
- detaro 11y agoSure, but that only to the stream you actually send to the DAC, not the source material? (as in, you can take a 16 bit stream, scale it to 24 bits and then lower the volume) Am I missing something?
- Hello71 11y agono, because if you play at lower volume, that simply means that the quietest parts are closer to (or underneath) the threshold of hearing. I see it this way: let's say 16 bits is needed to represent the entire discernable dynamic range between the threshold of hearing and the threshold of pain. if you turn the volume to 50%, then you throw out 8 bits, but you also only need to represent 8 bits worth of hearing range.
- Franciscouzo 11y agoturning the volume %50 down would yield 15 bits, not 8 bits, which would be discernible.
- Hello71 11y agoer, my log math is bad, but the point is still valid.