17 ms·
> Nicotine is basically a synonym for addictive. the same is for caffeine, addiction hits at very low level of consumption : http://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/p
by trhway 11y ago
> Nicotine is basically a synonym for addictive.
the same is for caffeine, addiction hits at very low level of consumption :
http://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/psychiatry/research/BPRU/docs/Caffeine_Dependence_Fact_Sheet.pdf http://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/psychiatry/research/BPRU/docs...
Now imagine if every cup of your coffee came with a spoon of asbestos mixed with cadmium and radon powder.
The problem with nicotine and its addiction isn't the nicotine or the addiction itself - they are basically harmless, like coffee.
The problem is that typical nicotine delivery method - tobacco cigarette - causes people to inhale whole slew of carcinogenic chemicals. The vaping eliminates all those bad factors thus converting a very harmful habit into a habit of mild relaxation (basically the only effect of low levels of nicotine). The best one thing a government can do right now to improve health of the nation (and decrease Medicare expenses) in near future is to give away the e-cigs everywhere where tobacco is sold.
To the Wikipedia link in the comment below - with all the respect to Wikipedia, my link above is from John Hopkins.
- Zikes 11y ago"Caffeine addiction, or a pathological and compulsive form of use, has never been documented in humans." [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caffeine_dependence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caffeine_dependence
- sophacles 11y agoThere are big problems with addiction studies in general - in this case because needing a cup of coffee to start your day is considered just fine, whereas needing a drink to start your day is considered pathological. Being grumpy because of lack of coffee is generally understood and sympathized with. Being grumpy because you haven't had a bump today is considered a cocaine problem and compulsive behavior. There is so much socialization and stigma around various substances, that terms like compulsive and pathological are hard to use objectively.
- Zikes 11y agoStarting your day with bacon & eggs is just fine, too, unless you ask the vegans.
- sophacles 11y agoI don't understand what this has to do with my point. Are bacon and eggs addictive too? I was merely pointing out that there are known difficulties with the wikipedia statement, because "addictive" "pathological" and "compulsive" are words that have a level of social acceptance built into them, and the same behaviors towards one substance are pathological, while they aren't in another.
- Zikes 11y agoAnything can be psychologically addictive with habitual use and what one might call an "addictive personality". Video games, work, porn, caffeine, bacon & eggs, all the same. Some of those things even have support groups, pills, patches, etc. Nicotine is addictive on a scale far beyond that. Comparing caffeine and nicotine is like comparing nerf and 9mm. That's my argument, and even though every single comment I've made on this thread to that effect has been downvoted into the negatives, I don't care. Apparently that's the hill I'm dying on today, and I'm just fine with that.
- sophacles 11y agoThis "nicotine is more addictive" concept is hard to understand for me. For the reasons I outline above. The timeline and severity of withdrawal symptoms aren't that different. The relapse to previous use levels isn't that different. A huge factor in how "bad" each is however seems to be in the responses to relapse. There's disapproval in people's responses to someone taking up nicotine again, but if someone is back to drinking coffee, there's at most a "oh drinking coffee again bob?". These factors in the consequences regarding a slip up or relapse make it hard to judge how "addictive" something is independent of the socialization of it. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rat_Park https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rat_Park