5 ms·
The article is pretty clear about this too - higher bitdepths and sampling rates can be quite useful in mixing and recording situations. They're pointless for
by ska 11y ago
The article is pretty clear about this too - higher bitdepths and sampling rates can be quite useful in mixing and recording situations.
They're pointless for playback.
- niels_olson 11y ago> higher bitdepths and sampling rates can be quite useful in mixing That is really the central issue. It's much like imaging since the time of Ansel Adams: the sensor can capture more dynamic range than the human eye can experience. The producer may have use for that range when editing, but the audience will never know what was -- may have been -- missed. And we're not talking about limits of reproduction. We're talking about the human sensors both instantaneous and absolute upper and lower bounds.
- msandford 11y ago> That is really the central issue. It's much like imaging since the time of Ansel Adams: the sensor can capture more dynamic range than the human eye can experience. That's not really true. Dynamic range refers to the difference between the biggest value that isn't clipped and the smallest value that isn't rounded to zero. The human eye is a logarithmic detector, cameras are linear. The only reason HDR is a thing is because cameras DON'T have enough dynamic range. http://photo.stackexchange.com/questions/21579/how-does-the-dynamic-range-of-the-human-eye-compare-to-that-of-digital-cameras http://photo.stackexchange.com/questions/21579/how-does-the-...
- niels_olson 11y agoYou're thinking about absolute range of a human system. Yes, I can look into shadows and my iris will imperceptibly dilate. Similarly, the stapedius muscle can dampen input to the oval window. So you can appreciate a wide dynamic range. But instantaneously, your retina is only good for about 7-8 EV steps. Modern imaging sensors deliver well over 10 EV, some deliver more than 14. Depending on which format you save to, you could be throwing away half the information! So, much like a artist should record 24/192, a photographer should be saving to RAW. But no monitor or film or the human eye will ever capture all that range in one instant. So, especially for temporal media, like audio and video, that space can be scoped down in the interest of space saving without any perceptible loss.
- jamesfmilne 11y agoDefine HDR. Almost all displays people have these days are not capable of reproducing the dynamic range that most cameras can capture. Hence why we have colour grading, which is the image equivalent of audio mastering.
- Sharlin 11y agoThe instantaneous dynamic range of the human eye is estimated to be less than eight stops. Both film and modern camera sensors can capture much more than that. The reason we're able to adequately perceive scenes with 12+ stops of dynamic range is that our visual system does continuous integration and reconstructs an HDR "mosaic" in real time. HDR photography is required in situations where even the 12-14 stops that a modern sensor is capable of is not enough. However, that's neither here nor there because the human eye is not the real bottleneck here. The media we use to display photos are. Printed photographs have approximately six stops of DR; typical monitors have eight. Modern cameras capture much more information than can be displayed, and the raw sensor data must be tone-mapped either by the camera software or in post-processing to produce a viewable image. There is a lot of latitude in deciding how to map 2^14 discrete values of input to a mere 2^8 values of output.
- jacobolus 11y agoNice photo prints can typically show something like 100:1 to 200:1 contrast (~6.5–7.5 stops) between white and black, or at the top end, some dye transfer prints under carefully controlled lighting can get up to about 500:1 (9 stops). Nice computer displays (and mobile device displays) without glare and with the brightness cranked all the way up can get up to something like 9.5–10.5 stops. Of course, that range still pales in comparison to the contrast between shadows and highlights on a sunny day, which can be more like 16+ stops.
- jlarocco 11y agoI don't know about music and audio, but your photography comparison is incorrect for two reasons. First, as msandford pointed out, the human eye has significantly better dynamic range than image sensors. Technically, our eyes have a lower range at any specific instant, but due to the way our eyes work we effectively see upwards of 20 stops of dynamic range. The best sensors available (in medium format cameras, pro-DSLRs, etc) can only capture 14-15 stops. Second, some black and white films have a better dynamic range than digital sensors, so it's also not the case that digital is strictly better. 18-20 stops isn't unheard of for some types of film.
- rcthompson 11y agoI think the point was that sometimes you do want to apply some effect to the sound at playback time, e.g. an equalizer, and in that case a higher bit depth could maybe conceivably become useful.
- alkonaut 11y agoDoesn't that depend on what type of playback you are doing? More and more playback these days is done via digital transfer with the volume set in software at the sending end, to amplifiers at fixed volume, such as many multi-room systems. If I airplay a song from my iPhone and have the volume at 50% set in software, then a few extra bits can help. Not sure if it makes a noticable difference, but it's a digital mixing scenario occurring at playback. If you play at extremely low volume it should be noticable.
- derefr 11y agoAn aside: I've never understood why the logic around digital signal-path volume adjustment isn't "keep the volume number around all the way to the end; throw the signal through the DAC at 100% gain, and then attenuate the signal on the analogue path using the digital volume setting." Uses more power, I suppose.
- alkonaut 11y agoThat's how it should work. Not sure why it doesn't. Needs some updated standard for digital transfer I suppose. Updates to AirPlay, Toslink etc.
- detaro 11y agoWhy woulda few extra bit in the source data help there? A DAC with more bits would, but that can easily be scaled from the existing data.
- alkonaut 11y agoIf you attenuate digitally you bit shift things out. If you have data in a 16bit (-32k..32k) stream and set a low volume in software before you send it, then it will scale the samples to (say) -8k..8k which is basically now a 14bit stream. With a 24bit stream you can easily give up a few bits without losing dynamic range.
- detaro 11y ago
- TheOtherHobbes 11y agoNo they're not. And no matter how many times this gets linked to on the Internet, it's still wrong. The basic problem: the quieter a sound or detail gets, the fewer bits of resolution are used to represent it. In 16-bit recording, there simply aren't enough bits to represent very low level details without distorting them with a subtle but audible crunchy digital halo of quantisation noise. In a 24-bit recording, there are. Talking about dynamic range completely misses the point. It's the not the absolute difference between the loudest and quietest sounds that matters - it's the accuracy with which the quieter sounds are reproduced. This is because in a studio, 0dB full-scale meter redline is calibrated to a standard voltage reference, and both consumer and professional audio has equivalent standard levels for the loudest level possible. These levels don't change for different bit depths, and they're used on both analog and digital equipment. (In fact they've been standard for decades now.) This is why using more bits does not mean you can "reproduce music with a bigger dynamic range" - not without turning the volume up, anyway. What actually happens is that the maximum possible volume of a playback system stays the same, but quieter sounds are reproduced with more or less accuracy. In a 16-bit recording quiet sounds below around 50Db have 1-8 bits of effective resolution, which is nowhere near enough for truly accurate reproduction. (Try listening to an 8-bit recording to hear what this means.) You might think it doesn't matter because they're quiet. Not so. 50dB is a long way from being inaudible, ears can be incredibly good at spectral estimation, and your brain parses spectral content and volume as separate things. There's a wide range between "loud enough to hear" and "too loud" and 24-bit covers that whole range accurately. 16-bit is fine for louder sounds, but the quieter details just above "loud enough to get hear" get audibly bit-crushed. The effect isn't glaringly disturbing, and adding dither helps make it even less obvious. But it's still there. 24-bit doesn't need tricks like dither - because it does the job properly in the first place. Now - whether or not commercial recordings have enough musical detail to take full advantage of 24-bits is a different question. For various reasons - compression, mastering, cheapness - many don't. But if you have any kind of aural sensitivity, you really should be able to A/B the difference between a 24-bit uncompressed orchestral recording and a 16-bit recording using an otherwise identical studio-grade mixer/mike/recorder/speaker system without too much difficulty.
- ska 11y ago