6 ms·
I really don't understand why anyone thinks that anonymous money is a good idea. I'm as big a fan of freedom as the next person, but it seems to me that the pr
by lisper 11y ago
I really don't understand why anyone thinks that anonymous money is a good idea. I'm as big a fan of freedom as the next person, but it seems to me that the primary purpose of anonymous money is to do an end-run around the law.
[UPDATE] Let me try to make this a little more precise: I don't understand the appeal of anonymous digital money. Physical cash is very useful, and I would not want it to go away. But even physical cash is not completely anonymous because you have to be physically present to exchange it, which entails a certain amount of risk, and that puts some checks-and-balances on potential abuses. Anonymous digital money does away with those checks-and-balances and makes a lot of activities with questionable societal value like crypto-extortion much more lucrative than they were before. For example, malware that encrypts your hard drive for ransom was unheard of before the advent of Bitcoin.
- zmanian 11y agoWe've always had anonymous money: Cash and money laundering Regions like Scandanavia are trying to eliminate anonymous money. If you eliminate anonymous money, it is unclear how freedom of speech, religion, inquiry etc can be preserved. Anonymous money is always going to be less convenient that paying in the clear. But it should exist. Good Luck Electric Coiners
- mathgeek 11y ago> We've always had anonymous money: Cash and money laundering Consider that if the money was truly anonymous, we wouldn't be able to use serial numbers to track down who used it.
- themetrician 11y agoCash has existed for a lot longer time than cash-with-a-serial-number.
- mathgeek 11y agoTrue, but to what purpose does that serve us today?
- declan 11y agoSilver and gold and other coins, without serial numbers, have existed as a store of value for far longer than pieces of paper or linen with serial numbers. People have used anonymous money in the form of coins for millennia. It wasn't until the 1860s that the first one-dollar bill in the U.S. was printed with serial numbers. For ~95% of the time that money has existed, it has been what you would call "truly anonymous." If you go back to pre-coin history and use weights of silver as opposed to minted or hammered coins, you're looking at maybe 153 years of serial numbers vs. about 5,000 years of non-serial numbers. "Truly anonymous money" is the historic norm; the current situation with numbers printed on paper/linen/plastic is something of a historical aberration.
- aqme28 11y agoBut you can't do that with current paper money unless stores start regularly scanning money as it enters the cash register. Even if the bank gives me a tracked 20, I can easily "launder" it by using it to buy something. Now I have $19 in anonymous cash and stick of gum.
- mintplant 11y agoYou seem to be making proclamations here without really saying much.
- mathgeek 11y agoI'd say it's a primary purpose, rather than the primary purpose. I do agree that the downsides to anonymous currency can outweigh the upsides.
- monort 11y agoA lot of the law is unjust. Anonymous money solve this problem.
- tptacek 11y agoThis argument boils down to "a lot of the law is unjust, so a bunch of programmers will overrule the law en masse". That's great if you're an an-cap but doesn't so much address the question upthread.
- SilasX 11y agoNot just an-caps; that's also the basic justification given to the whole "don't talk to police" thing and to the Fifth Amendment whenever someone says, "If you're innocent, you can just tell the truth, so obviously silence should count as evidence of guilt." [1] Which is to say, the specter of "you're violating a bunch of laws all the time anyway, so better to make it harder in general to prosecute stuff". Recall the Bennett Haselton (sp?) fracas: http://yro.slashdot.org/story/13/06/07/1439220/seeking-fifth-amendment-defenders http://yro.slashdot.org/story/13/06/07/1439220/seeking-fifth... [1] Of course, it always will, irrespective of a judge's sheepish instructions.
- sarciszewski 11y agoIt's easier to influence the direction of an international cabal of open source software developers than it is to get a sane result from international politics.
- tptacek 11y agoIf you believe that it's OK for programmers to override laws, you don't get to complain about Uber anymore.
- sarciszewski 11y ago> If (false statement), (non sequitur about a service I don't use or complain about) Great contribution there, Tom.
- themetrician 11y agoI'm the next person and to me you don't seem such a big fan of freedom as I am. The reason I am for anonymous money is that it is of no one else's business what I do with my money. It's really that simple. EDIT: David Friedman wrote a good piece on the misuse of "externality" arguments that every Freedom-loving person should know (and I'd be surprised if lisper did not know of it): http://www.daviddfriedman.com/Machinery_3d_Edition/The%20Misuse%20of%20Externality%20Arguments.htm http://www.daviddfriedman.com/Machinery_3d_Edition/The%20Mis...
- ska 11y agoNobody else's business so long as you aren't committing fraud or breaking a contract, aren't avoiding alimony or other legal commitments, have paid (all of) your taxes, haven't stolen it, aren't money laundering, etc. Not quite so simple after all. What is basically desirable is that (some kinds of) transactions can be made anonymously.
- lisper 11y ago> you don't seem such a big fan of freedom as I am I think you might be surprised. > it is of no one else's business what I do with my money If you use your money to, say, hire a hit man to kill me, how is that not my business? > It's really that simple. No, it's really not that simple at all. You should read this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Externality https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Externality
- davnicwil 11y agoThe only purpose of money is to trade work and the captured value of work with other people, therefore it is by definition always someone else's business what you do with your money. But I know what you mean, you don't want non-directly-involved third parties to know about transactions you make. But then there are always contracts, laws and regulations you must follow and be held to account on. These are the things which bind the economy together and make modern civilisation work. Your bank balance and the things you buy with your money do not exist in a vacuum. There will always be a trail of your spending left behind anyway, even if it's just asking the people you bought things from what you bought and when. It's an inescapable fact deeply embedded into the nature of what money is, and the function it serves in society.
- thaumasiotes 11y agoThe law isn't good for its own sake.
- vdaniuk 11y agoThere are literally billions of people who live in places where the rule of law is unjust, oppressive and corrupt.
- Karunamon 11y agoWell, no. I can think of a very good use case right now: sending money is a PITA. Say I want to pay somebody in another country for perfectly legal goods. (Example I've personally done: local food from a friend in Japan) My options are: * Bank wire transfers (expensive and annoying to set up, requires paperwork) * Cash transfer services like Western Union or Moneygram (expensive and inconvenient, requires physical presence at a branch location for both parties, if one exists in the location) * Electronic cash transfer services like PayPal (awful and opaque CS/policies, expensive, requires linking a physical bank account/credit card, something people in many countries don't have - if they operate in the country at all) * Currency through the mail (danger of never getting there) * Something like Bitcoin (annoying to set up.. once) The last one ticks all the boxes in a way that the previous few do not. - It's available everywhere with an internet connection without exception - It's not subject to any middleman fees (though you can splash out a very tiny amount of money to get the transaction processed quicker) - It's not subject to any middleman misbehavior, the transaction is strictly between you and the other person. - There's no paperwork or going to a physical location required, it's all electronic - Once you send a transaction, it will most assuredly reach its destination - It requires nothing from the sender/receiver other than a piece of software The (pseudo?)anonymity is just a bonus in this instance. It's none of the GCHQ, NSA, their associated cronies, etc business knowing what I'm buying and why.
- nfoz 11y agoI typically agree with that sentiment..... but then I think about all the information that Amazon has about me: e.g. political and religious views, cosmetic and OTC pharmaceuticals....... I'd really rather I could buy things anonymously online. I'm ok with the government seeing these things with a warrant; I just don't want the stores I'm interacting with to have such a thorough profile.
- DennisP 11y agoAnd lately we're seeing that governments often don't restrict themselves to warrants. It'd be nice if we could fix that with reforms but so far we haven't had much success. Of course if you're getting something physical shipped to your house, anonymous currency doesn't help you.
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoEven if they do, it doesn't matter when the law itself is horrendous.
- Domenic_S 11y agoYou still have to pick up the items or have them delivered. Even if you open a PO Box or something, Amazon would still aggregate your purchases all shipped to one PO Box into a profile. That data is still valuable, even if it's not personally connected to you.
- Lawtonfogle 11y ago>I'm ok with the government seeing these things with a warrant Really? Maybe okay with your current government, but I bet their are governments out there that you would not be fine with seeing this information when they are in a position to attack you, warrant or not. And there is no guarantee that your government will not become the same.
- vox_mollis 11y agoStrange, we have entirely opposite views on this. One thing Jeff Bezos can't do is trump up "structuring" charges, arrest me, prevent access to decent legal representation by freezing my assets, and then use the threat of decades in prison to extort me into accepting a plea deal of being locked in a cage with violent people for just a few years. I'd be FAR more accepting of Amazon having full detailed knowledge of my financial life than an entity with the real power to destroy my life on a whim.
- DennisP 11y agoBlockchain currencies make all transactions public. Given that, if they're not anonymous it's kinda like posting everyone's credit card statements online.
- tlrobinson 11y agoThat sounds a lot like a "nothing to hide" argument.
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoMaybe you are living in China and want to donate to a group fighting for freedom of speech. Maybe you are in the US and want to buy medicine for your child that you can't afford to pay the US price for. Maybe you are in Venezuela and want to sell something for what it is really worth given the actual exchange rate. Maybe you want to make an online purchase of something embarrassing that you don't want anyone to know about even if they see your card statement. In short, those checks and balances are starting to become corrupt and thus people create a means to do away with them.
- sneak 11y agoNon-anonymous payment systems can be blacklisted to deny people rights (most importantly, the ability to publish, travel, and hire legal representation) without due process. Witness this occurring recently with Wikileaks being banned by Visa, MC, and PayPal without any criminal complaint filed against them, much less a trial. The government cannot have the ability to censor payments or perform traffic analysis on one's payments and receipts if we are to maintain a free and civil society. The US Supreme Court has ruled several times that free speech is not free speech without anonymous speech. Dependency chart: (anonymous payments) <- (anonymous publishing) <- (freedom to publish unpopular opinions without reprisal) <- (freedom to publish with the intent of changing public opinion and changing society) <- (free and civil society) Another: (anonymous payments) <- (untracked travel) <- (freedom of association with unpopular groups) <- (ability to form new political parties) <- (free and civil society)
- panglott 11y agoYour argument is that exchanging anonymous digital money is like cash, except without the risks to personal safety that exchanging cash requires...and that is a bad thing?
- lisper 11y agoMostly. I think society would collapse if civil disobedience had zero cost to the individual engaging in it. I think having that cost come in the form of risk to personal safety is far from optimal, but still far better than nothing.
- deepnet 11y agoNot just the law but also the powerful. For instance, it was impossible at one stage to donate to Wikileaks by Credit Card or Paypal due to Senatorial Pressure on private business.
- logfromblammo 11y agoEver used a vending machine? Did it take your photo before dispensing your purchase? If not, congratulations; you enjoyed a completely legal, completely anonymous transaction. If you have never read A Clockwork Orange by Anthony Burgess, it is a 20-minutes-from-now sci-fi story that briefly explored the consequences involved in making people physically unable to break the law. Go ahead and read it. It's considered by some to be a classic in the same vein as 1984. I consider it vitally important that there be some avenue by which a person can choose to break the law, even if there is only a miniscule likelihood of subsequently escaping punishment for it. Otherwise, the law becomes the iron collar around our necks, and those at the other end of the chain are able to drag us wherever they choose, just by rewriting the statutes. "One has a moral responsibility to disobey unjust laws." --M.L. King Jr. "Protest beyond the law is not a departure from democracy; it is absolutely essential to it." --H. Zinn "It is not always the same thing to be a good man and a good citizen." --Aristotle "An unjust law is itself a species of violence. Arrest for its breach is more so." --M. Gandhi "...if it is of such a nature that it requires you to be the agent of injustice to another, then I say, break the law." -- H.D. Thoreau How then will you engage in nonviolent civil disobedience when you find that you cannot break the law, even when throwing your whole strength against it? What will happen when every person who stands in protest vanishes into an oubliette the instant after they rise to their feet? The impulse to stamp out crime so thoroughly as to make it practically impossible is an open invitation to the tyranny of the totalitarian police state. I much prefer the sort of society where people can choose between doing good and doing evil, by the measure of their own moral standard, over one where people are forced to obey the commandments of others.
- kwhitefoot 11y agoI'd just like to say thanks for saying what I wanted to say better than I would have done myself.
- iamsohungry 11y ago> I really don't understand why anyone thinks that anonymous money is a good idea. I'm as big a fan of freedom as the next person, but it seems to me that the primary purpose of anonymous money is to do an end-run around the law. To be perfectly honest, that's exactly the reason I think anonymous money is a good idea. In a world where laws for huge nations are made by corporations, overthrow of government is impossible, and change within the system is too slow to solve problems now, breaking the law and getting away with it is one of the few remaining recourses an individual wishing to exercise their freedoms has. The kinds of crimes this enables are exactly the kinds of crimes I don't think should be crimes: drug use, prostitution. Yes, it also enables tax evasion. However, I would argue that it's merely leveling the playing field in this respect: the ultra-rich already have legal means of avoiding taxes which aren't available to most people. Anonymous currency just makes it possible for average-to-poor people to avoid taxes. And ultimate, I'm not entirely against tax evasion: I like my roads, schools and libraries, but the US has spends more on the military than the next 7 top spenders combined to kill people for economic reasons, and I don't have any way of preventing my tax money from going to that. The kinds of crimes I do care about leave behind lots more evidence besides a money trail: murder leaves behind bodies, rape leaves behind witnesses (victims). Typically money trails have little to do with investigations on these kinds of things. In the end, though, I don't think talking about the upsides and downsides of anonymous money makes any difference. Bitcoin isn't really anonymous, but it's only a matter of time before easily anonymous money exists, and there's really nothing that can be done to stop that.