7 ms·
> some of it... much less so Like what?
by lisper 11y ago
> some of it... much less so
Like what?
- tptacek 11y agoDelegating to journalists he hardly knew a cache of documents so large that he could not possibly have read them, cheerleading the disclosure of intelligence secrets that had nothing directly to do with the surveillance of Americans.
- lisper 11y agoDelegating that job to journalists has always seemed to me like a responsible decision on his part. What would you have had him do instead? If the journalists released "intelligence secrets that had nothing directly to do with the surveillance of Americans" (it's not clear to me that they did, but I'm willing to suspend disbelief here) isn't that on them, not Snowden?
- davidw 11y agoThey obviously wouldn't have the stuff to release in the first place if it weren't for him.
- Nadya 11y agoI never understand this reasoning. That all the burden should be placed on Snowden to pour over the documents and determine what is breaking the law and what isn't. He was fairly certain a majority of it was - at that point it's most responsible of him to hand it off to people who are in a better decision to make those calls. 1) Do you expect a single person to go through 1000's of documents with their rudimentary understandings and interpretations of the law? Would you and why would you trust him if so? 2) Should he have a lawyer go through the documents with him? 3) Should he get second opinions on whether or not something is breaking the law? 4) Should he trust a team of respected journalists and their team of lawyers to go through the documents on his behalf? The journalists he released the documents to have trust that they've established for years. That makes them hard to dismiss as looney bins. Snowden does not have that trust and would have been easy to dismiss by himself.
- davidw 11y agoAs per my other comment above/below - I think he's basically handled it as well as he could under the circumstances. Most of what's come out is pretty much targeting nefarious and/or potentially illegal practices. I think his actions have been - and hopefully will continue to be - a positive force for change. But - yes, he chose to release that material. If, for instance, the journalists released something irresponsible that, say, led to deaths of people, that's still part of a chain of events that leads to him and his decision. I'm glad he did what he did, and so far things seem to have gone ok, and I can't imagine the stress and pressure he's under.
- Nadya 11y ago>But - yes, he chose to release that material. You either blow the whistle or remain silent. Choosing to not release the material would mean he's compliant, and not a whistle blower. Which - given the details that have come to light - I judge the compliance of the individuals impeding on my rights to privacy far harsher than I judge Snowden as a whistle blower. >If, for instance, the journalists released something irresponsible that, say, led to deaths of people Do you think Snowden or the journalist team are more or less likely to release something irresponsibly that would lead to the deaths of people? My bets are on Snowden; had he acted alone. Simply because as an individual he is less capable of citing/knowing which laws what is breaking, what should be released and shouldn't be released (he would have to make that call himself, rather than discussing it among others), how details may be interpreted by the public, dangers of releasing certain information, etc. I believe it would be inevitable for him to fuck up had he acted alone. Your argument boils down to "he shouldn't have blown the whistle" and I cannot agree with that. At all.
- davidw 11y ago> Your argument boils down to "he shouldn't have blown the whistle" and I cannot agree with that. You're simplifying it too much. I think he did the right thing, but took some big risks of varying kinds, too. That's part of what makes someone a 'hero' isn't it? Pressing forward in the face of uncertainty and danger. I was just arguing with the "it's all on the journalists if something goes awry" line.
- tptacek 11y agoRead everything, disclose only information that he could reasonably connect to the NSA violating the rights of Americans. Not reveal everything all at once. Not assume that a particular journalist whose politics he supported would (a) carefully minimize the leak to whistleblowing material only and (b) be competent enough to protect it against the intelligence services of other countries. I don't see what's so complicated about that.
- gozo 11y agoI just not sure how much choice you can afford when going up against a state actor. I would say spreading the "blame" and being a public figure was quite crucial to increasing the odds of success and providnig less incentive for the US government to take action.
- soared 11y ago> he could not possibly have read them > Read everything Well...
- ikeboy 11y agoSee http://www.vanityfair.com/news/2013/06/errors-edward-snowden-global-hypocrisy-tour http://www.vanityfair.com/news/2013/06/errors-edward-snowden...
- effie 11y agoThat's some very untrustworthy language used there. The article expresses lots of allegations, doubts and negative opinions, but never mentions the big brother surveillance, the point of what Snowden did and the immense value for society of it. Even if some published documents were harmful to US government, it is not Snowden who published them. The article reads more like a manipulative government propaganda than like a balanced text written by a genuine journalist.
- ikeboy 11y ago> never mentions the big brother surveillance That's false. >immense value for society of it The question we're addressing here is not "Did Snowden do good things?" The question is whether he is a hero, and the fact that he did bad things is relevant. You could argue that he did more good than bad, and I might even agree; but doing more good than bad doesn't make someone a hero. the data-mining program that slurps up e-mail and phone data of American citizens >Even if some published documents were harmful to US government, it is not Snowden who published them. He gave them to journalists that published them. How is it not his fault?
- effie 11y agoYou're right, the article mentions it. But it does not do a good job at that, it does not paint things in proportion. The big brother surveillance and recording of everybody in US is euphemised as "domestic surveillance program" and "data-mining program". The focus of the article is on slandering Snowden. "The question we're addressing here is not "Did Snowden do good things?" The question is whether he is a hero, and the fact that he did bad things is relevant." The article, as some groups do, tries to turn people from thinking and talking about the important things such as the big brother surveillance and questioning government to various irrelevant issues, such as "isn't he a traitor". They try to mislead your attention astray. Don't let them; think for yourself.
- davidw 11y agoBy and large, what's been released seems relatively pertinent and 'on target'. To me it seems like he's handled it all pretty well, especially given the circumstances: I can't imagine the pressure and stress. I'm much more ambivalent about the wikileaks cables leak, because that truly was a massive data dump, much of which was not exposing any wrongdoing, just private conversations.
- caskance 11y agoThe Belgacom stuff and TAO catalog leap immediately to mind as things that went way over the line.
- justcommenting 11y agoIt's disappointing to see someone who is usually so thoughtful on these issues implying that the mass surveillance of the ~7 billion people on this planet who are not Americans was inappropriate to disclose. Perhaps you meant something different, but that's not how your comment reads.
- Alupis 11y agoWell, to be fair, most Americans are unlikely to care about foreign surveillance (although I can hear Team America World Police playing in the background right about now...). The issues that upset Americans is going to be the domestic surveillance programs.
- tptacek 11y agoYes, disclosing that was inappropriate. What else do you want to know? I'm not demanding that you agree with me, but I would push back on the idea that my argument is unreasonable. I have conservative friends and I have an-cap friends and friends at many points in between. The an-caps oppose all espionage by any state anywhere; the conservatives think disclosure of any spying by the USG is treason. Not everyone agrees about this stuff. This thread is rooted in a comment that expresses surprise that there are Americans that oppose what Snowden did. Well, there are a lot of Americans who oppose it, for a bunch of different reasons. So: be less surprised.
- vezzy-fnord 11y agothe conservatives think disclosure of any spying by the USG is treason Neoconservatives, anyway. Conservatives as classical liberals, as well as paleocons, would largely align with the anti-surveillance side.
- tptacek 11y agoNeoconservatives are conservatives who believe in a muscular foreign policy focused on the middle east centered on support for Israel. Tea Party conservatives aren't neoconservatives, nor are libertarians.
- mwerd 11y agoJournalists with a publicly verifiable track record who had a history of adversarial journalism. He chose them for their principles, not their charisma. It seems like you're grasping at straws here. How is an embedded contractor with high level security clearances supposed to get cozy with journalists? It's ludicrous. Snowden watched what happened to Bill Binney and Thomas Drake and knew that the suggested whistleblowing path was a trap. Journalists were the second to last resort (the last being the wikileaks approach). The outcomes are evident. He was right. There is/was a problem and courts and commentators worldwide acknowledge that. Hell, even Obama acknowledged there were problems. And on your last point: it turns out non-Americans have human rights too, something that Snowden would have no-doubt recognized after living in Switzerland. American exceptionalism bullshit is no excuse for crimes against humanity (i.e. mass surveillance). These are uncharacteristically dumb comments from you.
- slg 11y agoWhen he revealed this [1] was when I started to question Snowden. Hacking into the networks of a destabilized foreign power that is fighting a civil war that involves huge American interests including eventual military action seems like exactly the thing the NSA is supposed to be doing. [1] - http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/aug/13/snowden-nsa-syria-internet-outage-civil-war http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/aug/13/snowden-nsa-syr...
- lisper 11y agoTo be clear, Snowden didn't reveal this to the public, the Guardian did. So it seems to me that if this shouldn't have been revealed, this is on them, not Snowden (unless you want to argue that none of what Snowden handed over to the Guardian should have been revealed).
- slg 11y agoThat doesn't appear to be the case. From the second paragraph of the linked article: >In an interview with Wired magazine, Snowden said the elite NSA hacking unit, called Tailored Access Operations, accidentally cut off Syria’s internet while attempting to infiltrate it. This [1] appears to be the interview the article is referencing. Either way, Snowden is 100% responsible for everything that is revealed regardless of whether it was revealed by himself directly or a journalist with which he shared the information. You can't just pipe secret information through a journalist to absolve yourself of leaking that info. [1] - http://www.wired.com/2014/08/edward-snowden/ http://www.wired.com/2014/08/edward-snowden/
- soylentcola 11y agoAt the same time, he's not responsible for the people actually, you know...doing those things. It's like if I steal a car and some dude I know calls the cops with an anonymous tip. They then tell the owner. Sure, the dude is "responsible" for the owner learning about it even if the info was piped through the cops. It doesn't change the fact that I'm the one responsible for stealing the car.
- 11y ago
- tajen 11y agoThe Safe Harbour with Europe has been revoked based on proof presented in the Snowden documents. I'm European so I'm happy, but this wasn't in the best interests of US. Unless we're talking about freedom of speech.
- jacquesm 11y ago> but this wasn't in the best interests of US. In the short term. In the longer term it is in everybody's interests, including the US.
- effie 11y agoRevoking Safe Harbour could be in the long-term best interests of american society, if not of the US government. It may help people in tech companies in pushing harder against the surveillance by government and freedom restrictions it imposes.