5 ms·
> I wonder why they can't see the obvious wrongdoing by our leadership and how it erodes our values. It's because traditional Christian values have been hijac
by lisper 11y ago
> I wonder why they can't see the obvious wrongdoing by our leadership and how it erodes our values.
It's because traditional Christian values have been hijacked by business leaders who believe it is in their best interests to cultivate a populace with unquestioning deference to authority. (They're probably right about that too.)
- tptacek 11y agoThis is an uncharacteristically dumb comment from you.
- lisper 11y agoWell, thanks for the backhanded compliment. But why do you think it's dumb? It seems self-evidently true to me.
- tptacek 11y agoThat what this thread needs is a bunch of culture war bullshit about traditional Christian values?
- lisper 11y agoIf the shoe fits...
- tptacek 11y agoReally? "Wake up sheeple" is all you have?
- lisper 11y agoUm, no. Let's review: the comment to which I was responding was by someone who considers Snowden a hero and couldn't understand why his midwestern family considered him a traitor. The OP specifically couched his confusion in terms of Christian values, and even cited a Bible passage. I responded with an answer to the question that he posed in the terms in which he posed it, and which made a factual claim that I believe to be correct, and which I can support with evidence. That's what I meant by "if the shoe fits..." (Just in case you're not aware: https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/if_the_shoe_fits https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/if_the_shoe_fits)
- tptacek 11y agoYou know what? You're totally right, and I'm wrong. I apologize. I still want to push back on the idea that people raised in conservative Christian families are necessarily authoritarian, but I'd have better luck doing that in a conversation I hadn't already poisoned by jumping the gun.
- lisper 11y ago> I apologize. Apology accepted. > I still want to push back on the idea that people raised in conservative Christian families are necessarily authoritarian You'd have even better luck if you pushed back against something I actually said. I never said that Christian families are necessarily authoritarian (though there are clearly strong traditions of authoritarianism in many branches of Christianity). What I said was that traditional Christian values have been corrupted by cynical business interests for material gain. And again, this seems to me to be self-evidently true. Look up "prosperity gospel" for example.
- visakanv 11y agoYou can always choose to ignore the bullshit and focus on having a thoughtful conversation!
- squidfood 11y agoIt's a bit unfair to blame "business leaders" when this trend of Christian power-politics started with Constantine the Great.
- Synaesthesia 11y agoWell they are the current leaders who are carrying on the tradition.
- skwirl 11y agoMy life experience has been that Christian vs. non-Christian is not a valuable lens through which to view the world and will lead you to some pretty crazy places, and it looks like you have landed in one of those crazy places.
- lisper 11y agoI only couched it in those terms because the comment I was responding to couched it in those terms.
- hitekker 11y agoWhile it's true business leaders will promulgate myths such as "the lord helps those who helps themselves" and "the first thing jesus christ will do in the second coming is repeal the estate tax", they are one faction out of many types of elites seeking to distort mainstream christianity to fit their values.
- drumdance 11y agoAnd they may actually believe those things. That's the issue I have with the parent. He's basically suggesting they're all liars.
- mediocrejoker 11y agoIs it dumb because it's untrue or because it won't generate valuable discussion here?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 11y agoThis was an all- too- characteristically dumb knee-jerk response from me. Sorry.
- larrys 11y ago"who believe it is in their best interests to cultivate a populace with unquestioning deference to authority" The populace doesn't ask questions. They simply parrot what a few outspoken people with a mouthpiece tell them to do or think. Most people are lemmings they don't have your brain (I looked at your resume). Not that every conclusion that you would come to would be correct. But in the everyday world (away from NYC, SV and HN) the mediocrity and low level thinking of everyday people is stunning. A large amount of lawn signs is enough to get you elected to local office.
- explorigin 11y ago> But in the everyday world (away from NYC, SV and HN) the mediocrity and low level thinking of everyday people is stunning. Please don't think that 3 communities contain the monopoly on critical thinking. From my observation (living in the "Bible belt"), it comes from a person's news media sources. Television and newspapers (traditional news media) parrot party lines and support the two-party duopoly. People that have always gotten their news this way understandably are easily controlled. There is a newer generation (not just young people) that use the internet as an augment or even primary source of news[1]. This gives a completely different perspective on world events. These sorts of people are all over the world. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jOeAa6Ye4dc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jOeAa6Ye4dc
- drumdance 11y agowho believe it is in their best interests to cultivate a populace with unquestioning deference to authority Facts not in evidence. You really think you can know what they believe in their hearts?
- laotzu 11y ago>Avoiding the risk of transgression has become more important to us than carrying a difficult position for God. And it is this that is killing us. "The more dangerous a thing, the more is its conquest ordained by life": it is from that conviction that the modern world has emerged; and from that our religion, too, must be reborn. -Pierre Teilhard de Chardin
- marcusgarvey 11y agoQuite right. One example is the whole "support the troops" fetishism you find in the midwest and the south. If you really supported them you would not want to send them off to dangerous places for spurious reasons.