3 ms·
"Nothing wrong"? - The ads are almost never useful for the consumers - Companies keep shoveling money into ad campaigns just so that marketing teams can justi
by rglullis 11y ago
"Nothing wrong"?
- The ads are almost never useful for the consumers
- Companies keep shoveling money into ad campaigns just so that marketing teams can justify their budgets
- Ad publishers are incentivized to completely undermine the idea of private data
- Thomas Watson is often mocked for saying "I think there is a world market for maybe five computers". If we look today at Google, Facebook, Amazon, Microsoft and Apple, we are not that far from that reality. The "ad economy" is at direct odds against an open web.
I'll give you that Google's breakthrough came because they could find a way to revenue, and that without ads they would never bring many useful things for fruition. But the best way to justify their wealth creation is that they manage to make the social function of advertising (connect producers and consumers) and make it more effective.
There was almost zero progress in that regards afterwards. It is just a race to the bottom. I can actually bet that we would be better off without these products, services and media if they were gone. Case in point: one of the links on the front-page right now is http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2015/11/04/no-spooning-isn-t-sexist-the-internet-is-just-broken.html http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2015/11/04/no-spooning...
- scintill76 11y ago> The ads are almost never useful for the consumers My favorite thing about this is that I occasionally see an ad I am interested in, just as the page is reloading. I go back to try to see it again, and I get a different ad. I refresh several times, getting more ads but not the one I saw first. Oh well, I guess I won't buy that after all. :D If it makes them feel better, I'm probably most interested when it's a promotion, so they didn't lose as much money.
- eli 11y ago"The ads aren't relevant" could just as well be an argument for better ad targeting.
- manigandham 11y agoI've heard all this arguments and more a 1000 times, it's nothing new and usually based on emotions and opinions rather than any objective study. 1) Ads are useful for consumers as it leads to them solving their problem. Whether that's a discovering a new service or buying a product, they needed something and they got it. It's still ultimately their decision. 2) Do you know the best thing about digital ads? It's the data. These aren't billboards that are bought without any idea who's seeing them or giant print ads bought on ego, we can tell exactly who's clicking on what and what they do after all the way to purchase. It's not just money thrown around, it leads to real bottom line results. The ad industry is one of the biggest data-driven industries in the world, contrary to what many might think. 3) Not sure how you came to this conclusion. There is no such thing as the "ad economy"... it's just a business model and industry, not some major paradigm of society. It will always exist because it works and serves and need, and outside of the direct monetization, it's the best form of payment there is. It's quick, passive and requires no decision willpower and is the primary reason for so many websites and such a large open web. We wouldn't have nearly as many sources on the internet if it weren't for ads. The monopolies you mentioned exist in every industry because that's the most efficient way to scale and run a business, it's got nothing to do with ads specifically. 4) I don't get the last point - are you saying that article isn't worth anything? Why? because you don't like it? So you're the judge of good content? I'm not a fan of celeb news but it's a huge market and draw for readers online so who am I to judge? There are billions of people with their own interests and needs, nobody get's to just set the baseline here. Yes there are scams and fraudulent stuff and arguably 'low-quality' bits out there but this exists in every field and is a constant battle. It doesn't mean we devalue everything because of it.
- rglullis 11y ago1) What I was talking about Google being one exception to the rule. The thing is that at least with AdWords you get related to your search. When I am reading some news, the last thing I care about is if I could be missing some opportunity to buy a car, or if be bombarded with ads from Coca-Cola, or some possible tourist destination. Ultimately, there is no problem to be solved when people are visiting whatever source of content they are going for. That people that tolerate ads in web pages do it only because they think it is the only way to get the content for free, not because of the value-add of the promoted advertisement. 2) Yes, the best thing about digital ads is the data... for the marketers. The producers get very little real benefit from it and in the end are put in an arms race by the marketing companies that tell them that the only way to keep their market share is by outspending the competition. 3 and 4) "We wouldn't have nearly as many sources on the Internet if it weren't for ads." That would be great, actually. We need more quality, not quantity. What you list as qualities ("quick, passive and requires no decision willpower") is exactly what brings the quality of the content down. And yes, I am saying that the linked article is worthless. Not because I just don't like it, but because I seriously doubt that the "huge market" would actually vote with their wallets to get that kind of content produced. We don't need ad money to fund something like Wikipedia. Conversely, ad money is what makes Buzzfeed, Gawker and Jezebel to pass for journalism nowadays. And these are not even the worst around. -- I truly believe that people accepting ads as a way to get content is one of the largest disgraces for society in the digital age. I like to make the analogy with the corn industry and the government subsidies since the 70's. People wanted to get "cheap" food, and all they got was externalized costs. Years later we got an obesity epidemic, huge costs in healthcare and corn-ethanol, which is energy net-negative. The Advertisement industry does the same thing for our culture, our education, our civic values (slacktivism) and the economy at large. This "just a business model" is morally bankrupt.
- manigandham 11y ago1) Ads work whether you care about them or not. Google isn't an exception to anything, they run ads and you either have a problem with ads or you don't. You're just more accepting to ad suggestions when searching since you're in a natural discover mode and Google is extremely relevant because you type your intent right into the search box, that's about as good as it gets. 2) The producers/manufacturers get all the data they want. Don't you think they know who's buying their stuff? The money comes from them to the agencies and ad networks so they will always know the most. And yes, marketing is a race because it works. They have to spend to get people aware and interested in their products and services. There's always a user acquisition cost, especially if you're competing with another company for the same user. It's not some made up thing. These companies aren't stupid. If they could do it without it they would. 3) Have you read the journalism that Buzzfeed puts out? They have an acclaimed hard news section and are partners with even the White House. They have several levels of content in depth and coverage, much like many other media companies. Again YOU are not the judge of quality and the mass market already spends lots of money on tons of things that are similar to what you claim is low quality media. It's just not that simple to suggest that certain things somehow don't value to someone else. 4) Wikipedia isn't a business. They don't do anything except host servers and have some developers building features. ALL of their content is user generated. No real business can work that way. --- It's FAR better to have democratic and free access to content rather than tying it to direct payments and vastly limiting access and amount. That is going backwards to the entire intent of the internet and the spread of information.