4 ms·
> Dart for mobile Dart was originally designed for the client-side as a challenger to Javascript, and I consider it to have generally succeeded in its ulterior
by kibwen 11y ago
> Dart for mobile
Dart was originally designed for the client-side as a challenger to Javascript, and I consider it to have generally succeeded in its ulterior goal of spurring the Javascript standardization committee into greater velocity out of threat of competition. Recently it's pivoted towards server-side programming, though I could see it finding a home in mobile app development. Given its familiarity to Java, it was always more likely than Go to succeed Java on Android (though IMO less likely than a typed variant of Javascript).
To be clear I don't think this is an "official stand" proclaiming Dart as the future of Android (and regardless of Oracle's asshattery, I don't see Google outright removing Java support any time soon). As other commenters have pointed out, Google has more than one ongoing initiative in this area.
- sandGorgon 11y agoAm I wrong in thinking that Dart VM on Android is the only other VM that has been officially released by Google ? Doesnt that make for a pretty strong statement ?
- shadowmint 11y agoNo. This isn't the same thing at all. The C# runtime on android is used by thousands of apps; this is simply a dart runtime that runs on android. This is a cool project; and its great to see people trying to do interesting things with dart; Dart as it currently stands is a total and abject failure in all of its goals as a replacement for javascript. New goals for it to live as a mobile platform might give it a breath of fresh air. Pretty nice to see; it's a nice language with a good ecosystem, if it gains traction as a 'app' language, it could go places. ...but this is absolutely not Google saying 'the future of android is dart'.
- afsina 11y ago>this is simply a dart runtime that runs on android. User facing side of the framework is written in Dart. That means something.
- shadowmint 11y agoNot really. The User facing side of unity is written in C#. /me spins finger in the air... This is like any other 'insert language here' mobile runtime with native bindings to the mobile apis (eg. camera, etc) and its own widget library. Unity and kivy spring immediately to mind as examples of other ones. Hardly revolutionary.
- kibwen 11y agoGoogle is notorious for officially funding multiple competing solutions to every problem under the sun. I'm not trying to discount how important this is for Dart, but this announcement here doesn't carry even a thousandth of the heft as e.g. Apple's support for Swift over Obj-C.
- lern_too_spel 11y agoYes, that is wrong. They have also released V8.
- aikah 11y ago> Dart was originally designed for the client-side as a challenger to Javascript, and I consider it to have generally succeeded in its ulterior goal of spurring the Javascript standardization committee into greater velocity out of threat of competition Dart was never a threat to JS in anyway. I don't think it had any effect on ES spec. ES spec evolved "faster" because the committee changed, the old guard (anti OO ) moved on and Microsoft didn't sabotage the effort this time. Things were way different back in 2007 for those who remember it. MS had a commercial interest in not wanting ES4 to succeed ( Silverlight ) while ironically Adobe and the Flash team were pushing for a strong standard. So I fail to see how Dart has anything to do with ES6 success.
- kibwen 11y agoI tend to agree that Dart was never a "threat" to Javascript (smarter hackers than I have remarked at how difficult it would be to have both V8 and the Dart VM playing nicely together), but at the time of its announcement Dart (nee Dash) was certainly the cause of much consternation over potential fragmentation of the web. I recall more than a few of Brendan Eich's impassioned denouncements of Dart during that time. Dart's origin was just as much political as it was technical (though I do think it's transcended that origin to become quite a nice language, though still trying to find its foothold in the dev community).