10 ms·
The Buddhist Priest Who Became a Billionaire Snubbing Investors
- ddellacosta 11y agoForget it, says Kazuo Inamori, entrepreneur, management guru and Buddhist priest. Spend your time making staff happy instead. Huh...and here I thought Kyocera had a reputation in Japan for being a terrible place to work. (sorry, no luck finding links in English, but search for 京セラブラック企業) and you get a fair number of links. https://www.google.com/search?q=京セラブラック企業 https://www.google.com/search?q=京セラブラック企業 EDIT: (ブラック企業 = https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Company_%28Japanese_term%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Company_%28Japanese_term...)
- Nadya 11y agoTo be fair, a lot can change in a decade, which seems to be what most results are centered around (a whistle blower from 1999 who wrote a book). But it isn't exactly ranked high by employees [0]. Also may want to explain what ブラック企業 means. I can take an educated guess but I'm not 100% certain I'm right. [0] https://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=ja&u=http://www.vorkers.com/company.php%3Fm_id%3Da0910000000FrTH&prev=search https://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=ja&u=http://...
- patio11 11y agoA "black company" is one which abuses employees in such a manner as to shock the conscience of a Japanese salaryman. Normal company: Work Monday to Saturday, Sunday off. Black company: two Sundays a month off... but you have to work on them anyhow Normal company: 70 hour workweek involving 20+ hours of paid overtime. Black company: the overtime is uncompensated ("service" overtime)/ Normal company: underperforming employees are ostracized or criticized. Black company: underperforming employees, or performing employees, are subjected to "power harassment" or physical violence. Incidentally, salaryman loyalty counsels that one's own company is never a black company... I mean sure, there might be some disreputable firms in Tokyo, but we are just going through a crunch period, Tanaka-buchou is well-known to be demanding, that project is over budget so sacrifices must be made, etc. Many Japanese salarymen of my acquaintance would identify the core underlying sin as "failing to uphold the company's end of the bargain all of us know we're making" and would say "It's mostly a thing at tiny SMBs who don't have the economic resources to consistently treat employees correctly." If it isn't completely obvious, I have strong reservations about salarymanhood as a system and how the discourse of "black companies" is designed to and functions as insulation for that system.
- nikatwork 11y agoMy outside impression of Japan and Taiwan is that they're horrific places for corporate work across the board. Is this a stereotype fuelled by the black companies, or is it largely accurate?
- patio11 11y agoI have no personal experience of working in Taiwan, but anecdotally, it has a Japan-esque work culture. Full-time employment at a traditionally managed Japanese company -- i.e. being a salaryman -- is, largely, not an experience I would recommend to someone I loved. There exist some startups or e.g. foreign-owned firms which would be far less odious options. Living in Japan is wonderful. A++ would totally immigrate again. A substantial portion of my present happiness is having created a job which means that I am 99.8% insulated from Japanese megacorps.
- anon4 11y agoTangentially, I keep seeing those figures, but can't figure out how it happens. I mean, how is there enough work for every single corporate drone to work 70 hours per week, plus an additional 20? What the heck is it that all those people do? Not trying to be derisive, I'm just genuinely curious if it's actual work, or if they clock in, spend 5 hours playing Fate/GO and 5 hours adjusting the spreadsheet a bit.
- patio11 11y agoIt's not highest-and-best-productive work -- if you actually try that, like a stupid young American, you will quickly be taken aside and told to stop making your teammates look bad. You'll spend lots of time on meetings, meetings to schedule meetings, corporate rituals, meetings to discuss improvement of corporate rituals, reading the newspaper, and doing a solid 6 hours of work in a 14 hour day.
- anon4 11y agoFewer hours at work and no dress code are never on the table, I suppose... On another tangent, is there no japanese analogue to Scott Adams's Dilbert? People must be self-aware of the system, right?
- sdrothrock 11y agoIt does have a terrible reputation. "happy" is being used unconventionally. > [Inamori's] brand of happiness comes from working harder than anyone else. It’s infused with the Buddhist idea of “shojin,” elevating the soul through devotion to a task.
- sdrothrock 11y agoAlso, since it's too late to edit: Kyoto has a reputation (anecdotally, a well-deserved one) for having a large number of black companies.
- hardwaresofton 11y agoSo I don't think Kyocera is one of the top "black companies". At the very least, anecdotally, they haven't made the lists mentioned by some of my friends. Generally I found that the "black"est companies in Japan happen to be the ones that pay the most (that aren't foreign held). IMHO, most "pure-bred" Japanese companies vary from a shade of gray to black. A lot of the things that are part of work life there would be probably pretty off-putting to us, starting from recruitment (during college).
- euske 11y agoIt's worth noting that the term ブラック企業 is now a kind of buzzword and a general slander that carries little meaning. I can see why people like using it because the sound it makes in Japanese is mildly shocking and tarnishing.
- hardwaresofton 11y agoNope, it definitely carries a lot of meaning still. Many younger members of the japanese work force (those are the only people I can claim to have talked about this kind of thing to), have a pretty clear perception of what makes a "black company": - Unreasonable hours - Distinct social pressure to not leave before your boss - Non-optional drinking after work - Absurd drinking rituals (ex. when you cheers, your cup must be below the more senior employees, a senior employee's cup near you should never be less than 80%) - Threat of being randomly reassigned to a distant town if you get on someone's nerves - list goes on...
- plonh 11y agoI thought that is normal salaryman culture, not the extra bad "black company"
- hardwaresofton 11y agoWell this is what I meant in an earlier post about most companies going from grey to black -- I think it's well understood that black companies have AT LEAST these issues (and I'm sure more that I don't know about), but this is definitely not the case at every japanese company I think... I think one of the only exceptions I know of is Nikon, I've heard they don't have such strict/crazy practices. Trying hard to think of more exceptions, but I can't, so maybe you're right :\
- smegel 11y ago> split staff into often tiny units that make their own plans The problem is this just doesn't work in some countries. It is as much about Japanese society and culture than the CEO that even makes this possible to begin with.
- ni-hil 11y agoCan you elaborate? What social and/or cultural aspects do you see as roadblocks? And in which countries?
- smegel 11y agoJapanese people actually practice integrity. If they find a wallet on the street, they will make every effort to return it to its owner - with the cash still inside. If you let small groups of employees "do their own thing" it might actually result in increased productivity and improved moral rather than disintegration and widespread corruption. Japanese culturally enforce and reward conformity to this modality. > And in which countries? Well I'm not sure there are many countries that can compare to Japan's homogeneous cultural ethic, it really is unique in many ways.
- hardwaresofton 11y agoGeneralizations are risky as always. I don't think it's clear that splitting employees into small, self-sufficient groups correlates to a dip in productivity regardless of whether any/all of the employees have "integrity" or not (if I understood you correctly, you're stating that splitting into small groups may not work if "integrity" is not present). I put integrity in quotes because the very concept is pretty nebulous, especially when crossing country boundaries. But, I can concede there's at least a general understanding of the word, and I can't say that's what motivates people to do good work/be productive. At the very least, it's not the only carrot, and you're completely forgetting the stick (which of course, is discouraged these days, but it definitely has it's uses).
- mahranch 11y agoBut is that ethic and morality something that is impossible for other cultures to emulate or adopt? If so, why? I think "culture" is a dynamic thing, it's changeable. I think the evidence of this is abundant & widespread (See: most countries adopting western/hollywood culture since the 1920s). I often see a similar argument from gun nuts. You show them that Japan has a ban on guns and that they have zero hand-gun related deaths annually, show them that they have among the lowest crime rate in the world, and they use the excuse of "Oh, it's a different culture. It's not comparable". That's nonsense logic to me. All it means is we also need to change our culture too, then. Sure, it's another factor to consider, but that's all. It's not a roadblock.
- Amorymeltzer 11y agoSay what you will, but >After taking the CEO role without pay, he printed a small book for each staff member on his philosophies, which declared that the company was devoted to their growth. >"Company leaders should seek to make all their employees happy, both materially and intellectually," Inamori said. I'd take a pay cut to work at a place like that. Enjoying your work, feeling like you will be taken care of, and being able to grow and develop are huge "benefits" that aren't easy to find in many jobs. ETA: Regarding the cutting of 16,000 jobs, yeah, not grand. But the article isn't clear on why, and if anything it's implied they were efficiency cuts. Man does it suck to lose your job, but 33% is better than 100% and companies really shouldn't have that much bloat.
- anpk 11y ago> In a 2004 book on his philosophy, he questioned Japanese people’s increasing tendency to value leisure time. That makes one of us.
- rl3 11y agoTo further expand on this: >When Inamori talks about making employees happy, he doesn’t mean they’ll be putting their feet up. His brand of happiness comes from working harder than anyone else. It’s infused with the Buddhist idea of “shojin,” elevating the soul through devotion to a task. That's nice and all, but not if it comes at the expense of employee leisure time or pay.
- modfodder 11y agoAs a freelancer I'm devoted to my task of maximizing the amount of leisure time.
- jackvalentine 11y agoDoes shojin conflict with a modern office job in which you have many tasks and many responsibilities? I can instinctively understand the idea if I were cutting wood or doing some other manual task, but I am having trouble picturing myself at work being able to get in to the right mindset if I have multiple moving pieces in every hour of the day.
- harryh 11y agoThis seems like a pretty clear false dichotomy. The best companies tend to be great for both employees and shareholders.
- GavinMcG 11y agoThat's why the article points out that it's not a dichotomy, and that "the man himself sees no conflict".
- PhasmaFelis 11y agoYou rarely hear complaints of companies that have neglected their shareholders in favor of their employees, while the reverse is endemic. When the scales are overbalanced this badly, you need to give them a firm shove, not carefully add equal weights to both side.
- hugh4 11y agoThe fact that you don't hear about it is largely because employees tend to be better at whining to the media when they don't get their way than shareholders. The American landscape is littered with many large companies which have gone bankrupt by giving in to all their employees' demands at the cost of profitability. The big airlines, for instance. And the carmakers.
- PhasmaFelis 11y ago> The fact that you don't hear about it is largely because employees tend to be better at whining to the media when they don't get their way than shareholders. That would seem to violate everything we know about public relations, i.e. it's a whole lot easier to get your voice heard when you have money.
- hugh4 11y agoNot at all, you need money and a good sob story. Nobody cares about the sob story of the rich hedge fund which isn't making as much money as it could be, they want sob stories with blue-collar workers sitting at a kitchen table looking balefully into the camera.
- percept 11y ago“If you want eggs, take care of the hen,” Inamori said in an interview on Oct. 23. “If you bully or kill the hen, it’s not going to work.”
- beedyg 11y ago> His turnaround also cut roughly a third of the airline’s workforce, about 16,000 people. At first glance that looks an awful lot like bullying the hen
- j2bax 11y agoOr is it killing the hen to ensure the other hens can continue eating and being happy?
- vidarh 11y agoHe also returned the company to profitability, and brought it back out of bankruptcy, without which it's very much possible that all of the staff rather than "just" 1/3 would have had to find new jobs. It's perfectly possible he could have managed without, or with fewer, redundancies, but pointing to redundancies as evidence he's not thinking of staff is short-sighted. It sucks to have people lose jobs, but the solution to that is not to have companies hold on to unsustainable amounts of staff to the extent where they are at risk of failing.
- beedyg 11y agoIf one assumes that the 1/3 job losses were 'trimming the fat', I'd still argue that enforced liposuction constitutes bullying (if not outright assault). The decision to cut the workforce may have been the right one but since the thrust of the article was the effectiveness of his philosophy I think it's only fair to highlight how it was applied.
- im3w1l 11y agoIf you see nothing wrong with this statement, you need to watch more PETA videos...
- mmanfrin 11y agoIs Kyocera really doing well? I see less and less of Kyocera these days, and an amazon search shows knives and one budget Android phone. Are they big in Japan?
- bharath28 11y agoI wish the article shed more light on actual practices within the company and measures they took to make employees happy. Without the details, the claim seems to be somewhat unsubstantiated.
- scotty79 11y agoShares are just tokens that can appreciate and depreciate in value (not unlike bitcoin). Price of shares usually has nothing to do with condition or more importantly future of the company. It depends solely on whim of people who have too much money and time and noting better to do with those. Idea that the company should be managed in a way that would raise the price of shares is silly. Trading shares is a game and what company does after making shares available for purchase serves only as random seed for share price. There are two parts to stock market. One is providing capital to companies. Selling shares is a way to do that. But not many people would buy shares because growing companies is risky and slow business. It would be only as attractive as buying shares just for the dividend. Thus we need a twist to make things more interesting so that people will act against their own interest. Proven thing that makes people part with their money is a lottery so we change shares into sort of token that players can trade between themselves. Heard behaviors provides the necessary randomness and the thrill. And that's how and why of stock market. Attempts to further sync the game with the reality are stupid, harmful and unnecessary.
- clarkmoody 11y ago> Price of shares usually has nothing to do with condition or more importantly future of the company. A plummeting share price makes it easy to accumulate the stock and use the voting power to orchestrate a takeover of the management. Keeping your company's market cap high enough to avoid a takeover is a real thing. Beyond that, you're right, small moves in price mean nothing for the company short term.
- oxryly1 11y agoI agree, to an extent. But I did get burned by this mindset... I owned a non-trivial amount of MSFT back in the 90s, and they had never paid dividends. Instead, their share price seemed to be linked to the tech bubble and their own popularity. I bought as part of that herd mentality. Eventually, though, I realized that their share price was really not bound by anything concrete, so I sold. A month later, they paid out a big dividend. I missed out on a decent payday.
- nicholas73 11y ago
- gotchange 11y agoThe guy looks like a fraud to me. The employees should be accountable to the management, and the management in turn should be accountable to the board which in turn they should be accountable to shareholders and believe it or not the General Assembly of shareholders can push for a vote of no confidence for the management and kick them out and elect a new board. That's how accountability, transparency and good corporate governance work. If you see any reluctance, hesitation, or outright objections from management, that's a sign that there's something wrong with them and they're hiding something. Also, his anti-shareholder rhetoric could jeopardize his mission as a CEO of the corporations he presides over as it would limit his option of raising capital on the open market esp in times of need because if you treat your shareholders like that and someday you that you need to finance a new project by tapping the equity market through issuing new shares, rest assured the existing shareholders will make you pay for every bad word you said about them while potential ones would be very skeptical of your intentions and ability to deliver due to your awful politics.
- fisk 11y agoSo his way to take care of the hen is to track its efficiency, give it a book telling it to be humble, and to fire it? Well, possibly that was the semi-subtle point of the article -- that he says one thing, but here's a read-between-the-lines lack of evidence that it's more than talk.
- JackFr 11y agoThis is utter nonsense. He simply is an excellent manager. He cut 1/3 of the workforce and began tracking hourly efficiency (presumably to the benefit of the company). That he's a Buddhist priest is not central to the story.
- TheOtherHobbes 11y agoIt's the corporate version of this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orientalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orientalism It was very popular in the 70s when Japanese business was totally a thing. The Japanese are probably reading something loosely related about Tim Cook and the shareholder-indifferent culture at Apple.
- jpatokal 11y ago> From Kyocera’s headquarters overlooking the hills and temples of the ancient capital of Kyoto... Ah yes, that old trope. This is what people think Kyoto looks like: http://i.telegraph.co.uk/multimedia/archive/02657/kyoto_2657285b.jpg http://i.telegraph.co.uk/multimedia/archive/02657/kyoto_2657... But it's a city of 1.5m, and this is what it actually looks like: http://nward.com/myworld/places/japan/214.jpg http://nward.com/myworld/places/japan/214.jpg
- HaloZero 11y agoI imagine Kyoto has some kinda large park like Tokyo has in Harujuku or like NYC has Central Park? I can only imagine that's what they refer to.
- jpatokal 11y agoNope, none: https://goo.gl/maps/xqNfgRhCP9B2 https://goo.gl/maps/xqNfgRhCP9B2 But there are some comparatively green hills around it.
- damon_c 11y agoI once took the train from Tokyo to Kyoto. Shortly after arriving, I found myself deep in a bamboo forest within close walking distance from the train station.
- Nadya 11y agoHey now, don't forget the view from Kiyomizu! :P As far as the "old trope" they aren't entirely wrong. From top floor of HQ you should be able to see the hills and temples above the city. [0] http://youinjapan.net/kyoto/higashiyama/kiyomizudera_night_hanami_view.jpg http://youinjapan.net/kyoto/higashiyama/kiyomizudera_night_h...
- mahranch 11y agoMy buddy took this picture of his trip to Kyoto: https://tokyokawaiietc.files.wordpress.com/2009/01/kyoto-scenery5.jpg https://tokyokawaiietc.files.wordpress.com/2009/01/kyoto-sce... I would assume Kyoto is just like any city. However, my buddy did say he was amazed by the cleanliness of the city, so I think your picture is slightly exaggerating what Kyoto actually looks like.
- geomark 11y agoWhat is a Buddhist "priest"? It certainly isn't a Buddhist monk. While Buddhism may be a big part of his life, using some made up title like that seems like just an attempt to make him seem somehow larger.
- mbrock 11y agoJapanese Buddhism has many "priests," who are noncelibate, typically married. They are trained in various rites and may officiate weddings and funerals and tend to temples. I don't know what this man does in his priestly capacities, but you don't seem to be very well informed about Japanese Buddhism. The translation "priest" is very common.
- geomark 11y agoI am not well informed about Japanese Buddhism. My knowledge of Buddhism comes from having been a monk myself, ordained in the Theravada tradition. I do know about these "priests" having wives. That means they are not monks since celibacy is one of the foremost precepts of Buddhism. Other aspects of being a "householder" also preclude Inamori from being a monk. Based on your description it seems like the priest title is imported from other religions.
- mbrock 11y agoIt's an imported title because it's a translation. I don't know the Japanese word. Yes, he is not a monk, and nobody has claimed that he is. I don't really understand your point in saying that his religious status is "made up" because he's not a celibate monastic.
- geomark 11y agoMy misunderstanding. It sounded to me like the story was trying to make him larger than life by throwing in the title of Buddhist priest. I wasn't aware of that title - I thought they were implying he is monk. That's what I was reacting to.
- dismal2 11y agosounds like the ravings of an egomaniac
- anigbrowl 11y agoSeth Fischer, chief investment officer at [an investment fund], says this is an outmoded way of thinking and ignores the risk that KDDI’s business may founder. You get paid a dividend as your risk premium, and you're free to express your apprehensions by shorting the stock if you don't buy into the CEO's strategy, or simply selling it and buying something else. What gives you the right to demand any particular level of return on a stock?
- spainispain 11y agoThe monk who bought a Ferrari ;)
- ommunist 11y agoNever heard of a company where every employee works only when he or she wants, enjoys dividends, has a yacht in the Caribbean, and allows spouse unlimited shopping in Dubai.
- mironathetin 11y ago"It’s a view that carries weight because of Inamori’s success." This bloomberg sentence fits well to my understanding of many businesses: their leaders don't use their brains, they follow the crowd. The author does a puzzling thing: he asks us to follow the good example but then wants to point out the special approach of Inamori. What is the advice? Follow Inamori and do what too many businesses do (follow, don't think)? Or do something original (and don't care about what everybody does)? And what about statistics? Here is a report about one single success that worked and its leader tried to make his employees happy (perhaps both things are unrelated, tbp). That does not carry any weight, until there is a meaningful statistics about the success of leaders who did it like this. Currently, it is just another success story. Even the hen-egg example is broken and the author did not see it. Take it literally: do we care for hens? No, we torture them until they die early, take all their eggs and make a good profit. The hen is dead? Get another one, she'll lay eggs too. The farmers who care for their hens are the ones in trouble: they have to compete with much cheaper eggs. And who really understands or pays for quality? A minority!