4 ms·
I do not agree with the premise that taxation is necessary. Any given alternative to taxation might be worse, though. It also might be better. There are a lo
by logfromblammo 11y ago
I do not agree with the premise that taxation is necessary.
Any given alternative to taxation might be worse, though. It also might be better. There are a lot of ideas that already failed, and a lot that haven't yet been tried.
But none of the potentially better schemes can possibly work when you already accept taxation as axiomatic.
Of course, this doesn't mean that there is no value in attempting to determine a method of taxation that is least unfair. But given the variance in individual tastes, you may have to combine multiple models of fairness to come up with a reasonable basis for comparison.
If your tax scheme takes as much money from a person as it is possible to take without causing that person measurable harm, you're obviously going to be able to take a lot more from rich people than from poor people. But then, as everyone would end up with the same standard of living, you disincentivize excellence. So maybe you use a model drawn from psychological experiments with respect to reward-seeking behavior, and you give accomplishment above and beyond the lowest common denominator diminishing returns. Maybe someone who produces twice as much gets twice as much as their reward, but someone who produces ten times as much only gets five times as much reward. The studies on lever-pushing rats suggest that this would still work. Someone might even produce twenty times as much for only six times the reward.
- AnimalMuppet 11y ago> I do not agree with the premise that taxation is necessary. I can see very few alternatives. Either you believe that no government is necessary, or you believe that government can operate without money, or you believe that government can create the money it needs to operate (with minimal negative effects), or you believe that government can raise sufficient money from something other than taxes. (But if they raise money from anything other than voluntary contributions, it's pretty much a tax. I would consider tariffs to be taxes, for example - they're just a tax on foreign trade rather than income or property.) From what I recall of your posts, I think you take the first position - that no government is necessary. I strongly disagree, but here I will limit myself to saying that there is no evidence of this being possible. (Yes, there are plenty of examples of people cooperating without government being involved. Cooperating to the point that no government at all was needed anywhere in society? Not so much.)
- logfromblammo 11y agoI also take those other positions. Government is not strictly necessary. Government can operate without the same currency as is used in the non-government markets. Government can fund most of its core functions by creation of fiat currency. Government can be run on sources of revenue other than taxation. (Some of these implicitly assume a certain definition of "government". Some people might say that an organization that does not tax is not a government. Others may define the "governmentness" of an organization by different criteria. My definition allows for governments that cannot or do not tax.) That doesn't necessarily mean that any system that demonstrates such possibilities would be subjectively better than anything already seen in practice. So far, I am aware of no controlled experiment that has tested any those hypotheses. It might not even be possible to run one. Sometimes the answer to a yes-no question is "I don't know [yet]." I have no knowledge of the truth of the hypotheses. I don't know whether a taxing government is objectively necessary or not. The anecdotal historical evidence suggests that it is not, but also that any society that lacks a government tax is eventually undermined and overwhelmed by a society that has a tax. The tax funds warfare, either as military, economic, or both. If you don't contribute to professional soldiers or financiers voluntarily, your people get conquered, assimilated, indebted, or enslaved, and have to do it anyway. Aside from that, in most cases, it is reasonable to reason from a point where you assume one or more untested or untestable statements to be true, but you should be aware that you are not covering the entire problem space. Assuming that taxation is necessary, it should be possible to say that there exists a system of taxation that is most fair among all systems of taxation. But you cannot then say that is the fairest possible system, because you have not even investigated any system that does not employ taxation. So if you cannot imagine any such system for the purposes of comparison, your lack of imagination may indirectly be making the world less fair than it could be.