4 ms·
I hope for Lytro's sake that they release real open-source playback tools. AFAICT, if you have a first-generation Lytro camera right now, you're pretty much st
by amluto 11y ago
I hope for Lytro's sake that they release real open-source playback tools. AFAICT, if you have a first-generation Lytro camera right now, you're pretty much stuck viewing the pictures you take in a Flash app, and I'd be very hesitant to buy a camera of any sort that gives no real assurance that the picture format will still be usable in ten (or twenty or fifty) years.
Everyone has access to a JPEG decoder. Lytro, not so much.
- loceng 11y agoHopefully it's just a timing issue and not control play.
- msabalau 11y agoThey were founded in 2006, and their first generation cameras were being unloaded on Woot last year, and the there was a flash sale on their second generation yesterday. It'd be great if they finally recognized that a proprietary format was blocking their success, but...
- loceng 11y agoIt'd be great if they put some resources into this, I agree - and it would have helped to open up their platform.
- saidajigumi 11y ago> It'd be great if they finally recognized that a proprietary format was blocking their success, but... FWIW, I also think that Lytro has been seriously off the mark in how they market the output of their cameras: as weird black-boxes for end-viewers to play with. IMO, the idea that an audience of image viewers want to fiddle with the light-field knobs themselves (e.g. post-shot focus) is actively hurtful of Lytro's products. The holy grail here is a light field camera that obsoletes the need for focus the way that digital cameras have obsoleted the need for color filters used in B&W film photography[1]. Unfortunately, Lytro's first product was well before its time. Their tech didn't have adequate still-image resolution compared to even a halfway-decent phone camera, certainly not enough to make the focus vs quality tradeoff make much sense vs conventional cameras. Lytro's approach is worth comparing to Apple's Live Photos in the iPhone 6s. Live Photos clearly aren't for every shooting situation, but AFAICT, they're becoming quite popular for what I'll dub "affective photography": moments of kids, pets, friends, etc. We'll see how well this feature lasts past its novelty phase, but it's got a far better hook into what motivates end-users than Lytro has ever had. [1] A quick primer: colored filters were used with black and white film to change the relative contrast of different objects in the scene, e.g. sky vs skin tones vs grass, etc. A skillful photographer learned to look at the colors in a scene and pick a filter that would produce the desired B&W rendering. Converting color digital images to B&W allows these rendering decisions to be pushed into post, with more creative freedom than was ever possible with film (or the odd, rare B&W digital sensor).
- frankiejr 11y agoLytro switched away from Flash to a JPEG/JavaScript player in 2013, then to a WebGL player in late 2014. There were some open source player controls floating around last year but I can't recall the name. There were also some open source tools to extract the JPEG stack from the .LFP file as well, which you could use to build a player of your own. I worked at Lytro from 2012-2015 and we'd see occasional updates from those tools.
- amluto 11y agoHuh, guess I'm out of date here. Is it really a JPEG stack? I had assumed there was more magic (i.e. math and clever compression) than that. Or is a JPEG stack with extra fanciness? I'd love to read up on how this stuff actually works. I know how to calculate the theoretical information capacity in a light field (hint: very very dense) but basically nothing about how people manage to munge it into something compact and useful.
- dwaxe 11y agoAt its core, the viewer works by just averaging the JPEG stack at varying offsets as described in this student project: https://inst.eecs.berkeley.edu/~cs194-26/fa14/upload/files/proj6/cs194-dj/faizullabhoy_riyaz_proj6/ https://inst.eecs.berkeley.edu/~cs194-26/fa14/upload/files/p... I haven't looked into how they make everything efficient, but the source code for their flash viewer is here http://lightfield.stanford.edu/aperture.html http://lightfield.stanford.edu/aperture.html
- catbird 11y agoWell, the raw picture (light field) from the camera looks like something from an insect's eye - a hexagonal grid of tiny pictures saved into one giant jpeg [1]. The Lytro software processes that data into a stack of jpegs of reconstructed views at varying focal lengths when you first import the image. [1] see for example http://lightfield-forum.com/2012/07/lytro-hack-how-to-extract-data-and-jpg-files-from-the-lfp-file-format-using-lfpsplitter/ http://lightfield-forum.com/2012/07/lytro-hack-how-to-extrac...
- aaronsnoswell 11y ago