30 ms·
>>doesn't mean she's more valuable than anybody else That only makes my argument stronger, not weaker - if she's exactly the same member of the society as ever
by gambiting 11y ago
>>doesn't mean she's more valuable than anybody else
That only makes my argument stronger, not weaker - if she's exactly the same member of the society as everyone else, she should still pay the same percentage as everyone else.
The rest of your statements are nonsensical. She provides something that I want, so I trade my money for her product - the "quality" of the product has absolutely nothing to do with it. Just like I trade my time for my employer's money.
- coldtea 11y ago>if she's exactly the same member of the society as everyone else, she should still pay the same percentage as everyone else. Flat percentage is not a fair tax scheme. Equal doesn't always mean fair ( http://everydayfeminism.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/Untitled1-300x225.png http://everydayfeminism.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/Untit... ). E.g. 40% tax for someone making $1000 a month is a huge sum eating into his food, rent etc, but even 80% tax for someone making 100.000 a month leaves them with enough to live extremely luxuriously. >She provides something that I want, so I trade my money for her product - the "quality" of the product has absolutely nothing to do with it. The only reason you provide that much for her product is not it's cost or some inherent value you see it in, but an artificial constraint of distribution. If it was $0.2 or $1 per book you'd be equally happy to pay that instead of $10. It's like with recorded music -- the era where people made fortunes from it was just an accident of available reproduction techniques. Artists weren't paid for that before, and people stopped spending in the era of mp3 and youtube too.
- gambiting 11y ago>>The only reason you provide that much for her product is not it's cost or some inherent value you see it in, but an artificial constraint of distribution. If it was $0.2 or $1 per book you'd be equally happy to pay that instead of $10. So who exactly should decide how much something costs? Do you think the author should not control how much a copy of their book costs?
- coldtea 11y ago>So who exactly should decide how much something costs? Do you think the author should not control how much a copy of their book costs? No. I think competing publishing houses should print the book in different prices (any price each publishing house wishes), with a percentage of sales going to the author, and the market decides how high or low it goes. In the end, if not allowed to form a cartel, all publishers will reach a stable-ish price (differing only for different qualities of each edition, e.g. paper quality, hardcover, etc). Else, it's like we limit a reproductible work in an artificial way as if it was an one-off item, by granting sole pricing rights AND absolute control of its sales to the author.