3 ms·
Actually, because tax time is coming up, and I'm a citizen of Canada who has to file taxes in both the US and Canada, I've been doing the math on this, the "nat
by potatolicious 17y ago
Actually, because tax time is coming up, and I'm a citizen of Canada who has to file taxes in both the US and Canada, I've been doing the math on this, the "nationalized health care is more expensive" thing is really quite the myth (that I believed myself).
Firstly, there's the commonly known factoid that the US spends more per capita for health care than any other industrialized nation - in fact you guys pay more than 2x what Canada pays for each of its citizens. So health care, on an aggregate basis anyhow, is actually much more expensive in the USA than Canada.
Secondly is the burden on the individual - I did the taxes for what I would have to pay in taxes in Canada (if I had earned the income there), and the total comes out to about $2K more than my tax burden in the USA. Considering my insurance (employer-subsidized) is still some $100 a month, the difference becomes even less pronounced. Not to mention there's no such thing as a co-pay in Canada (my US insurance plan has mediocre co-pays). Put it all together and suddenly you wonder why America just can't take the money it's already paying and just create a public system where everyone gets care.
- cwan 17y agoAs a Canadian, that's the bizarre thing I've found about the American system. The US spends more per capita on Medicare than Canadians do on healthcare - you'd think they would want to try to fix that before they tried to "extend coverage" and force everyone to participate in a public system. I should point out further though that the Canadian model is less than sustainable. As I've mentioned to others in the past, it took me over 6 months to book a physical and unless you know people access to specialists is a very lengthy wait.
- hga 17y agoAs cwan points out, access to a waiting list is not access to health care. When you ignore easily gamed statistics like life expectancy and look at things like cancer survival rates, you see that we seem to be getting something for the extra money we're spending. And we're a rich nation, it would hardly be odd for us to choose to spend a lot there. And for now, there are choices. At times I've had minimal health insurance, e.g. catastrophic illness or injury was covered but not my occasional sinus infection.
- pbz 17y agoTalking about gamed statistics: only those who received treatment are counted. While it's true that the US medical system has the highest rating for providing the right treatment is has the lowest rating for accessibility. Does it really matter how good the treatment is if you can't get it? http://www.commonwealthfund.org/Content/Publications/Fund-Reports/2007/May/Mirror--Mirror-on-the-Wall--An-International-Update-on-the-Comparative-Performance-of-American-Healt.aspx http://www.commonwealthfund.org/Content/Publications/Fund-Re...
- hga 17y agoI'm impressed: a study that ranks the US #1 in "right care", meaning "effective care", but ends up giving the U.K. the #1 position in overall quality with the US and Canada as 5 and 6. Right.... (Well, I'll believe that Canada deserves a low ranking :-). Now, that doesn't address your point about access, but I can't put too much weight in the study.
- pbz 17y agoIf you get to pick your patients of course it's much easier to rank first...
- potatolicious 17y agoI don't really see the point in continuing this: you've already made up your mind about the validity of public vs. private health care. If any claims are made without numbers, you will demand numbers; when numbers are provided, you will claim they are gamed, skewed, or otherwise misinterpreted. The relevant information is there - and from my experiences and wait time in the ER yesterday I cannot say I'm terribly impressed by the availability of your medical system. It wasn't a particularly busy night, but wait times were about equal to what I'd expect in Canada. I've met many other expats from nationalized-healthcare countries who have lived in the US (some for well over a decade), and I've yet to meet a single one that doesn't regard America's health care system as some kind of barbarism.
- 17y ago