5 ms·
Hypothetically, if there are sentient critters composed of dark matter, would black holes be a total mystery to them? Since we only really interact with dark ma
by pavel_lishin 11y ago
Hypothetically, if there are sentient critters composed of dark matter, would black holes be a total mystery to them? Since we only really interact with dark matter gravitationally, would they just see inexplicable gravitational point-masses with absolutely nothing there to cause them?
- anon4 11y agoAre there no dark matter black holes?
- jerf 11y agoTheoretically, any sufficient concentration of mass-energy creates a black hole. Theoretically, even light alone can create a black hole: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kugelblitz_%28astrophysics%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kugelblitz_%28astrophysics%29 Realistically, without the interaction of electromagnetism to create enough drag for gravity to be able to cause large clumps, it seems as unlikely that dark matter formed a black hole as light did.
- Udo 11y agoSince we have no idea what dark matter is, it's unknown how it interacts with black holes. If it is really a form of actual matter, it can become part of a black hole like anything else in the universe. Whatever its nature, a sufficient point-like concentration of dark matter will certainly create an object with the properties of a black hole, but it's unclear at this time whether dark matter even comes in the shape of point sources, or if there is anything "there" to fall into an existing black hole. We just don't know. Most physicists believe dark matter is just a type of particle, and if that turns out to be correct, its interaction with black holes will be exactly like with any other particle.
- jerf 11y agoWell... isn't that what black holes look like to us, too? We don't "see" anything there to cause them either.
- pavel_lishin 11y agoBut we can infer that there used to be a star there, and we can infer what the mechanism is that creates them; we also "see" immense electric fields sometimes, and we see accretion disks and other things. The dark-matter-critters would see literally none of that; they'd only realize anything was amiss if they saw gravitational lensing of their stars (if they even have light) or felt tides when someone happened to pass near one.
- yk 11y agoAs much as they are for us. Dark matter is matter that only reacts to us via gravity, so the effect of a black hole which also only acts via gravity^1 is the same for them as for us. ^1 I am ignoring charged black holes here, because astronomical black holes should be basically uncharged and my intuition is, that if there is some kind of dark charge, then the black hole could also be charged under that force.
- biswaroop 11y agoThey would still 'see' gravitationally active stars turning into black holes. They would infer a form of anomalous radiation from seeing the stars collapsing, and they would guess that there are other fields that interact with this other form of matter.
- pavel_lishin 11y agoThat's assuming that there are DM stars in the same place that our stars are (which is probably a safe assumption to make, if DM stars exist at all.)
- biswaroop 11y agoNo, I'm referring to real matter stars. DM critters would see the gravitation from real stars, and would watch them implode into black holes.
- ars 11y agoA particle that interacts only with gravity can not make a star.
- pavel_lishin 11y agoI'm hypothesizing that dark matter can interact with itself, just as our matter can interact with itself.
- ars 11y agoIt's more complicated than that. Think about it from an energy point of view - if it interacts with something it makes (transforms) energy. Where does that energy go? Normal particles get hot and make blackbody radiation, i.e. photons. Dark matter can't. Does it have a temperature? Can temperature flow between the particles? Without blackbody radiation you are going to have some violations of the laws of thermodynamics. Unless dark matter has some other particle to act as an equivalent. So you are hypothesizing an entire family of dark matter particles, and a whole set of new forces. Two entire universes each with entire sets of particles, that only interact via gravity. We could have a second sun and a second earth, that overlap us and never know it, we would just think that the gravitational constant is different (because our perceived mass is higher). Sounds like a wonderful setting for a science fiction/horror story.
- Udo 11y agoEverything about the universe as we see it would be a mystery to them, because the only way of them interacting with our universe is through gravity. But if you see it from our side, to us dark matter is just an incomprehensible field of gravity with no known source as well. So their perception could be absolutely identical to ours. This opens up a wild but entertaining hypothesis. Assume we have two universes, one of which is ours, and both are located very "close" to one another (whatever that means, maybe it's the next Brane over or something). Our dark matter could just be gravitation leaking out from that other universe. It would certainly explain why there is no other interaction. It would also explain why gravity is such a weak force (because it's leaking out). And our gravitational hotspots would in turn have the same effect on their matter.
- SolarNet 11y agoIt would also explain the amounts of normal matter and dark matter (4.9% normal, 26.8% dark), there could be a couple of universes that are close to a given universe (like ours). I'd be curious what sort of geometric configurations (along with equations) would lead to ~5.47 universes worth of gravity to leak through to each universe.
- gizmo686 11y agoAssuming the leaking hypothesis, the exact amount that is leaking into our universe wouldn't have any particularly meaningfull reason, in the same way that we now understand that their is no particular reason behind the distance between the Earth and the Sun.
- pavel_lishin 11y agoBut can't we infer a lot about the formation of the Solar System from the masses of the planets and their current orbits? One could argue that the particular reason we're here is because Jupiter swept the Solar System of most of its dangerous asteroids.
- ars 11y ago> Hypothetically, if there are sentient critters composed of dark matter You can't. Particles that interact only via gravity can't "do" anything. Unless you theorize there is some other force that only affects dark matter. If the only force is gravity then dark matter particles can "overlap" without interacting, so you would have huge clouds of particles orbiting and passing through each other for eternity since they have no friction they have no ability to transform velocity into other forms of energy. Since they are eternally in free fall they can detect nothing whatsoever. Occasionally some ordinary mass would go by and move their orbits and they would not be able to tell since you can not feel gravity when in free fall. > would they just see inexplicable gravitational point-masses with absolutely nothing there to cause them? You can not see gravity directionally, so you can not see points with more, or less, gravity. You can't even detect the sum total of gravity affecting you since it will just make you accelerate, which you can not detect if over things nearby are also accelerating. You can only detect gravity that is countered by some other force. All the gravitational detection we do is by detecting particles via light, not via gravity.
- pavel_lishin 11y ago> You can't. Particles that interact only via gravity can't "do" anything. Unless you theorize there is some other force that only affects dark matter. There was a story here not too long ago about the possibility of a Dark QCD - meaning that it's possible that Dark Matter interacts among itself just fine, in ways similar to the way that we do. (Meaning that it's not just one type of invisible garbage mass out there.) > All the gravitational detection we do is by detecting particles via light, not via gravity. Yup; I meant that if there is a Dark QCD, which means some sort of Dark Matter chemistry (and probably a Dark Matter light), they'd be able to observe the effects of gravity in the same ways that we do - by seeing gravitational lensing (of Dark Light), or by observing orbits, or by observing tides from fly-bys.